in answer to the seasons dillema, there could be an option in game that you can change the date, that way if there was a season-specific pokemon you want and it wasn't that season you could change the date, and the next time you turn on your game your in the middle of a snowstorm!
That's basically a get-out-of-jail-free card right there.
four way battles/real people tag battles, my old friends from school used to have battles between two of them whilst the other two where sitting watching, it got boring after their fourth match
whereas if there was a four way battle we could all enjoy the same battle, plus the sheer awesomeness of having three opponents
and the real people tag battles, this occurs only with wifi or if a friend is nearby and connects with you
thought those were a given
plus, this isn't for the DS, remember
pokemon feeding option, i mean come on, you've seen it in the anime, in the fanfics, but in the games? no, if you don't feed your pokemon for three days he starts disobeying you in battle and a few other side affects. 2 days later when he still hasn' been fed, he leaves you
this would be an extreme annoyance; you run out of money and can't buy the food, your pokémon start disobeying and you can't win as many battles (remember wild battles give no money); therefore you can't get money to buy their food, etc. when your pokémon start to run away you lose your team. also this wouldn't work for the last pokémon you have left; it can't run away or else you'd basically have to start the game over.
also big big scripting problem.
pokemon evolve during battle, i find it really annoying when i'm training and my pokemon becomes a level that it evolves at, then i have to wait ages cos this trainer has three pokemon.
honestly since the opponent's pokémon cannot even so much as level up during battle I find this idea unfair. The pokémon's stats are boosted highly in many cases. Hell, even sometimes getting the option of a new move is an overwhelming advantage.
the possibility of pokemon not liking pokeballs, pikachu doesn't like em so he has to stay outside of it and follow you around, so why can't this happen in the games? also, the chances of this are only a small chunk higher than the chance of finding a shiny.
If the chances are so low, then what's the point in adding it?
I mean, yes, I love the idea, but the way you word it sounds like every species has a chance of following you around, which would need the creation of overworld sprites for every pokémon, which is too much of a pain in the ass and a loss of memory to work well. I am, however, all in favor of the starter you obtain (whichever it may be) following you around; even with all twelve starters, a few more (like Pikachu), and some fakémon, it would still be manageable.
anime like calls, in the games it's really strange to me how the calls of all the pokemon are just these random noises, it gives me a machine feel rather than a living pokemon feel
too much time; too much effort; too much memory; too little gain.
not worth it imo
proper grammar during battle, in fr/lg it creeped me out how it said "foe ZUBAT used SUPERSONIC" i mean this both in terms of capitalisaion and the fact that it says "foe zubat" and other related terms
Honestly the capitalization is the only problem. I didn't find anything wrong (though sometimes funny) with its current state.
non identical NPC's, nurse joy is an exception, but don't you find it strange how there are like, 20 identical people throughout the game?
Actually, no, because that would be a) too much work and b) too much memory.
the addition of officer jenny, seriously, i havn't seen her since fr/lg
Honestly other than just an Easter Egg it would be pointless but I have no opposition.
a male interpretation of officer jenny, something like officer jonny or jimmy
wouldn't be much more than an easter egg (unless he's involved in the plotline) but [shrug]