Chapter 2
Back in the Lab, Leaf was greeted by an enthusiastic Eevee rubbing against her leg. Using Eevee for research was almost a cliché, but it really was a useful species to study; it's not like Leaf was only doing it for the aesthetic. (Although, like most Pokemon researchers, she wore a lab coat while working even if it wasn't strictly necessary.)
Leaf's current study was asking the question 'What makes Pokemon species different from one another?' which sounds like a simple or even obvious question at first. The crux of it was: if you had two Pokemon with the same stats, same moveset, same type, same nature, but of different species, then what
makes them different beyond what they look like?
She sat on a wheeled stool and patted a tabletop to beckon the Eevee to jump up, which it did. On the desk were various gadgets, only a couple of which would be recognisable to the layperson, such as a pokédex. A drawer which had been removed from its cabinet on the desk, it was pushed back against the wall and was lined with racks of technical machines, and beside it was a case with some evolution stones - visible through the glass but locked shut just in case. Above the Eevee whirred a circular device which was seemingly scanning the Pokemon.
"You have a jolly nature, you were hatched in Pallet Town," she said, apparently interpreting a stream of numbers which were appearing on a monitor hanging above the desk, "and if you were a Wurmple, you'd evolve into a Cascoon."
She swivelled to the side to access a keyboard and typed out a few lines of code. Upon pressing enter, a pokéball appeared in a slot beside the keyboard. Leaf pressed its button to release the Venonat contained inside. The Pokemon was directed to sit next to the Eevee and the two were given a bowl of treats to munch on while the machines around them did their work.
"You're... 91% identical." Leaf said while reading the numbers off the computer again, more to herself than to the Pokemon in front of her. She pushed herself away and wheeled over to another desk, and retrieved something blue from its drawers before rolling back over to the workstation. She unwrapped a small pellet from the blue wrapper and placed it with the treats in the Venonat's bowl. "94%" she said, a few moments after it had been ingested.
It was clear to anyone with a cursory knowledge of Pokémon that different species generally had different stats; the average Ponyta would be faster than a Slowpoke. While measuring these 'base stats' was quite difficult to do precisely, it was possible. Leaf was looking beyond that though, and was interested in more fundamental differences.
She spent the rest of the afternoon compiling data from her test subjects, writing proof-of-concept scripts using the Nohtyp programming language to run more efficient comparisons between simulated Pokémon, and committing some of those changes to the server clusters she was renting in Veilstone City, which were running trillions of those comparisons for her every day.
Her work for the day almost done, all Leaf had left to do was wait for some test results to come back and then she could close up shop. To keep herself occupied during the wait, she boiled a kettle and poured herself some tea (decaf, since it was getting late) and started browsing Haxorus News. This was becoming a habit of hers; the website often had interesting or amusing stories set right in the intersection between technology and Pokémon, which was directly relevant to her interests.
She scrolled through the news feed, as usual there were a few headlines which made her smile to herself. 'I gave my Jolteon a nickname containing nonstandard characters' read one. 'Getting a Rotom Pokédex to scan itself' was another.
Just then, one of the links caught her attention: 'I caught a Tauros on Cinnabar Island.' The link was to a StaryuTube video of someone making the same claim as in the title, and scanning his Pokémon with multiple pokédexes which all confirmed the first-caught location to be the same. The comments on Haxorus News were sceptical but willing to give the benefit of the doubt that the video was not fake, suggesting ideas on how the pokédex software might have a bug, or how a Tauros could have made it to the island.
Leaf had a think about this herself. It had been over a decade since the island was abandoned due a cataclysmic volcanic eruption, so it would be unlikely that a trainer released any Pokémon there, or that one had survived all that time since. She was one of the foremost experts in how the pokédex worked, so if there was a chance it was a hoax enabled by faulty pokédexes, she'd be the one with the knowhow to prove it.
Cinnabar was also only a short surf away from Pallet Town, so it certainly wouldn't be difficult for her to meet up with this individual, she thought. Looking on the video description she saw that he was a tourist from Johto, which still wasn't too far away. She sent him a direct message and suggested she could help confirm his claim if it was true, and asked to see the Tauros herself.
Surprisingly, she received a response before she closed the lab. The man who called himself Joey sounded enthusiastic and suggested they could meet in Viridian or Saffron cities, the two cities most easily accessible from Johto. After a couple of messages more, they had arranged to meet in Viridian the following weekend.
The day arrived, and Leaf sat in a café overlooking the main crossroads in Viridian City. If someone approached from the west she'd see him coming straight away, although at the moment the only person there was the young woman who taught new trainers how to catch Pokémon; she had taken over from her grandfather who had grown too old for the job.
"Yo, Leaf, finally taking a break from your work?" came a familiar voice from behind her.
"You could call it that." She replied, not turning to look at her friend Blue. He walked to the other side of the table and she briefly explained to him what she was doing.
"That sounds like work to me. You need to learn the chill out more." He took a swig from his coffee after he said this. Leaf felt a little annoyed, he was still standing up so he was
literally looking down on her. How someone like him could become a gym leader she never knew.
"This is what I find fun."
"Well, don't forget to pop in on your old pals once in a while. Smell ya later." He left the building, and and before the door closed someone else entered. A man who looked a little younger than Leaf, and wore very casual clothes: a baseball cap, a T-shirt, and shorts. He approached Leaf.
"Hello, you're Professor Green?"
"Yes, but please just call me Leaf. You must be Joey, nice to meet you." She stood up and offered a handshake, which he took, and she then gestured for him to take the other seat at her table.
"Hi Leaf. I've brought my Pokémon, just like you asked." Said Joey, motioning to show the three pokéballs he had on his belt. "I've always thought each of my Pokémon were special, but this one especially so." He unclipped one of them and placed it on the table. Not wasting any time, Leaf brought out her pokédex and scanned it.
"You're right. Caught on Cinnabar Island, how curious. Hmm..." She sat back and pondered for a few moments. "While I'm thinking of where to go next, would you like to order something while you're here? It's my treat since I invited you here - though I've already had something myself." She offered him a ₽500 note before he got up to go to the counter, though he declined it.
She scanned the pokéball again with her phone's pokédex app - less precise than her specialist pokédex but only to confirm it got the same readings. Either there was something odd about this Pokémon that was causing pokédexes to misread it, possibly due to an oversight in its code, or it really was caught on an a deserted island dozens of miles across the ocean from its usual habitat. Due to her expertise, she was hoping it was the former option; not because she wanted there to be an as-of-yet undiscovered issue with the technology, but because if there
was one she'd enjoy the satisfaction of understanding and fixing it. If it turned out to be the latter possibility, well it wasn't more
boring per se, just not a mystery she would necessarily be equipped to solve. After a couple of minutes, Joey returned to the table with a cup of tea and a packet of Pokémon treats.
"So you were holidaying in Kanto when you caught this fellow?" Leaf asked, cautiously trying not to accuse him of lying about his experience. "Did you catch any other Pokémon while you were here?"
"No. I wasn't really intending to," he replied after taking a sip of his tea, "just travelling and doing touristy things like visiting landmarks and buying souvenirs. I did go to the safari zone since that's one of the things all the Kanto guidebooks says you should do, but I didn't have any luck seeing any rare Pokémon. So I moved on to the next thing on my list of things to see: the Cinnabar volcano. I flew straight there on my Noctowl and while I was walking around the beach I saw my Tauros."
"Do you have your Noctowl with you today?" She asked. Joey retrieved another of his pokéballs and displayed it in his hand. Leaf scanned it. "Oh wow, you weren't joking when you said your Pokémon are special," she said, noticing that the Noctowl had a rare mutation that causes it to have different coloured feathers, "it's silver."
"I know, right?" he replied, unable to hide his pride.
"Well, I asked because if you're able to fly around today I'd like to take you to Pallet Town to do some more thorough scans on Tauros, or we could go to Cinnabar and you could show me the spot where you found it. If you're happy with either."
