Cats (2019) Mafia

[Trebek]

actually, maybe 3 if we have to account for 5 mafia

hahahaha are you just saying "my claim is real" because respect tbh. i love to see it

maybe

 

[Bluwiikoon]

I shoulda pretended I was the healer so mafia woulda stabbed me instead of someone actually important :-( But then again, my Big Brain Plays haven't exactly been the best for me (lol emmy!alienposting)

 

[Trebek]

it would be surprising to me if Jack ruled that a one-shot role getting blocked, still used up the shot

i asked him about this and haven’t received a response yet, but i did use my power once which is supposed to be how many times i’m allowed to use it, so i’m just assuming it’s used up tbh

and if not, well. it seems unlikely to me that i will get to use it anyway now that the Cat (2019) is out of the bag

if you use it next Night and get simultaneously killed i am inclined to believe that the revival is going to go through tbh

i believe so yeah, i’m actually not limited to using it at night (if i’m interpreting the role pm correctly); it just doesn’t revive the player until the following day phase

how would this interact with role block? like you submit it during the day, and then get roleblocked the next night?

 

[Trebek]

maybe i’m overthinking it but that feels like a bit of a contradiction

 

[rari_teh]

it would be surprising to me if Jack ruled that a one-shot role getting blocked, still used up the shot

i asked him about this and haven’t received a response yet, but i did use my power once which is supposed to be how many times i’m allowed to use it, so i’m just assuming it’s used up tbh

and if not, well. it seems unlikely to me that i will get to use it anyway now that the Cat (2019) is out of the bag

if you use it next Night and get simultaneously killed i am inclined to believe that the revival is going to go through tbh

i believe so yeah, i’m actually not limited to using it at night (if i’m interpreting the role pm correctly); it just doesn’t revive the player until the following day phase

how would this interact with role block? like you submit it during the day, and then get roleblocked the next night?

if it’s the same as it was in tvt, she would have to be blocked the previous night

 

[rari_teh]

it would be surprising to me if Jack ruled that a one-shot role getting blocked, still used up the shot

i asked him about this and haven’t received a response yet, but i did use my power once which is supposed to be how many times i’m allowed to use it, so i’m just assuming it’s used up tbh

and if not, well. it seems unlikely to me that i will get to use it anyway now that the Cat (2019) is out of the bag

if you use it next Night and get simultaneously killed i am inclined to believe that the revival is going to go through tbh

i believe so yeah, i’m actually not limited to using it at night (if i’m interpreting the role pm correctly); it just doesn’t revive the player until the following day phase

how would this interact with role block? like you submit it during the day, and then get roleblocked the next night?

if it’s the same as it was in tvt, she would have to be blocked the previous night

…oh.

 

[Trebek]

it would be surprising to me if Jack ruled that a one-shot role getting blocked, still used up the shot

i asked him about this and haven’t received a response yet, but i did use my power once which is supposed to be how many times i’m allowed to use it, so i’m just assuming it’s used up tbh

and if not, well. it seems unlikely to me that i will get to use it anyway now that the Cat (2019) is out of the bag

if you use it next Night and get simultaneously killed i am inclined to believe that the revival is going to go through tbh

i believe so yeah, i’m actually not limited to using it at night (if i’m interpreting the role pm correctly); it just doesn’t revive the player until the following day phase

how would this interact with role block? like you submit it during the day, and then get roleblocked the next night?

if it’s the same as it was in tvt, she would have to be blocked the previous night

as in if she was blocked last night, she can’t revive during this day?

 

[mewtini]

if it’s the same as it was in tvt, she would have to be blocked the previous night

wait but

 

[mewtini]

…oh.

lol ninjad

 

[Trebek]

oh wait did you guys think of something i didn’t lmao

 

[mewtini]

i was just thinking "if she were blocked during the night and it didn't work, then she shouldn't be able to retry during the dayphase" but then i got confused and didn't say anything else other than 'wait' heh

 

[mewtini]

if that's what y'all are thinking

 

[mewtini]

if that's what y'all are thinking

oh. reading other people's posts helps. yes we are all on the same page.

 

[rari_teh]

that’s what i was thinking too, to be clear

 

[Trebek]

i wasn’t actually thinking that far ahead, i was just pinged by the combination of “i can use my action during the day” and “oh hecc i got roleblocked last night”

 

[mewtini]

get on our level ryan

 

[Trebek]

i’m Sorry i cant have Out of Thread Communication ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

 

[mewtini]

we can have it too, it would just be illegal. <3

 

[kyeugh]

it is also possible i’m misreading it, specifically the role pm uses the verbiage “at any point in the game” but that might refer to, like, when i’m allowed to use it/when the target has to have died to be a valid target/i am just reading way too much into it

 

[rari_teh]

it is also possible i’m misreading it, specifically the role pm uses the verbiage “at any point in the game” but that might refer to, like, when i’m allowed to use it/when the target has to have died to be a valid target/i am just reading way too much into it

i would understand this as “regardless of the Time of the Day” as well tbqh