Blank Canvas Mafia Game Thread

[Butterfree]

oh yeah, i was a bit surprised that missingno wouldn't have reacted to the vote at all as a new player, but then i remembered that they had at least played a little bit slash read through a few games at the least

I do like mewtini's posting so far, and in particular I think I like the way she brought this up. Feels like an authentic thought process to have had but not necessarily considered worth bringing up until Eifie started prodding at it. Her posts feel pretty easy and natural overall. Very vibes-based but soft townread.

 

[Eifie]

may I also have a vibes-based soft townread

 

[Butterfree]

Dodge I'm not getting a very substantial read on even on an ISO, feels reasonably at ease but I would need to check out his previous games to know if that means much. @Dodge Out of curiosity, what are your thoughts on MF after getting her response regarding her potential reasons for Keldeo to pick Mawile? I saw you said you found it enlightening re: Mawile, but it sounded like you expected MF's reasons to be joke reasons; does the fact it wasn't change your impression of MF at all?

 

[Butterfree]

may I also have a vibes-based soft townread

Just for you, I will go ISO you properly

 

[mewtini]

I figured it was a joke vote or a way to start conversation, and Mawile thought the same too

this isn't really in line with how i interpreted mawile's reaction (i thought he had a more substantial one) but now i'm wondering if i'm off?

 

[mewtini]

may I also have a vibes-based soft townread

no

 

[Eifie]

may I also have a vibes-based soft townread

no

why did i even come back here

 

[Eifie]

I figured it was a joke vote or a way to start conversation, and Mawile thought the same too

this isn't really in line with how i interpreted mawile's reaction (i thought he had a more substantial one) but now i'm wondering if i'm off?

I think at first Mawile basically did nothing and was like I am chill, then the no elim vote came later

 

[Keldeo]

I figured it was a joke vote or a way to start conversation, and Mawile thought the same too

this isn't really in line with how i interpreted mawile's reaction (i thought he had a more substantial one) but now i'm wondering if i'm off?

I think at first Mawile basically did nothing and was like I am chill, then the no elim vote came later

I sort of got the sense that Dodge posted a thought about the first ~2 pages of that interaction and then did not update/has not yet updated that thought given new developments in the thread.

 

[Butterfree]

I do like the questions Eifie has been asking on a reread, some good active prodding that feels pretty organic and easygoing and I do vibe with a fair amount of her thoughts. Particularly liked the samebrain on MF's prod about the vote and poking mewtini about liking that post but also feeling +town on MF's prod. I think mostly there's some ancient kneejerk distrust in my brain from some mafia games of yore that I just don't remember as distinctly as the game where Keldeo betrayed me

 

[Dodge]

Dodge I'm not getting a very substantial read on even on an ISO, feels reasonably at ease but I would need to check out his previous games to know if that means much. @Dodge Out of curiosity, what are your thoughts on MF after getting her response regarding her potential reasons for Keldeo to pick Mawile? I saw you said you found it enlightening re: Mawile, but it sounded like you expected MF's reasons to be joke reasons; does the fact it wasn't change your impression of MF at all?

I did expect the reasons to be joke ones, because it felt too early to have any real ones, basically. So it was either jokes or knowledge of Mawile's prior playstyle. It being the latter doesn't reeeeally change my impression, though. But I'll agree that a confused mafia would be asking about missing a night action in mafia chat instead of in the thread (source: that was me last game, I was the confused mafia)

I figured it was a joke vote or a way to start conversation, and Mawile thought the same too

this isn't really in line with how i interpreted mawile's reaction (i thought he had a more substantial one) but now i'm wondering if i'm off?

Between you being off and me being off, I think the latter's more likely lol
I figured Mawile took it as either a joke or a conversation starter due to not really responding to it at first. The no elim vote does seem a bit panicked, which does make me lean slightly to suspecting Mawile, but I still feel like it's too early to really tell? I dunno, the fence is where I live apparently

I figured it was a joke vote or a way to start conversation, and Mawile thought the same too

this isn't really in line with how i interpreted mawile's reaction (i thought he had a more substantial one) but now i'm wondering if i'm off?

I think at first Mawile basically did nothing and was like I am chill, then the no elim vote came later

I sort of got the sense that Dodge posted a thought about the first ~2 pages of that interaction and then did not update/has not yet updated that thought given new developments in the thread.

Yeah, my bad, haven't been talking much lol

 

[Keldeo]

Butterfree, I have two questions:
- What precisely makes you find me towny so far?
- Could I ask you to place a vote after you're done rereading?

I think the way Butterfree is arranging her thoughts is maybe slightly towny, in that she doesn't seem to have much of an agenda in the order of people she's reading. Or at least if she's mafia, it seems like she's currently mimicking what she'd be doing as town (posting a vague summary then methodically going one by one through everyone) rather than trying to set the narrative of the thread

Eifie, have you got any thoughts on mewtini? Also on this hot take: no real read on MF but I really want to say Ever is town for the way ve voted...

 

[Eifie]

Butterfree, I have two questions:
- What precisely makes you find me towny so far?
- Could I ask you to place a vote after you're done rereading?

I think the way Butterfree is arranging her thoughts is maybe slightly towny, in that she doesn't seem to have much of an agenda in the order of people she's reading. Or at least if she's mafia, it seems like she's currently mimicking what she'd be doing as town (posting a vague summary then methodically going one by one through everyone) rather than trying to set the narrative of the thread

Eifie, have you got any thoughts on mewtini? Also on this hot take: no real read on MF but I really want to say Ever is town for the way ve voted...

YOUR HOT TAKE IS SO RIGHT I'M OBSESSED WITH THAT VOTE
i was holding it back until later but like uh. yeah. i know this is silly but. i've been looking for somewhere to start and i think i got it man

 

[Keldeo]

Actually did a little jig with my phone. Can we be masons now

 

[Eifie]

slightly annoyed that i now lost the chance to bust in like EVER IS MY TOP TOWNREAD AND THIS IS WHY: but anyway

honestly it's kind of bizarre to me how easily everyone is putting mewtini as town because I don't really see it? I don't really have any read on her. like I see the example Butterfree posted for example about a thought she liked and I just don't get it idk man sorry. I don't really know how to read mewtini either. I feel like maybe there's some sort of ~thread consensus~ opinion I should take from this or something but I don't believe in that kind of thing... unless I should... but...

 

[Eifie]

Actually did a little jig with my phone. Can we be masons now

(mewtini voice) no
i must wait at least 4 seconds before performing this action

 

[mewtini]

is it cringe if i say that i wasn't expecting this many TRs either lmao

 

[mewtini]

bye thread i should be "doing" "work" right now

 

[Eifie]

kind of surprised bfree actually gave me the soft vibes-based townread (well she didn't actually say that but) because she's another of the people I end up quibbling with every single game but i'll care about that later maybe. there's someone else who gave me an easier and even more unexpected townread that I'm still pondering rn

 

[Eifie]

kind of surprised bfree actually gave me the soft vibes-based townread (well she didn't actually say that but) because she's another of the people I end up quibbling with every single game but i'll care about that later maybe. there's someone else who gave me an easier and even more unexpected townread that I'm still pondering rn

i also have a secret reason for caring later but once i say it it will no longer be valid