"I'm free all weekend. If it helps reaffirm how special my Tauros is I'll go along with you."
The two chatted for a while about their plans. They'd go to Pallet first and once Leaf had looked over the Tauros more thoroughly she'd pick up her Fly-knowing Pokémon and they'd go do Cinnabar together. And so after a short bus ride through Route 1, Leaf showed her guest inside the lab.
"There's a ranch out the back, you can let your Tauros out to roam there, but first I'd like to do some scans. Feel free to let your other Pokémon out too."
As they passed the living area for the Pokémon in the lab, Joey let out his Raticate to allow it to join in with an Eevee and Venonat that were playing together. Leaf continued showing Joey the basics of the lab.
"This here is my Pokémon monitor, it displays far more information about a Pokémon than the Pokédex can at a glance. It's currently showing details of that Venonat. If you'll allow me-" she pointed a dish-shaped apparatus in the direction of Joey's Raticate which was rolling around with the others, "see, the number here which represents the species has decreased by about thirty, which makes sense." She paused for a second. "Wow. Your Raticate's IVs - its natural potential - are almost perfect."
"Top percentage!" Joey declared.
"Let's let your Tauros out." Joey did as he was asked and let it out in the stable-like area nearby. Leaf redirected the scanning apparatus once more. "No different from what the Pokédex said." She said matter-of-factly. She wasn't sure whether she was disappointed, or even what she expected.
Joey watched his Raticate play in the pen while Leaf continued to do whatever she was doing on her computer. She wasn't long, and then she grabbed a worn notebook and a pokéball from inside of of her desks.
"Ready to go to Cinnabar now?" She asked Joey. He confirmed and they stepped outside and mounted their Noctowl and Pidgeotto. It was a sunny day with very little wind, so they faced no resistance on their flight to the volcanic island.
Once there, Leaf retrieved a map from her old notebook. It was one of many maps she used from when she went on her Pokémon journey, and had "property of Daisy Oak" written on the back and the pre-eruption layout of the island on the front. Joey lead her to the spot where he claimed he found the Tauros.
"The eastern shore, hmm." Leaf pondered. There were lots of places of interest on the island but this wasn't one of them. She had done some reading up on the island but only found stories of lots of Tentacool washing up on the beach when people landed there from Seafoam Islands. "The closest building to here would have been the old gym, which was built into the side of the volcano. If it came from the mansion or the lab that used to be here, I'd have expected it to be on the western side." Of course, both of those buildings had long been in ruins, the only building left standing was the Pokémon centre which had been repaired and kept active for trainers visiting Seafoam gym. Leaf crouched down and took out her pokédex.
"I'm scanning for traces of Pokémon DNA. Maybe if there's anything left we can pick up its trail and work out where it came from." Joey just stood there watching as Leaf did her thing. She scanned around patches of the beach, which was dark grey due to the heavy concentration of ash in the sand. "Lots of water-types have been around here. But no traces of your Tauros I'm afraid. That's not to say I don't believe you, though." She sighed.
"I'm going to have a nosy around the Pokémon centre next. I might be a while, sorry for dragging you around just for everything to come up inconclusive."
"It's alright, it's all in the interest of science, right? If it's alright, I'll go and visit some places in Kanto I didn't have time for last time. Meet you back here in an hour?"
And so they agreed. Leaf entered the Pokémon centre and asked the resident Nurse Joy if anything had happened on the island recently, and she looked bemused.
"This is one of the most boring stations for a Pokémon centre. I
wish things happened here." Before Leaf had a chance to ask her next question she spoke up again and bowed slightly. "Not that I want people to bring in more injured Pokémon, of course."
Leaf's next point of call was the PC, which was standard in every Pokémon centre. She logged in and made sure she still had her privileged access; as part of her research Bill had given her a special account when accessing PCs that let her see more technical details about the Pokémon being handled. She couldn't see other people's Pokémon due to data protection standards, but Pokémon that had been released didn't tend to fall under that category. She opened up a log file and entered a search query for any Pokémon released from this PC. No luck, there had only been one Pokémon released from this location and it was a Goldeen. There were no logs from before the eruption either, probably due to the PC being replaced.
