Cats (2019) Mafia

[Tangrowth]

UC, what are your other reads, anything else you'd like to share?

 

[Keldeo]

Uhh... tbh, although I appreciate that he made them, MP7's thoughts don't move the needle that much for me. They seem to be mostly based on little fiddly tone/mindset things from day 1, which afaict are things that mafia Herbe excels at faking - I townread him for his early tone despite the fact that he didn't give a lot of reads early on in TVTropes

@Keldeo is there anyone specific you think could actually be bussing herbe right now? not looking for names necessarily, i just want to know if it's super possible we're just dogpiling a townie again. sorry if i missed it or if i read it and it evacuated my brain

ils' justification in voting on ultracool feels rushed in a bad way to me, but then again he unvoted right after ... hard to tell bc i think he was thrown by VM's "claim"

I thiiink so and I can name names later if you want, and same, hmm

 

[mewtini]

ultracool
pls claim

herbe (6): keldeo, trebek, VM, bfree, blu, kyeugh
ultracool (7): tofu, rari, herbe, mist, m+7, koko, mewtini
tofu (1): emmy
emmy (1): rnp

 

[Vipera Magnifica]

Ok so ultracool seems a bit fishy to me, if only because of VM's decisive statement in #1590.

i'm confused on this honestly

ftr, vm's 1590 is him saying "ultracool is def mafia" because ultracool said that fishing was anti-town. i don't really find it that convincing

to be fair this was from when i was in the tinfoil headspace that skylar had to be mafia and was buddies with ultracool (but in actuality i guess i just really really wanted him to be mafia)

i have since removed the clown makeup and left that tunnel

 

[Trebek]

mewt, question for you (this might change my vote)

in the hypothetical situation that herbe is maf and you are town, would you consider his check on you as a reason to be scared about getting mafkilled? if the answer is yes, then i feel more inclined to believe herbe is town

 

[mewtini]

in the hypothetical situation that herbe is maf and you are town, would you consider his check on you as a reason to be scared about getting mafkilled? if the answer is yes, then i feel more inclined to believe herbe is town

precisely

 

[Tangrowth]

Uhh... tbh, although I appreciate that he made them, MP7's thoughts don't move the needle that much for me. They seem to be mostly based on little fiddly tone/mindset things from day 1, which afaict are things that mafia Herbe excels at faking - I townread him for his early tone despite the fact that he didn't give a lot of reads early on in TVTropes

@Keldeo is there anyone specific you think could actually be bussing herbe right now? not looking for names necessarily, i just want to know if it's super possible we're just dogpiling a townie again. sorry if i missed it or if i read it and it evacuated my brain

ils' justification in voting on ultracool feels rushed in a bad way to me, but then again he unvoted right after ... hard to tell bc i think he was thrown by VM's "claim"

I thiiink so and I can name names later if you want, and same, hmm

This is good to know. I think I'll still keep my vote where it is pending UC further posts or something, but it does compel me to doubt the interpretation a bit more.

 

[Trebek]

ok after i asked that i realized that relies on herbe checking you n0 and i don’t remember which order it was

 

[mewtini]

ok after i asked that i realized that relies on herbe checking you n0 and i don’t remember which order it was

he did

your post is exactly why i was being cryptic before btw, that was what i had just realized

 

[Vipera Magnifica]

I can't speak for anyone else but I just trust butterfree's judgement on the Herbe matter tbh

if you think emmy is alien then why would you think herbe isn't town-aligned?

this doesn't make sense

ultracool

 

[Trebek]

ok after i asked that i realized that relies on herbe checking you n0 and i don’t remember which order it was

he did

your post is exactly why i was being cryptic before btw, that was what i had just realized

spicy

mr ultracool

 

[Keldeo]

I can't speak for anyone else but I just trust butterfree's judgement on the Herbe matter tbh

if you think emmy is alien then why would you think herbe isn't town-aligned?

this doesn't make sense

ultracool

VM I think he's saying he thinks Emmy is alien

skylar airpods dot png

 

[Bluwiikoon]

I can't speak for anyone else but I just trust butterfree's judgement on the Herbe matter tbh

if you think emmy is alien then why would you think herbe isn't town-aligned?

this doesn't make sense

ultracool

Why wouldn't it make sense tho?

 

[mewtini]

herbe (4): keldeo, bfree, blu, kyeugh
ultracool (9): tofu, rari, herbe, mist, m+7, koko, mewtini, vm, trebek
tofu (1): emmy
emmy (1): rnp

@Mr. Ultracool claim :')

 

[Keldeo]

Mr. Ultracool, claim?

 

[mewtini]

in the hypothetical situation that herbe is maf and you are town, would you consider his check on you as a reason to be scared about getting mafkilled? if the answer is yes, then i feel more inclined to believe herbe is town

precisely

can someone heal me tbh, and trust me if you TR me

 

[Bluwiikoon]

Mr. Ultracooooool!

 

[rari_teh]

@Mr. Ultracool great moment to roleclaim

 

[Keldeo]

in the hypothetical situation that herbe is maf and you are town, would you consider his check on you as a reason to be scared about getting mafkilled? if the answer is yes, then i feel more inclined to believe herbe is town

precisely

can someone heal me tbh, and trust me if you TR me

Over Emmy? Genuine question

 

[mewtini]

Over Emmy? Genuine question

i've got it :)