Cats (2019) Mafia

[rari_teh]

but like. the town protective power if true. :|

btw no one has counterclaimed doctor

by which i mean. idk why the "maybe ILS wasn't really doctor" thing continues on when the doctor probably should have counterclaimed to send herbe into the wolfgrave by now. as it stands we have no reason to believe that the proposition, if rnp is v, is doctor + partial heal + jailer, which doesn't fit in 14-player

there would be no real doctor to counterclaim in that scenario :P

 

[mewtini]

so even if herbe is wolf, i think that ILS was probably just the doctor, meaning that rnp is still the most sensical lynch. i think?

he was extremely solvy there and barely trolling at all

i think this depends on who coaches him/what his mindstate is. stryke wasn't even in that game lol

 

[mewtini]

there would be no real doctor to counterclaim in that scenario :P

are you proposing that it would just be me and a jailer as town healing?

 

[rari_teh]

that does read like someone that is thinking about wolf strategy in a way that I think wouldn't come naturally to a villager, even though maybe it depends on the type of player.

this isn’t valid imo
you can easily conjecture about how a wolf would think without being wolf yourself bc people aren’t villa/wolf for life

Sure, but I don't think it's probable. I don't think of wolf strategy when I'm town nearly as much as I do when I'm a wolf, so I'm less likely to make posts speculating about it.

in this case

maybe it depends on the type of player

 

[rari_teh]

there would be no real doctor to counterclaim in that scenario :P

are you proposing that it would just be me and a jailer as town healing?

ayup

 

[kyeugh]

there would be no real doctor to counterclaim in that scenario :P

are you proposing that it would just be me and a jailer as town healing?

that would be my assumption

 

[mewtini]

we're both nerfed though :|

 

[mewtini]

ugh my head hurts

 

[mewtini]

ok. i see. thought i was on to something there.
i still feel like it's more likely that it's just me + a doctor but maybe i'm just clinging onto conventional roles at that point

 

[Tangrowth]

that does read like someone that is thinking about wolf strategy in a way that I think wouldn't come naturally to a villager, even though maybe it depends on the type of player.

this isn’t valid imo
you can easily conjecture about how a wolf would think without being wolf yourself bc people aren’t villa/wolf for life

Sure, but I don't think it's probable. I don't think of wolf strategy when I'm town nearly as much as I do when I'm a wolf, so I'm less likely to make posts speculating about it.

in this case

maybe it depends on the type of player

For sure, it's possible. I can tell RNP approaches the game differently enough from the way I do that I wouldn't necessarily know what he's doing here, but it's still a consideration.

 

[Keldeo]

unvote

mmm

 

[kyeugh]

we're both nerfed though :|

that's why there are two of you

 

[rari_teh]

i’d say two nerfed doctors is enough for ten townies tbh

 

[Vipera Magnifica]

is there even another wagon rn or is it just rnp

 

[mewtini]

lol. yes. gdi i miss my blind resolve

 

[Tangrowth]

that does read like someone that is thinking about wolf strategy in a way that I think wouldn't come naturally to a villager, even though maybe it depends on the type of player.

this isn’t valid imo
you can easily conjecture about how a wolf would think without being wolf yourself bc people aren’t villa/wolf for life

Sure, but I don't think it's probable. I don't think of wolf strategy when I'm town nearly as much as I do when I'm a wolf, so I'm less likely to make posts speculating about it.

in this case

maybe it depends on the type of player

For sure, it's possible. I can tell RNP approaches the game differently enough from the way I do that I wouldn't necessarily know what he's doing here, but it's still a consideration.

Herbe about RNP, sorry, derp alert. I need more coffee.

 

[Keldeo]

is there even another wagon rn or is it just rnp

I was going to vote up MP7 as counterwagon but I actually like the conviction/analysis in his posts well enough here

aaargh

 

[mewtini]

is there even another wagon rn or is it just rnp

it's pretty much just rnp ...

 

[rari_teh]

is there even another wagon rn or is it just rnp

he’s the only one with more than one

 

[Tangrowth]

is there even another wagon rn or is it just rnp

I was going to vote up MP7 as counterwagon but I actually like the conviction/analysis in his posts well enough here

aaargh

How dare you.