• Welcome to The Cave of Dragonflies forums, where the smallest bugs live alongside the strongest dragons.

    Guests are not able to post messages or even read certain areas of the forums. Now, that's boring, don't you think? Registration, on the other hand, is simple, completely free of charge, and does not require you to give out any personal information at all. As soon as you register, you can take part in some of the happy fun things at the forums such as posting messages, voting in polls, sending private messages to people and being told that this is where we drink tea and eat cod.

    Of course I'm not forcing you to do anything if you don't want to, but seriously, what have you got to lose? Five seconds of your life?

Cats (2019) Mafia

@Butterfree can i ask if there’s anywhere you /do/ want to vote?

i am actually gone mostly fr right now but yeah.
@Tofu since you know vm’s role, does it seem consistent to you wrt how he’s been playing? i guess you’ll probably say yeah but i figure i should ask

ultracool
 
so um, this is not even slightly what I was expecting to come back to, but?

Seems people have pretty much verified Emmy's claim already so I don't really have much more to add to that, but I'd like to remind everyone that Jack explicitly said this game would not have the healer clash mechanic, so if there are doctor(s), please don't second-guess yourself about healing her, just do it!

regarding other people:
  • I... don't really see why people are looking at Tofu? even for Science(tm)? nothing she's said has been remotely antitown and then there's the whole thing with being unable to hide from VM as well
  • herbe as rolecop is an interesting one! I agree it's usually a mafia role but presumably he knows that too and would want avoid the scrutiny? that is, in the world where herbe is mafia, I don't think he claims? (unless wifom)
  • Butterfree, you say you're basically a "one-shot vig" after your partner dies. Does that mean you get to choose who you kill after being told you can do so? Because the version in the rules sticky says fishing brothers pick their targets in advance and immediately kill them if the other dies, which isn't quite the same thing. Just trying to get a feel for how strong this role is.
  • after doing some re-reading, I am not really vibing any more with VM's thing about kyeugh. while, yes, she looks a bit odd when you look at the votes in isolation, she wasn't actually tunnelling a great deal, it was more just sort of flitting around trying to start conversations / get people to talk. and toDay she's basically just been doing more of the same, just without the votes
  • i shall restrain myself from voting for RNP on principle because I did the same thing last game and it didn't go well for town
(this is post is shorter and later than usual because I spent all day playing Wargroove, oops. please understand. will try to be more present irl-tomorrow)
 
kokorico said:
Butterfree, you say you're basically a "one-shot vig" after your partner dies. Does that mean you get to choose who you kill after being told you can do so? Because the version in the rules sticky says fishing brothers pick their targets in advance and immediately kill them if the other dies, which isn't quite the same thing. Just trying to get a feel for how strong this role is.
Click to expand...
It's set up slightly differently here than in the mafia rules sticky; I get to choose a player to kill during the next night phase after my partner dies.
 
kokorico said:
because I spent all day playing Wargroove
Click to expand...
understandable have a nice day
kokorico said:
nothing she's said has been remotely antitown and then there's the whole thing with being unable to hide from VM as well
Click to expand...
i disagree tbh, but also like. is anyone jumping out at you as antitown? i’m getting ok vibes at minimum from basically everyone so i don’t think that can be the standard upon which we base our votes
 
mewtini said:
@Butterfree can i ask if there’s anywhere you /do/ want to vote?
Click to expand...
Probably VM if anyone at the moment; he's the one person who's done something I've found kind of concretely dodgy. I think I can probably buy that ILS was just thinking of the stage show, but haven't actually gone through his posts otherwise to see how I feel about him, and I'd still really like to reread Trebek and Superjolt, and possibly kyeugh. I will do my best tomorrow, dunno if I'll get through all of them.
 
I have VM as town so I'm slightly willing to trust the Tofu read but also I'm painfully aware of how easy it is for someone to pocket you if you're close with them (thanks @Seshas)

otherwise I suppose the only one in qva's list that I'd doubt is keldeo because a) he's a good wolf and b) I've read like, none of his posts so
 
Butterfree said:
kokorico said:
Butterfree, you say you're basically a "one-shot vig" after your partner dies. Does that mean you get to choose who you kill after being told you can do so? Because the version in the rules sticky says fishing brothers pick their targets in advance and immediately kill them if the other dies, which isn't quite the same thing. Just trying to get a feel for how strong this role is.
Click to expand...
It's set up slightly differently here than in the mafia rules sticky; I get to choose a player to kill during the next night phase after my partner dies.
Click to expand...
oh, that's good! means you (or your partner) get more information to plan your kill with!

kyeugh said:
is anyone jumping out at you as antitown? i’m getting ok vibes at minimum from basically everyone so i don’t think that can be the standard upon which we base our votes
Click to expand...
this is true. I too have a disappointing lack of scumreads

if we assume there's at least one or two wolves among the most active players, as VM (IIRC?) suggested, then I think PoE suggests Keldeo? but I don't really like that either - he's playing virtually identically to last game (except the trebekkening)

at the moment I think the best option is one of the relatively inactives/lurkers, like ultracool or maybe M+7?

it also occurs to me that mist hasn't actually said anything game-related yet since subbing in despite being online and acknowledging the thread
 
kokorico said:
if we assume there's at least one or two wolves among the most active players, as VM (IIRC?) suggested, then I think PoE suggests Keldeo? but I don't really like that either - he's playing virtually identically to last game (except the trebekkening)
Click to expand...
mm, fair point... tbh the last couple posts are making me think i really need to look closer at keldeo. it didn’t even occur to me that everyone on my list of six is pretty much inactive.

i’m going to reread his iso. my vote might end up here later. thinking about it now i think his iso was pretty weird, and i also wonder if he’s trying to pocket me on purpose.
 
I got a hypocop green on Keldeo so that's the sum of my feelings rn, in addition to my green on mewtini.

Is it mainly the alien stuff that makes you suspect me?
 
ok, hi. going to make a big push to catch up tonight, probably starting with the developments of earlier/when i was rapidfire posting, so that i'm #current going into EoD and hopefully i will not stay up until 4am today. fingers crossed bro.
 
I'm also here and catching up! It turns out "not playing mafia for a few hours" is an effective home remedy for mild headaches :p

re: posts on this page, @kyeugh @kokorico and also @Butterfree iirc - is there something specific I've done that you have an issue with, or is it more like, I've just not done enough for you to townread me and you're scared of my mafia game? If it's the latter, I guess that's fair (if a little frustrating lol) but if it's the former, I'd like to address it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom