Cats (2019) Mafia

[Trebek]

inb4 mafia fishing bros

 

[kyeugh]

i think the one-shot kill is less useful (esp considering we have an actual vig) than sorting as many people as possible without having to risk a mislynch/vig misfire

er, in that case they can just roleclaim before a mislynch?

also i hate to say it but is htis productive

i mean, no, that doesn't achieve the same thing at all

also i don't really see why not tbh

 

[Vipera Magnifica]

I'd lean towards keeping fishing brother a secret unless they're in immediate danger imo

this tbh
if mafia knows who the fishing brother is, they’ll never kill either of them and we’ll never get our second vigkill

it's more useful to town to be able to narrow down the pool of potential mafia

 

[rari_teh]

also i hate to say it but is htis productive

not at all
maybe i should side-eye whoever began talking about this obvious distraction

 

[kyeugh]

I'd lean towards keeping fishing brother a secret unless they're in immediate danger imo

this tbh
if mafia knows who the fishing brother is, they’ll never kill either of them and we’ll never get our second vigkill

i think the one-shot kill is less useful (esp considering we have an actual vig) than sorting as many people as possible without having to risk a mislynch/vig misfire

oh come on we all suspect who the vig is
they’re set to die sooner or later tbh

well yeah, we all are, unless we win first, which is not impossible even without vig/fishing brothers related kills in the equation at all

 

[mewtini]

i didn't mean to point at anyone for this, i just don't see what it has to do with the lynch, sorry

 

[Keldeo]

also i hate to say it but is htis productive

Yeah idk uhhh

I'm kind of waiting on MP7's reads list but does anyone else want to toss around other reads / worlds? I'm pretty okay with the wagons still

 

[Keldeo]

i didn't mean to point at anyone for this, i just don't see what it has to do with the lynch, sorry

idk do you feel like we should be yeeting/considering someone else?

 

[kyeugh]

i mean if people have stuff to say about the lynch they're free to do so but i don't think we should be disallowed from talking about anything else? it's not like we're beating people down for discussing lynch related stuff

 

[Tangrowth]

MP7 vibes-based reads list

Spoiler

Moderate to strong town
Butterfree
Emmy
mewtini

Slight to moderate town
Keldeo
koko
kyuegh
rari

Upper POE
Herbe
Mist
Tofu
Trebek
VM

Lower POE
Blu
RNP

Alphabetical within tiers.

@Keldeo

 

[mewtini]

i didn't mean to imply that. but i thought the lynch was still contested and we don't have much time

 

[rari_teh]

I'd lean towards keeping fishing brother a secret unless they're in immediate danger imo

this tbh
if mafia knows who the fishing brother is, they’ll never kill either of them and we’ll never get our second vigkill

i think the one-shot kill is less useful (esp considering we have an actual vig) than sorting as many people as possible without having to risk a mislynch/vig misfire

oh come on we all suspect who the vig is
they’re set to die sooner or later tbh

well yeah, we all are, unless we win first, which is not impossible even without vig/fishing brothers related kills in the equation at all

i think it would be better if we discussed this tomorrow tbh
it’s less than 30 min until sundown and this discussion has nothing to do with our current tricky situation

 

[Keldeo]

Blu, how's it going? Where's your head at?

 

[kyeugh]

I'd lean towards keeping fishing brother a secret unless they're in immediate danger imo

this tbh
if mafia knows who the fishing brother is, they’ll never kill either of them and we’ll never get our second vigkill

i think the one-shot kill is less useful (esp considering we have an actual vig) than sorting as many people as possible without having to risk a mislynch/vig misfire

oh come on we all suspect who the vig is
they’re set to die sooner or later tbh

well yeah, we all are, unless we win first, which is not impossible even without vig/fishing brothers related kills in the equation at all

i think it would be better if we discussed this tomorrow tbh
it’s less than 30 min until sundown and this discussion has nothing to do with our current tricky situation

i mean feel free to talk about the tricky situation then

 

[kyeugh]

MP7 vibes-based reads list

Spoiler

Moderate to strong town
Butterfree
Emmy
mewtini

Slight to moderate town
Keldeo
koko
kyuegh
rari

Upper POE
Herbe
Mist
Tofu
Trebek
VM

Lower POE
Blu
RNP

Alphabetical within tiers.

@Keldeo

can you explain your koko read a bit or link me to a post where you did? sorry if you've already explained this and i'm forgetting

 

[Tangrowth]

btw MP7 did I answer all your questions? I know you asked me some but I think I probably answered them in the course of doing normal stuff

herbe
sorry mate

i’m gonna go herbe for now bc of [nope] but my vote may or may not [nuh uh] in the next 45 minutes

I'm leaning more towards Herbe than RNP tbh

Can you all tell me more?

i’m in agreement but am currently [lol]

huh

can someone explain the herbe thing to me

i don't really understand this except for in relation to rnp in which case it seems to me like it makes more sense to just shoot rnp and resolve herbe with the vig if necessary

Yeah for me it's in relation to RNP. I'm kind of no longer vibing because that makes sense to me and that seemed like a big swing.

The swing was a bit alarming, lol.

alright, i’m done meming- rnp

i was interested in seeing how the mafia would react to a herbe wagon suddenly appearing: would they wagon it, or double down on rnp?

Who if anyone do you think is most likely to be mafia here in the quoted posts, and what would they be doing?

I think so yeah, thanks for checking though!

 

[Keldeo]

MP7 vibes-based reads list

Spoiler

Moderate to strong town
Butterfree
Emmy
mewtini

Slight to moderate town
Keldeo
koko
kyuegh
rari

Upper POE
Herbe
Mist
Tofu
Trebek
VM

Lower POE
Blu
RNP

Alphabetical within tiers.

@Keldeo

Can you explain about me, koko, and Tofu/VM being where you put them? What do you think of the earlier Blu/RNP not w/w read for Blu not seeming to understand about the jailer, I don't remember if you said?

 

[Keldeo]

Oh actually I think that post Tofu made a couple minutes ago about not understanding why town jailkeeper RNP would vote Emmy actually makes her and RNP probably not mafia together, either - both because of the pressing on RNP and because of the confusion about the jailkeeper role.

 

[Tangrowth]

I guess in the end it's up to whether Butterfree/her partner think it's better to be quasi-vanilla but clear in thread, or possibly get to use their ability but not have her partner be cleared.

Yeah, I agree with this.

 

[Bluwiikoon]

Blu, how's it going? Where's your head at?

Not gonna lie my brain is white static at this point Everyone seems to have a good grasp on things and I'm not really sure what I can contribute aside from just stray thoughts as they come to me. Mafia... is a tricky game!

I really wanna believe VM/Tofu are town for reasons. I guess when more flips come to light, I should revisit my Roster List tomorrow?