• Welcome to The Cave of Dragonflies forums, where the smallest bugs live alongside the strongest dragons.

    Guests are not able to post messages or even read certain areas of the forums. Now, that's boring, don't you think? Registration, on the other hand, is simple, completely free of charge, and does not require you to give out any personal information at all. As soon as you register, you can take part in some of the happy fun things at the forums such as posting messages, voting in polls, sending private messages to people and being told that this is where we drink tea and eat cod.

    Of course I'm not forcing you to do anything if you don't want to, but seriously, what have you got to lose? Five seconds of your life?

Morphic Character Analysis - Understanding the Psychology of Mia Kerrigan

M0lot0v97

New member
Pronoun
he/him
Did you know that empathy is not actually one singular ability? That there are multiple ways a person can understand, recognize, and respond to the emotions of others? While some people can instinctively feel what another person is feeling, others may have to consciously recognize and interpret those emotions before they can understand them. And perhaps more importantly, just because someone doesn't emotionally respond to another person's suffering in the conventional way doesn't necessarily mean they don't care.

This is something I think is particularly important when discussing fictional characters who are often described as Psychopaths or Sociopaths. Especially when their behavior doesn't necessarily line up with what those terms actually entail. While it can certainly be easy to mistake someone who is emotionally detached or socially unusual for someone who is inherently malicious, there is a pretty significant difference between lacking an emotional response and lacking the capacity to care about another person. Today, I'd like to revisit one of my favorite characters from the works of Dragonfree; the cold-minded Half-Scyther named Mia Kerrigan of Morphic.

For a quick background, especially for those who have not seen my previous thread on the eponymous character, Mia Kerrigan is a Pokemorph belonging to the world of Morphic. A story taking place in an alternate take on the Pokemon World, where Pokemon are treated more like actual animals and the existence of Pokemorphs is the result of genetic experimentation. A team of bio-engineers for Heywood Labs successfully create eight children whose DNA is spliced with various Pokemon. These children would inherit certain physical and behavioral characteristics from their respective species, with Mia being one of the more interesting examples.

As a Half-Scyther, Mia possesses a number of physical attributes associated with her species. Green horns, blades emerging from her forearms, wings incapable of supporting her weight, and a generally green exterior on her forelegs and feet. However, what makes her particularly interesting is how much of her species' behavior appears to have carried over into her psychology.

Scyther are described as cold, calculating, and ruthless creatures. A species that operates almost entirely on logic, with very little consideration for emotional responses. That they are essentially psychopathic by nature, being capable of understanding another point of view without necessarily caring about it.

And while Mia certainly displays some of these characteristics, I don't believe that calling her a Psychopath or Sociopath actually does her character justice. In fact, I would argue that her behavior is considerably more complicated than that.

The Question of Psychopathy and Sociopathy

Before we get into the more specific aspects of Mia's personality, I think it's important to establish what we're actually talking about when we use these terms.

Psychopathy and Sociopathy are often used interchangeably in popular media. However, neither is an official standalone psychiatric diagnosis. The closest recognized diagnosis in modern clinical practice would be Antisocial Personality Disorder, or ASPD. This is a condition associated with a persistent pattern of disregarding and violating the rights of others. This can include repeated unlawful behavior, deceitfulness, impulsivity, aggression, reckless disregard for safety, irresponsibility, and a lack of remorse. While Mia certainly displays some concerning behavior, I don't believe she meets enough of these characteristics to justify that particular interpretation.
For one, Mia isn't particularly deceptive. If anything, she seems almost incapable of understanding why someone would deliberately lie about something when they could simply tell the truth. She is remarkably straightforward in her conversations, even when the things she says are uncomfortable or socially inappropriate. She also doesn't appear to be particularly impulsive. Despite her occasional aggressive behavior, Mia generally approaches situations with a considerable amount of deliberation. She evaluates circumstances, considers possible outcomes, and makes decisions based on what she believes to be the most effective course of action. Her violent tendencies are certainly concerning, but violence by itself does not establish an antisocial personality pattern. Nor do a majority of her "violent" actions emerge without initial antagonism.

Another important consideration is her age. Mia is still a child throughout much of the main storyline, between the ages of nine and ten specifically, and personality development is an ongoing process. ASPD cannot be diagnosed in children, and a diagnosis in adulthood requires a history of conduct disorder before the age of fifteen.

Now, does that mean Mia has absolutely no concerning psychological characteristics? Of course not. But I think there's a distinction between having certain traits that resemble those associated with psychopathy and actually possessing the broader personality pattern. From everything else we've seen, Mia seems to have considerably more going on than simply being incapable of caring about other people.

Cognitive Empathy and the Ability to Understand Others

One of the biggest misconceptions surrounding Mia is that she cannot understand other people's emotions. I don't believe this is particularly accurate.

In fact, one of the more interesting demonstrations of her psychological abilities comes from "Dave and Mia Discuss Hotdogs." During their conversation, Dave gives Mia several photographs and asks her to identify the emotions being displayed by the people in them. Rather than immediately dismissing the task, Mia carefully examines each image and attempts to determine what the people are feeling. What makes this particularly interesting is that she doesn't simply recognize the emotions themselves. She is able to provide surprisingly detailed descriptions of the expressions and the circumstances surrounding them.

This is a pretty significant distinction.

Cognitive empathy is the ability to understand another person's emotional state from an intellectual perspective. It involves recognizing emotional cues, interpreting facial expressions, and understanding why someone might feel a particular way. Emotional empathy, on the other hand, involves actually experiencing or sharing some of those feelings yourself. These are two different abilities, and someone can possess one without necessarily possessing the other to the same degree.

Mia appears to demonstrate considerable cognitive empathy. She can recognize what someone is feeling, understand why they might be feeling that way, and even make predictions about how they might behave as a result. We see this again when she recognizes the individual responsible for Brian's death through his facial expressions and behavioral patterns. Her ability to identify the culprit isn't necessarily a matter of intuition or emotional instinct. It's an exercise in observation and deduction.

This is something I think people overlook when discussing her. Mia doesn't necessarily need to experience someone else's emotions to understand them. She can simply observe, process, and interpret the information available to her. Of course, this doesn't mean she's incapable of making mistakes. Her understanding of certain social situations is still limited, and she can occasionally misunderstand the intentions of others. That, however, is hardly exclusive to Mia. Especially when this is something that can happen to even the more normative folk by our standards.

Compassionate Empathy and the Capacity to Care

Now, this is where I think things become considerably more interesting.

Because while Mia's ability to emotionally empathize with others seems rather limited, I don't believe that necessarily translates into an inability to demonstrate compassion. Compassionate Empathy is the ability to recognize that someone is suffering and feel motivated to do something about it. Mia very well demonstrates this more than once. Perhaps the best example comes from her interactions with Dave. Despite knowing that Dave is afraid of her, he is one of the few people who consistently makes an effort to interact with her. He talks to her, takes her places, answers her questions, and generally treats her like a person rather than some biological abnormality.

Mia clearly appreciates this.

She enjoys his company, values his opinions, and seems to genuinely look forward to their conversations. Even when there isn't anything particularly interesting to discuss, she still wants to spend time with him. Also important to mention, if Chapter 9.5 is anything to go by, her attachment to Dave goes considerably deeper than simple convenience. She openly expresses her willingness to protect him, even going as far as suggesting that anyone who attempts to hurt him would have to deal with her.Now, admittedly, Mia's approach to this is rather blunt. She doesn't necessarily express concern in the way someone else might. The intention, however, is still there.

She wants Dave to be safe. She wants him to be happy, and she wants to be there for him. This becomes even more apparent in the alternate-universe extra "Dave and Mia Discuss Family." For context, this takes place in a timeline where the events surrounding Jean's survival turn out differently, leaving Dave in an absolutely miserable state following the loss of his family and friends. Mia notices this almost immediately. Rather than simply acknowledging that Dave is upset and leaving him alone, she actively tries to improve his circumstances.

She points out that he's neglecting his health, refusing to work, and won't even afford his drinking vice at the rate he is going. She recognizes that he's isolating himself and that his current behavior is doing him no favors. Though what really stands out is her decision to physically comfort him. She places her hand against his and explains that human contact releases stress-relieving hormones. It's a rather clinical explanation for what is otherwise a genuinely affectionate gesture.

That, to me, is what makes it so interesting. Mia understands that Dave is suffering. She knows that he needs companionship, and she deliberately makes an effort to provide it. She even goes as far as explaining why she wants to remain with him.

"I like you."

That's it.
No elaborate explanation, no attempt to disguise her feelings, and no ulterior motive that we have any reason to suspect. She simply likes him. She likes being around him, enjoys his company, and wants him to be happy. And when she realizes that he's no longer taking care of himself, she decides that she needs to do something about it. I think this is probably one of the strongest demonstrations that Mia possesses genuine compassion. She doesn't necessarily need to feel Dave's sadness herself to recognize that he's suffering and that she wants to help him. If that's not a demonstration of empathy in its own right, I'm not sure what is.

Emotional Processing and Social Development

Something else worth considering is how Mia processes emotions in general.

Throughout the story, Mia frequently approaches situations with a very matter-of-fact mentality. She doesn't seem particularly interested in social conventions, and she rarely considers whether something she says might make another person uncomfortable. This can make her appear rather detached. However, I don't think it's necessarily accurate to assume that she doesn't experience emotions simply because she doesn't express them conventionally.

For example, Mia clearly experiences frustration when people repeatedly harass her at school. She becomes irritated when others make assumptions about her, and she doesn't particularly appreciate being treated as though she's somehow less human than everyone else. Her response to these situations is often considerably more direct than what people would expect. Rather than attempting to appease others or make herself more socially acceptable, she would much rather be left alone.

And honestly, I think there's a rather unfortunate reason for that.

Mia has spent a considerable portion of her childhood being treated as something abnormal. Her classmates fear her, religious students antagonize her, and even her own father appears to have difficulty accepting her as a person. It's not particularly surprising that she would develop an extremely limited interest in socializing with people who have already decided they don't like her. This is something I think is important when discussing her apparent antisocial tendencies. Something I am ultimately going to have to come back to- Later on in this psychological profile. You will hear my completed thoughts, but for now; context. Contrary to popular belief, being asocial and being antisocial are not the same thing.

Someone who is asocial may simply have little interest in social interaction, prefer solitude, or struggle with conventional social situations. Someone with antisocial personality traits, meanwhile, displays a much broader pattern of disregarding other people's rights and boundaries. Mia certainly demonstrates the former more consistently than the latter. I would also argue that her social development is complicated by her unusual intelligence. Even at a very young age, Mia demonstrates an impressive ability to process information. Dave himself describes her as exceptionally intelligent, and her conversations frequently show that she can understand concepts that other children her age might struggle with.

However, being intellectually advanced doesn't necessarily mean being equally advanced in every other aspect of development. Mia can be remarkably intelligent while still having a child's understanding of certain social situations. She can recognize the logic behind an argument without necessarily understanding why someone might be emotionally invested in it. She can understand what someone is feeling without necessarily knowing how to respond in a socially conventional manner. Sometimes even, she can come across as considerably more mature than she actually is. I think this is particularly important because people often seem to expect Mia to understand everything simply because she's intelligent. But intelligence and emotional development are not interchangeable.
The Influence of Scyther Biology

Of course, we can't discuss Mia without considering her biological inheritance. One of the more interesting aspects of Morphic is how the Pokemon DNA influences the behavior and personalities of the children. In Mia's case, her Scyther DNA appears to have contributed to a more predatory disposition.

Scyther are solitary hunters, creatures that rely on speed, precision, and calculated movements to take down their prey. They aren't particularly concerned with the emotional implications of their actions, and Mia seems to have inherited some of this mentality. As her comments regarding Brian's blood are perhaps the most obvious example. She describes the smell as pleasant and even suggests that she might have wanted to eat him.

Now, that's certainly an uncomfortable thing to hear from a child but I think it's important to consider the context. Mia doesn't seem to be expressing a desire to hurt Brian. Rather, she appears to be describing a biological reaction or instinct that she doesn't entirely understand herself. Her wording is particularly interesting here. She says that she thinks she wanted to eat him, rather than simply declaring that she wanted to. That distinction might seem insignificant, but I think it suggests some uncertainty on her part. She's describing an unusual sensation and attempting to make sense of it. Considering the nature of her biological inheritance, I don't think it's unreasonable to assume that some of these reactions are influenced by instincts that would be perfectly normal for a Scyther.

This also brings up another interesting aspect of her personality.

Mia doesn't seem particularly interested in suppressing her biological instincts. Whereas some of the other Pokemorphs appear uncomfortable with their inherited characteristics, Mia and Lucy seem considerably more accepting of theirs. They don't necessarily view their abilities or urges as something shameful. While that doesn't mean every instinct should be acted upon, I think it helps explain why Mia is so comfortable discussing things that other people would find disturbing. She doesn't necessarily associate those thoughts with morality in the same way someone else might. To her, an instinct is simply an instinct. What matters is what she chooses to do with it.

Aggression, Violence, and Morality

This brings us to another particularly important aspect of Mia's character: her relationship with violence. Mia is undoubtedly capable of aggression. She has demonstrated a willingness to physically confront people, and she doesn't appear particularly disturbed by the prospect of killing someone when she believes it's necessary. However, I think there's a distinction between enjoying violence, being comfortable with violence, and possessing no moral restraint whatsoever.

During the events of Chapter 13, Mia participates in the fight against the Church of Holy Truth. Following Will being shot, the situation quickly deteriorates, and Mia takes an active role in fighting the armed attackers. She is capable of inflicting lethal injuries, and she eventually kills one of the assailants. However, it's worth remembering that these people are armed adults attempting to murder a group of children. Mia isn't simply attacking innocent people for her own amusement. She's fighting against people who have already demonstrated that they're willing to kill her and everyone around her. Furthermore, she had previously been instructed to hold back from killing whenever possible.

This is something I think gets overlooked when people discuss her violent tendencies. Mia is certainly more comfortable with violence than most people, but that doesn't necessarily mean she has no concept of right and wrong. She understands consequences. She understands that certain actions can result in imprisonment, and she understands that hurting someone can create problems for herself and others. She simply doesn't seem to place the same emotional weight on violence that most people do. Considering her biology, upbringing, and experiences, I think that makes considerably more sense than assuming she's inherently incapable of morality. There's also something worth mentioning about the other PokeMorphs.

Mia isn't the only one who experiences violent urges. Throughout the story, other members of the group demonstrate their own capacity for aggression and their willingness to act on it when circumstances become desperate. The difference is that Mia seems considerably more comfortable acknowledging these impulses. She doesn't spend nearly as much time pretending that she isn't capable of doing terrible things.

And perhaps that's part of why she's so unsettling to the others. She's not necessarily more violent than everyone else. She's simply much more open about it.

Personal Observations – Suffering in Taught Silence

This is the part that might come off as a bit emotionally charged. Though you could make that argument through this entire profile, this part is going to be where it speaks to home the most. Mainly because it has to do with a topic near and dear to my heart from firsthand witness accounts and the years I spent studying the effects parenting, upbringing, and psychological affairs can have on the psyche of a child developing. Might seem like a lot but there is a reason why I find this character so tragic and in deep need of a hug. I will begin.

Though I will end up contradicting what I said earlier about lacking Emotional Empathy, there is another angle to look at all this from. Simply put, when you have spent your entire life being told and looked at from the very get go that something about the way you were born was incorrect, that sticks with you. Made especially apparent when you grow up your entire life being reminded that you are the odd one out. That something about you was born incredibly wrong, and that permanently will change how people view you. That no matter what you do, regardless of what you can do, every interaction you have will be directly influenced by something you had no say in, In this case, your very existence.

Though they might’ve had worries due to her biology, and what she has been spliced with, they took a look at this little girl growing up over the years, and decided no real emotion in any human sense could develop in her. Yet in Chapter 9.5, Mia displays a trait in her desire to protect Dave in the event his life is ever in danger. Though Scyther don’t really do personal connections outside of species necessity and raising the young, Mia displays loyalty to Dave in a far greater capacity to that of her own parents. Made especially apparent in “Dave and Mia discuss Family” where she flat out declares she likes Dave more than Howard, her adoptive Father. The mere sight of a depressed Dave made her frightened she would lose him. Though not directly stated, it’s made clear she feels she would be worse off if Dave were not a part of her life. There’s no real use pevaricating about the bush. In a lot of ways, due to how often they seem to interact and how much he tries to make her comfortable in spite of the fear- Howard may be her Father, but Dave in a lot of ways was her Dad.

The fact that Mia had difficulty expressing emotions, or couldn’t shouldn’t really be an excuse for her to be treated differently. And I’m glad that to an extent, this mentality was shared with a few people in the group. If just mostly the adults. This is however, where I feel I must get into how she is viewed. So far, almost everyone had feared Mia to different regards. Many disliked her outright, many merely pitied her. Others, did both at the same time. While we can certainly point towards Isaac Daniels and the Church of the Holy Truth as one of her more lethal haters- the honest truth, it seems like the people Mia has been the most mischaracterized by were her own family and friends. Dave himself, in spite of him giving Mia plenty of love, is guilty of doing the same. I get why, though one thing to remember is that even children unlike Mia are far more perceptive than you expect them to be. No matter how detached you think they are, everything sticks to them. Why would Mia be any exception due to supposed lack of Empathy? Especially when at some point, Dave asked Mia if she was thinking how she liked Dave or wanted to eat his throat. To which she replied “both.” Might not have been intentional, but for many who grew up, that is a response birthed from someone whose already given up. Knowing she won’t receive the specific love she desires, so she settles for this. Self-Depreciating humor or not, it’s a form of comedy that slowly but surely eats at the soul.

As for when it comes to how the Morphs view her, all seven have their own varying opinions that we don’t entirely have a full grasp on. Many interactions, we don’t get to see. Though with strands of dialogue and thoughts, we know there are members who view Mia in a more positive or negative light. With Lucy being the one who loves her sister unconditionally and was the most vocal about her death, while everyone else seemed to be afraid of her. Her inclusion in the mission to save Gabriel, they didn’t really factor in if she would be motivated to save Gabriel out of personal attachment to him. Rather, trying to placate to her Scyther instincts and telling her she’d be in for a good fight. In the end, she was going to be a weapon due to her Scyther Biology, sharp mind, and belief that she’s already ready to kill. A member of their own kind, merely being viewed as a weapon in the long run. Only when she was dead did they realize Mia might not have had been the most mentally disturbed one. Only that she was the most open about it. They make excuses for each other, but Mia is just already a lost cause in their eyes. The only outlier in all of this is Lucy Kerrigan, her adoptive sister, who saw nothing wrong with her from the very start. Her relationship with everyone sours, including her relationship with her own mother and father due to them believing her death was a good thing.

This ultimately leads to something I have to consider. The Worst Possible Scenario in regards to the true depths of the suffering. You might recall from earlier, I mentioned one of the more disturbing things Mia has said at one point. Regarding the comment about she smelled Brian’s corpse. “I think I wanted to eat him.” Is this a disturbing thing to say? Of course, no one will argue against that. The issue I have however is the preface of the phrase “I think”. Mia has far more situational and emotional awareness of the events and people surrounding her. Though there are these little moments where she acts out in ways that are confusing to her. Either triggered by her Scyther Biology, or worst of all, a “tic.” An involuntary action, either verbal or physical. A tic can be formed for different reasons, though the most relevant one here is trauma. Given that this is a real death she’s currently witnessing, the fact its resulted in a response like this- Mia’s human side has completely halted in this situation. Trying to process what she had just witnessed, while her Scyther instincts are in full force. About the only thing she can really do in this situation.

Mia Kerrigan is the kind of person who wears everything on her sleeve, and has no filter whatsoever. Yet at every point, her instincts and “Scyther behavior” is almost always within her Human Control. Apart from the killing of the fly in an unneeded way, or reacting violently in response to ill-prepared intimacy; Mia is never in a position in where she has lost all control to the extent people believe she does. Especially made apparent when it comes to taking down those armed people in the Church during Chapter 13. We can see that she has enough control over herself to listen to reason, as seen when Jack called her to take it easy. In spite of her being in the best possible spot to use her abilities, she is never so lost that no one can reach her. So far, every single time Mia has acted out against someone, she was being antagonized first. While she obviously needs to be more mindful of how she handles tense situations since she’s far stronger than kids her age- she’s otherwise shown immense restraint.

Even if Mia has been raised by a completely loving environment, all canon material, and even some non-canon ones show that she is never actually treated like a normal person to begin with. Just as a thing completely incapable of emotions, so they stop trying to act like they are. When a child growing up believes they are not capable of certain attributes, they eventually stop trying to show that off. They begin to associate said behavior with negative connotations. Much like how if a mother punishes their child for telling the unabashed truth out of belief they’re being insulted, the child learns to lie. That ability to lie grows into every aspect of their life, to where they’re lying to people they don’t have to. A child punished for a mundane action will grow up believing the only way to receive positive affirmation will adjust their personality into one where they receive it. In this case, it feels like the only way for Mia to receive anything close to that was to become the very thing they said she would be. Along with her attempts and trying to hold everything back just so she doesn’t get taken away. Because of how children develop to their enviornment- if Mia’s first instinct when the boy in Chapter 5 tried to hug her was to attack, that says something. It implies that the amount of physical intimacy she receives is so small or nonexistent, she doesn’t register a hug as a positive action. While yes, she is right to be suspicious of hugs from a stranger- This was a child receiving a hug from another child who tried.

In my experience, the amount of children who do this are either never held and thus, never taught to associate hugs with positive feelings, or are people who have used physical intimacy to manipulate or hurt them. Causing them to associate hugs with harming. For many people, I know all too well this rings close. You never know just how badly someone completely falls apart when you hold them in your arms after they trust you enough to do so. It’s hard for me not to see this in someone like Mia, who at the end of the day is fiercely loyal to these people.

That’s another thing. Mia’s first thought in the response to anyone in the group getting hurt is to fight back. Defend them. Even when such actions only would further their fears of her, all that matters is that either they are safe, or the offender has been neutralized. She loyal to a fault, will actively risk her own like, and even escalate her own danger so long as it keeps the heat off of those she cares about. Mia knows how strong she is, and uses it to its maximum when she needs it. Which is why it leads me to believe that to a certain degree, this ultra-rationalist mentality a facade. A coping mechanism meant to keep everything together long enough to keep her mind in check. Especially since the whole turning point in her survival is her not losing her cool. Evidenced by “Dave and Mia discuss Family”, the alternate take where she and Lucy are the only survivors. In that, her own parents would no longer be around, all she would have left in the end are Dave and Lucy. The ONLY people in her life that still love her. I can’t in good faith say Cheryl and Howard did, on account of their behavior in Chapter 14 when they were glad she was dead. How they have the gall to think Lucy would want to talk to them after that is beyond me.

I know this section is the most emotionally charged I’ve done, but this is observation and theories I’ve presented stem from personal studies into Child Psychology, affects of poor mental health, and personal experiences meeting many good people in my life who were severely damaged by the circumstances of their lives. Seeing many walks of life helps identify certain signs of suffering behind a friendly or stone-cold face, and who are genuine monsters. A lot of times, the people who were or thought themselves monsters, were people ravaged by the situations they were in. It’s hard for me to not recognize certain patterns.

I suppose that’s why her story affects me so greatly. It hits too close to home for all the people I’ve come to known who were treated in ways that mirror her. Someone hug this kid right now. Just tell her she isn’t a monster. Even if she can’t emote about it. You know, provided she’d let you hug them. Because Mia Kerrigan’s story genuinely feels like a self-fulfilling prophecy about a girl who was deemed a monster from the start and treated like shit throughout her entire life, ultimately warping her into the very monster they feared she was in her final moments.

So, What Would Mia Actually Be?

Now, after everything we've discussed, I think it's worth returning to the original question. What would Mia Kerrigan realistically be classified as? Apart from very hurt?

Honestly, I don't think there's enough information to assign her a specific psychiatric diagnosis. And I don't believe we need one to understand her character. If anything, I'd describe Mia as someone with an unusual neurodevelopmental and emotional profile, characterized by reduced or atypical affective empathy, strong cognitive empathy, considerable analytical reasoning, limited conventional social engagement, and a rather unconventional relationship with aggression. There are certain aspects of her characterization that could invite comparisons to Autism Spectrum Disorder.

Her unusual social communication, preference for directness, literal approach to certain situations, and differences in emotional expression are all characteristics that can be found in some autistic individuals. However, I wouldn't go as far as diagnosing her with autism based on these characteristics alone. We don't have enough information regarding her developmental history, sensory processing, repetitive behaviors, or other relevant diagnostic criteria. Alexithymia is another possibility worth mentioning, although I'm less convinced that it fully explains her. Alexithymia involves difficulties identifying and describing one's own emotions. Mia does seem to process certain emotional experiences differently, but she also demonstrates a fairly clear understanding of her own preferences and attachments.

She knows that she likes Dave. She knows when she's irritated. She knows when she wants to protect someone. So while she might have some difficulty interpreting or expressing certain emotions, I wouldn't necessarily consider alexithymia an established explanation. I think the most important thing to remember is that Mia's Scyther inheritance introduces an entirely fictional biological factor that makes direct comparisons to human psychiatric conditions particularly difficult. We don't know exactly how her hybrid brain functions, how much of her emotional processing is inherited, or how much of her personality has developed through environmental influences. Without that information, assigning her a diagnosis would be little more than speculation. However, I can say that I don't believe she's the emotionless, compassionless monster that some characters in Morphic seem to think she is.

She's an intelligent child who processes information differently, has unusual biological instincts, and has spent much of her life being treated as something fundamentally wrong with her. Despite all of that, she's still capable of forming meaningful relationships, recognizing the suffering of others, and actively trying to make their lives better. If anything, I think Mia is a rather interesting example of how easily people can mistake a lack of conventional emotional expression for a lack of humanity.

Conclusion - The Tragedy of Mia Kerrigan

Ultimately, I think what makes Mia such a tragic character is that she seems to have been judged long before anyone actually took the time to understand her. Her biology makes people uncomfortable. Her behavior reinforces their suspicions. And her inability or unwillingness to express herself in a conventional manner only makes it easier for others to assume the worst. Even her own family struggles to understand her.

But when we actually take the time to examine her interactions with people, particularly Dave and Lucy, we see something considerably more complicated. Mia isn't necessarily someone who feels things the same way everyone else does. She doesn't always respond to suffering with sadness, express affection through conventional gestures, or understand why certain things are considered socially unacceptable. But that doesn't mean she doesn't care. She has people she loves, people she wants to protect, and people whose happiness genuinely matters to her. And perhaps the most heartbreaking thing about her is that she seems to understand this perfectly well, even when the people around her don't.

I think "Dave and Mia Discuss Family" is particularly important here because it demonstrates something that the main story only occasionally allows us to see. Mia isn't simply capable of understanding that Dave is suffering. She actively wants to help him. She recognizes that he needs companionship, that he's neglecting himself, and that he shouldn't have to go through everything alone. And despite her rather unconventional way of expressing it, she makes it abundantly clear that she cares about him. For someone who has been described as incapable of compassion, that's a rather remarkable thing to witness.

It makes me wonder how differently things might have turned out if more people had made the same effort Dave did. Because at the end of the day, Mia Kerrigan isn't simply a Half-Scyther with a questionable relationship with violence. She's a person. A rather unusual person, certainly, but a person nonetheless. And I think she deserved considerably more understanding than she received.

Final Thanks

With all that said and done, I believe this is a good spot to conclude this Psychological Profiling! I'm not too used to making these things, so I apologize if this was rough. I would like to get better with some more practice. It's honestly a little surprising to me that a story can make me this vocal. Not many fanfics I've read really get this much emotion out of me! I suppose if anyone is interested, feel free to recommend me some stories with characters you adore and I'll see if I can get as attached to them as you do! For now, thank you again, Dragonfree! You've given me a lot to think about, and it's helped out with a lot of stress I've been having recently. And remember everyone. Hug the dragon, and do it now!

Thank you for getting this far. Feel free to let me know if you have any questions, comments, or concerns!
 
Back
Top Bottom