The only thing left for her to do was to sit at a table and read through her notes from her Pokémon journey. She remembered encountering wild Pokémon in the mansion which was abandoned even back then, but not which specific species were there. She had started keeping a diary on her 10th birthday and had continued the habit to this day. This particular notebook covered the latter half of her journey, beginning in Saffron City and covering her eventual victory over the Elite Four, and continuing on for a few months after that.
She flicked through the book and found mentions of Cinnabar just less than half way though. A feeling of nostalgia flowed over her as she read over details she had since forgotten: The door to the gym was locked and a series of riddles left by Blaine lead her to believe the key was in the mansion building. The lab on the island was experimenting with resurrecting Pokémon from fossils. She met up with Bill after defeating the gym to go to the Sevii Islands. A lot more happened there than she remembered, but it was the day she spent rooting around the mansion that she was most interested in.
As expected, most of the Pokémon she listed as having seen in the abandoned building were fire-types. Aside from those, she saw Koffing, Raticate, and Ditto. That last Pokémon she distinctly remembered encountering because of how alien it seemed. It didn't fit with everything else. Cinnabar was a volcanic island so it made sense for Pokemon related to fire and smoke to find their habitat there. Raticate was a scavenger and finding them in urban environments isn't unexpected either. She continued reading her notes. Ditto was only found in the secret basement, from what she could glean from her own writing. There were other people's diaries left in the building about finding the mythical Pokémon Mew. Being so young at the time she was in awe of these notes and wholeheartedly believed them. Now, though, she reckoned that was set-dressing for the game Blaine liked to set up for his prospective challengers. It was effective entertainment, given how excited it made her younger self feel.
She continued reading. It mentioned lots of strange machines in the basement. There weren't many details, but she wondered if she'd be able to understand what they were for now that she was a scientist herself. She read about how just before finding the key to the gym she picked up the TM for solarbeam. She remembered that, it was in a room full of plants with no windows. Maybe they were doing experiments with artificial sunlight, she thought.
Before long, Leaf realised it was coming up to an hour since she parted with Joey so she made her way to the front of the Pokémon centre to be ready for his return.
"...eaf. Leaf!" A man's voice was coming from outside. The automatic doors opened and Joey stood at the entrance. "Come quick!"
The two made their way over the rocky terrain back towards the eastern shore of the island. "I just flew back here and decided to check out the same spot again before meeting back up. It happened again. Look."
And lo and behold, Leaf saw what Joey was pointing at: a Doduo was walking around on the ashy beach, looking lost.
"They're flightless, right!?" Joey asked, catching his breath.
"Yes. They are."
Chapter 2
Battling Creatures
Battling has long been one of the first things people think about when the topic of Pokémon is brought up. Before we could catch them, before we even domesticated Pokémon as pets, people used to encounter wild Pokémon and watch them (often baiting them into) battle and bet on which one they thought would emerge victorious. Once the smaller or more tame species were domesticated people would get them to battle each other in a similar fashion, although watching the more ferocious species in the wild still drew spectators. Eventually, as we all know, the pokéball was invented and stronger and stronger Pokémon became tamable.
From the onset, people knew that knowledge about the Pokémon involved in a battle was key to winning the gambling games they were engaging in. While it was generally advantageous to keep this information to oneself, some things were so apparent that it was common knowledge and not worth being coy about. These included:
- The more battles a Pokémon had previously won, the more likely it was to win future battles.
- Some Pokémon species had an innate advantage when paired against other species (e.g. a Bellsprout against a Goldeen).
- In addition to paying attention to the species of a Pokémon, you also needed to keep track of the repertoire of attacks or moves it employed.
