Cats (2019) Mafia

[Novae]

and mewtini claimed mech clear on kyeugh right

 

[Bluwiikoon]

You're not gonna put yourself on that list? :o

 

[mewtini]

and mewtini claimed mech clear on kyeugh right

i claimed mech on rari and almost-mech on kyeugh

 

[kyeugh]

and mewtini claimed mech clear on kyeugh right

yes, and rari

 

[mewtini]

almost-mech

read "not impossible, but i won't be going there for a while"

 

[mewtini]

i still put it at like 100%/98% lol.

 

[Novae]

You're not gonna put yourself on that list? :o

no, because I'm town, lol

 

[Novae]

Keldeo
kokorico
Trebek
M Plus 7
Tofu
Bluwiikoon
Vipera Magnifica

this is like, an okay PoE? but it doesn't really make sense unless ultracool was outgroup in which case herbe isn't really clear

 

[kyeugh]

Keldeo
kokorico
Trebek
M Plus 7
Tofu
Bluwiikoon
Vipera Magnifica

this is like, an okay PoE? but it doesn't really make sense unless ultracool was outgroup in which case herbe isn't really clear

this is pretty much where i'm at too except rnp is in there

 

[kyeugh]

Keldeo
kokorico
Trebek
M Plus 7
Tofu
Bluwiikoon
Vipera Magnifica

this is like, an okay PoE? but it doesn't really make sense unless ultracool was outgroup in which case herbe isn't really clear

this is pretty much where i'm at too except rnp is in there

oh and also you are too. :p

 

[mewtini]

oh hey, that's almost my PoE!

 

[mewtini]

except mist/rnp are in there and trebek maybe isn't

 

[rari_teh]

I kinda read last Night as uhhhh mewtini saying she'll protect Emmy and asking any living healer to heal her, and then the heal being Successful and the maf targeting mewtini Just In Case because y'know, we coulda lost a healer already without knowing and because mewtini seems to have a strong role. But that's just my theory!

so you’re saying that mewtini is not really a healer? i don’t follow

i think the reasoning is like... mewtini said she would target emmy and asked the other healer (if present) to go onto her. the mafia took a gamble that there was no other healer and targeted mewtini, but she was indeed projected and that’s why there was no kill?

ooooh so the point is that there would be another healer whose identity is unknown to us who healed mewtini, under the assumption that RNP is mafia? makes sense

 

[kyeugh]

and trebek maybe isn't

why not

 

[kyeugh]

I kinda read last Night as uhhhh mewtini saying she'll protect Emmy and asking any living healer to heal her, and then the heal being Successful and the maf targeting mewtini Just In Case because y'know, we coulda lost a healer already without knowing and because mewtini seems to have a strong role. But that's just my theory!

so you’re saying that mewtini is not really a healer? i don’t follow

i think the reasoning is like... mewtini said she would target emmy and asked the other healer (if present) to go onto her. the mafia took a gamble that there was no other healer and targeted mewtini, but she was indeed projected and that’s why there was no kill?

ooooh so the point is that there would be another healer whose identity is unknown to us who healed mewtini, under the assumption that RNP is mafia? makes sense

indeed yeah, it's a pretty good theory tbh and if rnp flips red i might go so far as to say that it's probably what happened? but i don't think it's really changing how i view the situation, like it isn't particularly incriminating

 

[Novae]

I am not willing to put RNP in the PoE until we get an alternate explanation on where the kill went

unless the team is like

RNP/Tofu/VM/+2 and there was a 1-shot vig

 

[Trebek]

tbh it could also be a smorgasbord of the two scenarios (v!rnp targets emmy, maf target mewt who gets healed) but that would imply jailer+healer+whatever mewt is which makes me shudder to consider maf power roles

ok maybe i talked myself out of this as i was writing it but imma hit post anyways

 

[mewtini]

why not

i could be convinced maybe but i still feel p good about his EoD. w!trebek has no reason to figure out (+post) what i was breadcrumbing unless he actively wanted to bus ultracool or ultracool was indeed outgroup, because he was the deciding vote/i'd think mafia would be more cognizant of that. saying something like that aloud means he was fine with potentially getting other people to follow his vote

 

[kyeugh]

I am not willing to put RNP in the PoE until we get an alternate explanation on where the kill went

unless the team is like

RNP/Tofu/VM/+2 and there was a 1-shot vig

what's wrong with the current explanation
it's not conclusive but it's certainly sufficient to put him in the poe for me at least. there are worlds that make sense where he's mafia

 

[Novae]

town cascades (barring shenanigans):
herbe > mewtini > rari/kyeugh/emmy
herbe > butterfree