• Welcome to The Cave of Dragonflies forums, where the smallest bugs live alongside the strongest dragons.

    Guests are not able to post messages or even read certain areas of the forums. Now, that's boring, don't you think? Registration, on the other hand, is simple, completely free of charge, and does not require you to give out any personal information at all. As soon as you register, you can take part in some of the happy fun things at the forums such as posting messages, voting in polls, sending private messages to people and being told that this is where we drink tea and eat cod.

    Of course I'm not forcing you to do anything if you don't want to, but seriously, what have you got to lose? Five seconds of your life?

Cats (2019) Mafia

kyeugh said:
this is pretty much where i'm at too except rnp is in there
Click to expand...
mewtini said:
oh hey, that's almost my PoE!
Click to expand...
unknown.png
 
As would I... I gave my reasons for voting. Rnp annoyed and confused me and I wanted to hear others' opinions.
 
Trebek said:
rari_teh said:
tofu
Click to expand...
would be interested in hearing more about this :0
Click to expand...
it is a collection of small things tbh
- her thoughts seem to be extremely reactive and against the grain, and not in a good way
- the fact that she threw shade on kyeugh for vigspeccing (when it was VM who pressed her to explain her thoughts) and then a few pages after, completely out of nowhere, claimed that there is indeed a vig between her and VM pings me in a terrible way
- if my megatinfoil is right (which is seeping into my brain by the minute and will probably only be shaken off once rnp flips red), tofu is maf
 
Tofu said:
As would I... I gave my reasons for voting. Rnp annoyed and confused me and I wanted to hear others' opinions.
Click to expand...
oh and by the way wasn’t it you who was staunchily against sciencevoting right until sciencevoting rnp? (apologies if i’m misremembering)
 
rari_teh said:
- her thoughts seem to be extremely reactive and against the grain, and not in a good way
Click to expand...
How is this scummy to you / can you point at specific examples? To my mind, stubbornly acting against the grain draws attention in a way that a newer mafia is more likely to avoid. And how do you factor in her vote on Ultracool?

I guess my POV is there doesn't seem like a ton of reason for me to distrust VM's read on her atm.
 
Keldeo said:
rari_teh said:
- her thoughts seem to be extremely reactive and against the grain, and not in a good way
Click to expand...
How is this scummy to you / can you point at specific examples? To my mind, stubbornly acting against the grain draws attention in a way that a newer mafia is more likely to avoid. And how do you factor in her vote on Ultracool?
Click to expand...
her vote on ultracool could just as well be bussing or distancing tbh

now wrt specific examples:
Tofu said:
I'm wondering why the same small handful of people are dominating the discussion. Boredom is a valid reason, but I see more investment in this. I read that much investment as suspicious, because it gives the power to a smaller group of people who are able to influence others by just being more vocal, which seems like a mafia-y thing to do. I would like to hear from some others who have managed to follow the discussion.

There are 17 people alive.

I'm side-eying Mewtini and Skylar at this point.

Btw, why would posting slightly or more or less memes mean anything lmao
Click to expand...
i formerly saw this as excited!newbie townie looking for mafia, but i’m increasingly seeing this more like excited!newbie mafia fishing for improbable wagons, in the same way that ultracool was doing with kyeugh and others D1
Tofu said:
Most of what I have seen of people defending Skylar has been "oh, hypocop" and, while I get why people do that, it irritates me because clearly not everyone is a cop and it's like an excuse to just give a name with no reasoning under the guise of covering for the real cop. Information without reason makes me suspicious, and why are so many people doing it for the same person?
[…]
I read it as just an interesting post trying to figure out probabilities, when at that point we had limited information (and, we still do). Because of that post, I think it helped me to gain perspective on what we could be dealing with in the game, and, while I think vm is rightly suspicious of Skylar, I don't think the numbers were meant to be a clear indication but were just for like, interest/observation (which is what we're supposed to be doing, right...) To me it looks like it's being skewed and not being looked at objectively.
Click to expand...
this feels like an extremely pushy attempt to fuel kyeugh’s wagon, as in speaking about subjective stuff as if it was objective, if that makes sense

there’s probably more, but i think that’s enough for now. tell me if i’m wrong
 
Hey devil's advocate, why would RNP claim to have jailed Emmy if the conclusion is that this situation is more likely if he's mafia? Like Emmy isn't gonna get suspected, so just for kicks, or so that someone would make this argument, or because the plan around mewtini's heal was still opaque?
 
i have some feelings on this but need to substantiate them a bit (have been playing very lazily since midyesterday) but fwiw i think at least one of the wolves is going to be like. 'findable' or conspicuous looking ... i'm probably getting sucked into confbiasing everyone/getting triggerhappy i think but i think falling into the "they seem towny" trap works for like everyone in my PoE/nonclear pile right now haha. does that make sense?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom