Cats (2019) Mafia

[mewtini]

if RNP is town there’s probably a mafia roleblocker that was on mewtini, yes?

if they assume there's only one healer then yeah
this all falls apart if herbe is indeed mafia tbh

 

[mewtini]

I think people aren't getting that you were a one-shot healer (I thought you made this clear like at the start of toDay but maybe I imagined it)

i'm not a one-shot healer fwiw. that's why i was afraid that there might not be another doctor

 

[Trebek]

if i was maf after last EoD, there’s a chance that i would’ve gotten pinged by mewts confidence and decided to take the risk of there maybe being another healer targeting mewt

what do you mean by pinged here

like, it would have flagged me as “hmm, she’s probably being serious i shouldn’t attack emmy”

might have used ping incorrectly heh

 

[kyeugh]

if RNP was scum why not block mewtini and shoot emmy though

who knows. no matter what the mafia's actions last night are a pretty big question mark though

if RNP is town there’s probably a mafia roleblocker that was on mewtini, yes?

that seems like fair conjecture but i'm not sure it's a safe assumption

 

[Novae]

mewtini and Emmy seem like the most logical kills last night, maybe herbe

Outside shot of Tofu/VM I guess?

 

[rari_teh]

oh, question. if rnp is villa, then does it make sense for mafia to assume there was a second healer? it wasn't known that i was only a partial healer

i’m inclined to believe so, yes. specially since jack said that if there were multiple healers there wouldn’t be healclash, which would be unnecessary to say if there weren’t multiple healers

but in any case (i.e. regardless of RNP’s alignment) i think that three healing roles are a bit too much for a 14-people game? so i’m inclined to believe that there are no other doctors

 

[Trebek]

for all we know mafia could have been expecting a mysterious third healer to coin flip between emmy and mewt, in which case the best choice would be RB emmy and kill mewt/someone random

 

[mewtini]

but in any case (i.e. regardless of RNP’s alignment) i think that three healing roles are a bit too much for a 14-people game?

not if rnp is roleblocker and was just lying tbh, then 1.5ish doctors sounds fine to me i think?

which would be unnecessary to say if there weren’t multiple healers

i think he specifically said that it didn't have any bearing on whether or not there existed more than one healer

 

[mewtini]

ftr i'm not totally speccing w!rnp as a jailer, i've been thinking about it as a roleblocker. maybe that'll make my posts make a bit more sense haha

 

[Trebek]

tinfoilhat time rnp blocked emmy and no one died it’s emmy

jkjkjk

 

[rari_teh]

not if rnp is roleblocker and was just lying tbh, then 1.5ish doctors sounds fine to me i think?

very good point tbh

 

[kyeugh]

tinfoilhat time rnp blocked emmy and no one died it’s emmy

jkjkjk

this is what he said when he revealed that he'd blocked emmy. it'll be huge loltown if it's true tbh

 

[rari_teh]

if rnp dies and flips green, emmy survives and she checks an obvious town as green i’ll be inclined to believe that rnp’s tinfoil is legit

 

[mewtini]

i'd scream

 

[kyeugh]

hm, i'm going to put my vote back on redneckphoenix. i think no matter what this is a very useful flip that will answer a lot of questions for us

 

[mewtini]

i want to say no infolynching!!! but i'm vibing with my vote heh

 

[kyeugh]

it's not even necessarily an infolynch, i think the odds that he flips scum are like 50% tbh? maybe more? but even if he doesn't it won't be a huge deal, we'll learn a lot from it. so i feel ok sitting here

 

[Butterfree]

hmmm, thinking for a minute, the facts are that emmy didn’t die last night, there was no mafia kill, AND she had her action blocked. if we take mewtini at her word that she healed emmy, the worlds here are:

• v!rnp jailed emmy, and the mafia targeted her.
• w!rnp targeted emmy, and the mafia targeted someone else, who was either bulletproof, an alien, or protected by a second town healer.

i’m kind of thinking the first option is more probable here? i’m going to unvote for now.

Isn't it pretty possible that the mafia gambled on there not being a second doctor and targeted mewtini, who was then healed by a second doctor that did in fact exist?

 

[mewtini]

yeah, that's why i brought up that i hadn't said yet that i wasn't a full doctor. in that case there's another doctor but the mafia might not have realized that

but then it comes down to 'would they have been that convinced that there was only one doctor'

 

[Novae]

no infolynching

also am I insane for considering a world where butterfree is a mafia fishing brother who was partnered with mawile and scum![tofu/VM] is fakeclaiming the vig shots