The first point was dubbed the experience level, a feature of individual Pokémon. Some people argued that it wasn't winning battles that caused a Pokémon to get stronger, but rather a Pokémon that was already strong won a lot of battles and would, therefore, also win future battles. This was quickly proven to be a false assumption, however; a strong Pokémon can be defined as being able to defeat its opponent with a single attack, or to overcome a type disadvantage. It can easily be observed that the more battles a Pokémon wins, the more it becomes strong according to that definition.
The knowledge that those Pokémon with higher experience levels went on to be more successful battlers is what caused the Pokémon
trainer to emerge as a profession. People wanted to win their bets, and a good bet was on the more experienced Pokémon.Over time, of course, people stopped battling for gambling reasons and instead did it for its own sake. It is an interesting history lesson to know that the custom of paying prize money to the winner of a battle wasn't a natural consequence of competition, but a holdover from betting games.
The second point can be split into several factors, but the most prominent one is the Pokémon's type, a feature of the species. A Bellsprout is part Grass-type, and as such it has an advantage over the Water-type Goldeen. Many types of Pokémon have been known since ancient times, the oldest ones being those that correspond to the classical elements; Water, Fire, Ground, and Flying. Whether the theory of the classical elements came first or was based on pre-existing theory of Pokémon types is still debated among scholars. What we do know is that tables were formulated very early on describing which types match up well against others. Indeed, one of the earliest clay tablets archaeologists have ever uncovered has an example of such a table engraved on it.
Over time, more types were codified, and many Pokémon were recategorised as being dual-type. That is, having two types rather than just one. Take note that I hesitate to say the types were
discovered. It's not inaccurate to say so, but I would stress that types (among most features of a Pokémon's species) are are model which we use to describe what we see; they are not strictly
real in a physical sense. For comparison, my name is Leaf - but my name has no physical presence on or within by body; it's just a word used to communicate to someone you're talking about that one scientist who wears loose socks. I would still exist if I had no name, just as Pokémon would still be weak or strong against one another if we didn't describe the type-patterns we see.
I can already hear objections claiming that the model perfectly describes Pokémon matchups, and as such surely exists in some sense. As models go, it is very successful, but I am keen to stress that it is still a model. We thought we had a complete model before we extended it to include Fairy in the last century. Furthermore, there are always exceptions to rules predicted to our models; why do evolution stones not correspond one-to-one with these types? Why is the Ice-type move Freeze Dry super effective against Water-type Pokémon?
That brings us finally to the third point: a Pokémon's moveset. The pool of moves a Pokémon
can learn or has the potential to learn is a feature of its species, but the set of four moves it can currently use is a feature of the individual Pokémon.
Moves differentiate themselves by the effect they have in battle (and sometimes outside of one). These include the damage they deal (if any), changes they make to any Pokémon's stats, accuracy or probability of succeeding, status conditions they inflict, to name a few. The most basic property of a move is its type, which we describe using the same 18 types we use to describe Pokémon. We do not describe any moves as of yet as dual-type, and a Pokémon may learn some moves that are of a type other than its own.
We are so used to knowing these basic facts - that a Pokémon has a type and can learn a moves and those moves have types independent of the Pokémon's - that we take them for granted, but it stands to reason that we didn't always know and there must have been a period where people first realised these things. Part and parcel of being a scientist is asking
why and wondering how else things could be, so I find it helpful to look back at those times and ponder how those revelations came about.
These days, we have mathematical formulae that accurately describe how much damage an attack will do; if we don't know what move a Pokémon used, we can look at the damage and solve backwards for the move's
base power. Back when battling as a sport was in its infancy, people didn't have access to details of a Pokémon's stats, so how did they know if an attack used by a Pokémon was Tackle or Body Slam? This was before they had a list of possible moves to compare against, even. The answer is that they just observed and over time developed an intuition. This folk knowledge was passed down over the generations and became familiar to people today even outside of the spheres of Pokémon trainers or researchers.
Most fields of research into Pokémon follow this similar pattern of knowledge being attained naturally over time by professionals or hobbyists, and gradually became standardised over time until we end up with the formal science we have today. It will be the same story for a Pokémon's stats, which we will cover in the the next chapter. I will try to tell that tale without repetition.