Out of Context TVTropes Mafia Quotes Mafia

[Novae]

WHY are we yeeting despicable meme

 

[kyeugh]

i'm vibing personally. i don't think a seshas lynch will give us that much useful information to go on unless she flips wolf (doubt), and koko isn't getting yeeted today. at least this way we get a clear on a living player at minimum. redneckphoenix sorry bro don't flame i feel guilty

 

[Keldeo]

Super ?_? at all this, I almost want to say it anti-aligns the [VM-Hydrei] and [MF-RNP] pairs, which I think are aligned within themselves (unless DM posts the copypasta at :59 or something)?

I've kind of swung back to thinking Seshas is more likely to flip town with how like... not focused on them this EOD has been...? @Seshas do you have legacy reads or anything you want to share?

 

[Novae]

DO NOT VOTE MY TOP TOWNREAD

 

[Trebek]

• rnp/dm v/v - possible, they're both telling the truth. if we lynch one, all their flip will confirm is the other.
• rnp/dm w/v - possible, they're both telling the truth (except rnp is lying about their alignment, but nothing else).

also, this seems like a contradiction? or at the very least, this means that misyeeting dm doesnt actually solve anything

 

[Keldeo]

DO NOT VOTE MY TOP TOWNREAD

Why are they your top townread?

 

[tbh²]

rnp/dm w/v - possible, they're both telling the truth (except rnp is lying about their alignment, but nothing else).

no tbh
why would rnp, given that the role is indeed what he says it is, use it on a townie
if the role is real i think rnp is just town tbqh
-m

 

[kyeugh]

• rnp/dm v/w - impossible. if rnp is telling the truth and they aren't collaborating, dm would have to admit they're scum.

i think the issue here is that rnp admitted that this could be the case: dm could feasibly just be waiting until the last possible minute before EoD to tell the truth

yeah, maybe. if we lynch rnp and he flips town we can be pretty sure dm is town; otherwise dm will claim mafia in the thread and vig can shoot them.
only hole in this as far as i can tell is that if we lynch rnp, he flips town, and dm ends up looking town as a result, mafia might shoot dm overnight and we're left at square one.

 

[Novae]

DO NOT VOTE MY TOP TOWNREAD

Why are they your top townread?

-role is never a wolf role
-role has been confirmed by herbe
-if they're w/w with DM they're tied together in a way that's really weird to pull D1

 

[kyeugh]

rnp/dm w/v - possible, they're both telling the truth (except rnp is lying about their alignment, but nothing else).

no tbh
why would rnp, given that the role is indeed what he says it is, use it on a townie
if the role is real i think rnp is just town tbqh
-m

public confirmation from a townie of his role?

 

[kyeugh]

i disagree that rnp is necessarily town if he's telling the truth, because his actual role (not the one-shot part) is NAI, but more useful to scum than town.

 

[tbh²]

public confirmation from a townie of his role?

seems WAY easier to just assume that rnp is lying in that case
if the role is real, it isn't on a wolf. i think that that's ez
and i don't want to base wagons in a possibly-clarifying post from hmf (mafia claim) that may as well come with 15 sec left in the day
-m

 

[Novae]

i disagree that rnp is necessarily town if he's telling the truth, because his actual role (not the one-shot part) is NAI, but more useful to scum than town.

how is a public check ever a wolf role

 

[Trebek]

i disagree that rnp is necessarily town if he's telling the truth, because his actual role (not the one-shot part) is NAI, but more useful to scum than town.

also for the record, we have no way of knowing that one half of his role being true guarantees that the other half is true without exposing a watcher

 

[Keldeo]

idt "force target to claim their role truthfully or die" is a mafia role, yeah

 

[tbh²]

this is weird vibes
why would a thread alignment check be >rand wolf when it would give town a confirmed player?!
-m

 

[Zori]

meow?

 

[qenya]

i disagree that rnp is necessarily town if he's telling the truth, because his actual role (not the one-shot part) is NAI, but more useful to scum than town.

but the one-shot part is actively harmful to scum. it essentially converts a townie into an innocent child

why would scum have that role, and if they had it, why would they use it

 

[Trebek]

this is weird vibes
why would a thread alignment check be >rand wolf when it would give town a confirmed player?!
-m

pocketing and/or bastard?

ftr i actually think i agree with you on this one, just thinking about possibilities

 

[Butterfree]

Okay yeeting RedneckPhoenix does make more sense