E’s vibing well enough for me to be almost sure e’s a townie with a busy-ish meat life.
How dare you, I'll have you know I'm a vegetarian D:<
but yeah, this is pretty accurate tbh.
As for actual game thoughts.
Honestly at this point Ottercopter just sounds to me like an alien who had never heard of aliens before (or who didn't immediately recognise that her role was alien - I know my role PM didn't explicitly state the standard mafia name of my role) and misunderstood her goal. Dunno if this conflicts with anything she's already said.
(Or she's some sort of "reverse alien" who needs to be lynched and
then nightkilled?)
can I further the confirmation bias and speculate that maybe boq's somewhat vocal distrust of Panini and M&F could've been a factor in his death
Not sure I dare say this but... does this not also apply to Keldeo? who he also spoke quite strongly against? which you didn't bring up until M&F did (in #1764)?
I concede I may have confbias too, but it's not as if boquise was being secretive about scumreading Keldeo. He talked about it several times. And I know you noticed, because you argued with him about it (in #1085). So why omit him from your list of "people boq FoSed"? I've been townreading you almost all game (and still am overall, for all the many other reasons people have given), and from tierlists it seems like everyone else is too, so this is a little baffling to me.
i don't really get why we're assuming vm got shielded? i keep seeing this tossed around and don't get it
like in order for that to be true we have to make all of these assumptions:
[long list of assumptions]
this is all vs the more obvious conclusion of
- there is no vig
- the mafia targeted boq last night fsr
Because the "obvious conclusion" doesn't explain why mafia
didn't target VM last night, given that, if he was being truthful, he was almost certainly going to become a doctor.
I'm not totally convinced VM was shielded either, but afaict, the alternative is that he is lying about something. That's eminently possible (he only tropeclaimed White Mage after Negrek had already named it), but it seems inconsistent with his activity. If he were actually carrying out some arcane plan that required us to believe he had an unusual power role, I feel like he would be putting a lot more effort into convincing us.
I also don't think there being more than one way to nightkill people is a terribly outlandish assumption in a game with ~20 players. It's not implausible that either the mafia or the hypothetical vig targeted Ottercopter last night and she is now an activated alien.
I mean literally dozens of pages worth of speculation! I still feel like there's very little evidence of anything right now. We have some hints of people with powers who are probably not Mafia, but that's as solid as I feel about anything (and even that could just be trickery).
