Cats (2019) Mafia

[mewtini]

also while I think of this, if RNP flips red, I think it's safe for Butterfree to claim the other fishing brother

wait why, just for the clear?

no roleblocker then

 

[Keldeo]

also while I think of this, if RNP flips red, I think it's safe for Butterfree to claim the other fishing brother

wait why, just for the clear?

For the clear, and because the situation where mafia can just kill one of them and block the other becomes no longer possible if RNP is mafia. Now they have to fear the revenge vig shot so they can't eliminate the clear villagers.

 

[mewtini]

most likely anyway

 

[mewtini]

lol jk.

 

[kyeugh]

oh fsr i didn't consider that the fishing brother's kill could be blocked

 

[Bluwiikoon]

I'd lean towards keeping fishing brother a secret unless they're in immediate danger imo

 

[Keldeo]

oh fsr i didn't consider that the fishing brother's kill could be blocked

I don't actually know if it can, but from how Butterfree described it earlier it seems reasonable?

 

[rari_teh]

I'd lean towards keeping fishing brother a secret unless they're in immediate danger imo

this tbh
if mafia knows who the fishing brother is, they’ll never kill either of them and we’ll never get our second vigkill

 

[kyeugh]

idk, i think the mafia are unlikely to kill a fishing brother unless they have no other option, so it's probably good for that information to be public so we have a bigger group of locktowns and can better filter out the scum. i'm vibing with this tbh

 

[rari_teh]

I'd lean towards keeping fishing brother a secret unless they're in immediate danger imo

this tbh
if mafia knows who the fishing brother is, they’ll never kill either of them and we’ll never get our second vigkill

maybe not even if the fishing brother is in danger

 

[mewtini]

does anyone have a votecount? if not i can ... do it.....
also mafia is actively disincentivized to kill fishing brothers, so we get a bigger towncore

 

[Trebek]

but if mafia know both fishing brothers, they turn into vanilla town

 

[mewtini]

unless we really want the vigkill that is heh

 

[kyeugh]

I'd lean towards keeping fishing brother a secret unless they're in immediate danger imo

this tbh
if mafia knows who the fishing brother is, they’ll never kill either of them and we’ll never get our second vigkill

i think the one-shot kill is less useful (esp considering we have an actual vig) than sorting as many people as possible without having to risk a mislynch/vig misfire

 

[Trebek]

is that a risk we want to take

 

[rari_teh]

RNP is ahead by a fuckton of votes
i have no idea how many a fuckton is, but it is at least 2 ig

 

[Keldeo]

I guess in the end it's up to whether Butterfree/her partner think it's better to be quasi-vanilla but clear in thread, or possibly get to use their ability but not have her partner be cleared.

 

[kyeugh]

but if mafia know both fishing brothers, they turn into vanilla town

more like two locktown bombs tbh

 

[mewtini]

i think the one-shot kill is less useful (esp considering we have an actual vig) than sorting as many people as possible without having to risk a mislynch/vig misfire

er, in that case they can just roleclaim before a mislynch?

also i hate to say it but is htis productive

 

[rari_teh]

I'd lean towards keeping fishing brother a secret unless they're in immediate danger imo

this tbh
if mafia knows who the fishing brother is, they’ll never kill either of them and we’ll never get our second vigkill

i think the one-shot kill is less useful (esp considering we have an actual vig) than sorting as many people as possible without having to risk a mislynch/vig misfire

oh come on we all suspect who the vig is
they’re set to die sooner or later tbh