Cats (2019) Mafia

[Trebek]

of my initial rnp reaction

 

[kyeugh]

Presumably someone who got Jailed would specifically know they were in jail, according to what Trebek outlined

the thing trebek described is from a different meta, it almost certainly doesn’t work that way here. as he says, whether emmy got roleblocked of jailed her only indication either way would be her lack of inspection result

 

[rari_teh]

I'm feeling pretty similar, but I was getting paranoid about Ultracool being outgroup meaning interactions don't matter, but maybe I shouldn't be?

i was thinking, if ultracool was outgroup and outgroup is (likely) terrorist, wouldn’t he blow himself up at the last moment before being lynched? :|

EOD1 they swapped between Stryke and myuma a bunch, which I read in the moment as an indecisive town trying to do the right thing with incomplete info, but could probably also be compatible with mafia who didn't actually care who got yeeted there.

uuuuuh wouldn’t that be the opposite? like, i may be being naïve, but wouldn’t a mafia who knows that the wagons are v/v just park at one of the wagons because who cares who’s going to be lynched?

Or 3p, which would be weird and I'm not sure how that role would really work.

if there’s a 3p i definitely don’t think it’s fishing bros/lovers/whatever role that comes in pairs, given the high mafia-to-town ratio

I didn't know we had multiple protective roles too, so hopefully Emmy is reasonably safe for now?

idk. if rnp is town, it’s kinda pointless for him to heal emmy every night given that it would also block her reads, and mewt isn’t a full healer iirc, whatever that means

emmy

i'm not smart and emmy's been quiet so i'm just sticking to the one hunch i have

this is starting to bug me tbh

i think this is most likely just him having fun at our reactions tbh. i mean, if i were mafia with rnp i’d be screaming in the scumchat

Also, vm wasn't lying about one of the two of us being vig.

uuuuh why would you say this out loud tbh

 

[Bluwiikoon]

For what it's worth I think everyone appreciates your input, Trebek! ^^

 

[Trebek]

also just to make sure i didn’t somehow invalidate my vote earlier

rnp

 

[mewtini]

i lowkey think there's just not a 3p tbh.

uuuuuh wouldn’t that be the opposite? like, i may be being naïve, but wouldn’t a mafia who knows that the wagons are v/v just park at one of the wagons because who cares who’s going to be lynched?

not if they're feigning confusion

 

[kyeugh]

i think this is most likely just him having fun at our reactions tbh. i mean, if i were mafia with rnp i’d be screaming in the scumchat

maybe! but i think it’s still pretty frustrating and i’m just not really into the whole “well by now we should expect this guy to play against his own interests” thing

 

[mewtini]

i lowkey think there's just not a 3p tbh.

don't quote me on this though. it just doesn't make sense in the 14-setup is my thought

 

[mewtini]

i was thinking, if ultracool was outgroup and outgroup is (likely) terrorist, wouldn’t he blow himself up at the last moment before being lynched? :|

this is kind of a good take tho

 

[kyeugh]

i kinda feel like there isn’t an outgroup

 

[Trebek]

how does terrorist work again?

 

[kyeugh]

how does terrorist work again?

aiui aligned with mafia, doesn’t know the other mafia (might know just one), not in scum chat, can blow themselves up on someone

 

[mewtini]

i kinda feel like there isn’t an outgroup

yeah with the 14-setup in mind, i'm in agreement

how does terrorist work again?

they pick someone to blow up/daykill in the thread (and die with them)

 

[Bluwiikoon]

Given we know of a few powerful town roles right now, I'm not sure why a terrorist wouldn't kaboom yet unless it's a self preservation thing. It's surely more dangerous to let cops and semi-healers roam free

 

[Trebek]

how does terrorist work again?

aiui aligned with mafia, doesn’t know the other mafia (might know just one), not in scum chat, can blow themselves up on someone

yeah, that doesn’t really vibe with what we saw from UC

i doubt outgroup tbh

 

[Vipera Magnifica]

i lowkey think there's just not a 3p tbh.

idk, i still think there could be an alien and i shudder to think they might have just been activated last night

i'm disinclined to believe it's RNP at least, because in what world was he the high priority target for the mafia last night?

 

[Bluwiikoon]

This is my Cats 2019 character, Explodeytippytoes. They die in the first twelve seconds of the movie for the sake of gratuitous CGI effects

 

[Trebek]

This is my Cats 2019 character, Explodeytippytoes. They die in the first twelve seconds of the movie for the sake of gratuitous CGI effects

i mean the movie budgets gotta go somewhere

 

[Vipera Magnifica]

maybe the terrorrist is Old Deuteronomy.. why else wear an oversized fur coat if not to hide bombs?

 

[mewtini]

idk, i still think there could be an alien and i shudder to think they might have just been activated last night

yeah there's still an alien/bulletproof hit possibility, you're right