• Welcome to The Cave of Dragonflies forums, where the smallest bugs live alongside the strongest dragons.

    Guests are not able to post messages or even read certain areas of the forums. Now, that's boring, don't you think? Registration, on the other hand, is simple, completely free of charge, and does not require you to give out any personal information at all. As soon as you register, you can take part in some of the happy fun things at the forums such as posting messages, voting in polls, sending private messages to people and being told that this is where we drink tea and eat cod.

    Of course I'm not forcing you to do anything if you don't want to, but seriously, what have you got to lose? Five seconds of your life?

Forum Revival TV Tropes Mafia Revival - D7

Deja Vu, Deja Vu

I think this fairly clears Panini, though I haven't seen the archetype of EoD4 in a game where I was paying attention to it so
 
I liek Squirtles (5) (Herbe, Keldeo, Mawile, Negrek, mewtini)
Ottercopter (4) (I liek Squirtles, Seshas, kyeugh, rari_teh)
(abstain) (3) (Mr. Ultracool, Ottercopter, serimachi)
Panini (2) (Boquise, Eifie)
Eifie (1) (M&F)
Keldeo (1) (Mist1422)
Odie_Pie (1) (Panini)
kyeugh (1) (RedneckPhoenix)
[JackPK] (1) (Vipera Magnifica)
No vote (6) (Flora, Stryke, IndigoEmmy, Odie_Pie, kokorico)

Let's play a game called find the scum
I never thought I'd say this but: I think Mawile spews Herbe non-Mafia here
This VC doesn't say much about kyeugh/Vipera, which is mostly what I was looking for
 
Butterfree said:
ALL RIGHT I am caught up sorry about that thank you for being a wild ride

Here's a vote count, day will end at 1:30 UTC (in ~20 minutes).

Keldeo votes Ottercopter (#1488)
Keldeo unvotes (#1550)
Eifie votes Panini (#1577)
Keldeo votes Panini (#1882)
Mist1422 votes Panini (#1940)
Herbe votes serimachi (#2001)
Eifie unvotes (#2101)
Keldeo unvotes (#2131)
Herbe unvotes (#2155)
Eifie votes Mawile (#2177)
Herbe votes serimachi (#2179)
M&F votes Keldeo (#2210)
rari_teh votes Mawile (#2215)
IndigoEmmy votes Mawile (#2216)
Herbe unvotes (#2251)
Herbe votes Stryke (#2259)
IndigoEmmy votes Stryke (#2261)
M&F votes Stryke (#2311)
Panini votes Mist1422 (#2356)
kokorico votes serimachi (#2357)
kyeugh votes Odie_Pie (#2404)
mewtini votes Mawile (#2407)
kokorico votes Odie_Pie (#2429)
Mawile votes Odie_Pie (#2434)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2435)
Herbe votes Odie_Pie (#2436)
kyeugh votes Mawile (#2439)
Stryke votes Odie_Pie (#2441)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2446)
Ottercopter votes Odie_Pie (#2451)
mewtini votes Mawile (#2466)
Panini votes Mawile (#2479)
Keldeo votes Mawile (#2495)
Negrek votes Odie_Pie (#2547)
Ottercopter votes Mawile (#2579)
Eifie votes Odie_Pie (#2612)
Ottercopter votes Odie_Pie (#2614)
Keldeo votes Odie_Pie (#2619)
Panini votes Odie_Pie (#2621)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2624)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2638)
rari_teh votes Stryke (#2643)
Seshas votes Stryke (#2702)
Herbe votes Stryke (#2705)
mewtini unvotes (#2713)
rari_teh votes Odie_Pie (#2716)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2718)
rari_teh votes Mawile (#2720)
Keldeo votes Stryke (#2722)
rari_teh votes Stryke (#2739)
kokorico votes Stryke (#2740)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2741)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2765)
Keldeo votes Odie_Pie (#2787)
Panini votes Stryke (#2806)
Panini votes Odie_Pie (#2819)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2821)

Vote counts:
Odie_Pie (8) (Eifie, Keldeo, Mawile, Negrek, Ottercopter, Panini, Stryke, mewtini)
Stryke (6) (Herbe, IndigoEmmy, M&F, Seshas, kokorico, rari_teh)
Panini (1) (Mist1422)
Mawile (1) (kyeugh)
No vote (9) (Flora, serimachi, RedneckPhoenix, Vipera Magnifica, Mr. Ultracool, Odie_Pie)
Click to expand...

I'll probably reconstruct a previous votecount at the peak of the Mawile wagon later
 
Keldeo votes Ottercopter (#1488)
Keldeo unvotes (#1550)
Eifie votes Panini (#1577)
Keldeo votes Panini (#1882)
Mist1422 votes Panini (#1940)
Herbe votes serimachi (#2001)
Eifie unvotes (#2101)
Keldeo unvotes (#2131)
Herbe unvotes (#2155)
Eifie votes Mawile (#2177)
Herbe votes serimachi (#2179)
M&F votes Keldeo (#2210)
rari_teh votes Mawile (#2215)
IndigoEmmy votes Mawile (#2216)
Herbe unvotes (#2251)
Herbe votes Stryke (#2259)
IndigoEmmy votes Stryke (#2261)
M&F votes Stryke (#2311)
Panini votes Mist1422 (#2356)
kokorico votes serimachi (#2357)
kyeugh votes Odie_Pie (#2404)
mewtini votes Mawile (#2407)
kokorico votes Odie_Pie (#2429)
Mawile votes Odie_Pie (#2434)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2435)
Herbe votes Odie_Pie (#2436)
kyeugh votes Mawile (#2439)
Stryke votes Odie_Pie (#2441)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2446)
Ottercopter votes Odie_Pie (#2451)
mewtini votes Mawile (#2466)
Panini votes Mawile (#2479)
Keldeo votes Mawile (#2495)
Negrek votes Odie_Pie (#2547)
Ottercopter votes Mawile (#2579)
Eifie votes Odie_Pie (#2612)
Ottercopter votes Odie_Pie (#2614)
Keldeo votes Odie_Pie (#2619)
Panini votes Odie_Pie (#2621)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2624)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2638)
rari_teh votes Stryke (#2643)
Seshas votes Stryke (#2702)
Herbe votes Stryke (#2705)
mewtini unvotes (#2713)
rari_teh votes Odie_Pie (#2716)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2718)
rari_teh votes Mawile (#2720)
Keldeo votes Stryke (#2722)
rari_teh votes Stryke (#2739)
kokorico votes Stryke (#2740)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2741)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2765)
Keldeo votes Odie_Pie (#2787)
Panini votes Stryke (#2806)
Panini votes Odie_Pie (#2819)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2821)
kyeugh votes Odie_Pie (#2849)

A veritable rainbow
 
well if you really wanted to know I'm an alien, which is a jester that can only win upon being attacked

I was banking on getting vigged last night and getting lynched for surviving but it didn't work out
 
Town has no Vigilantes
Mafia has no incentive to kill you

Cop softed a redcheck on you
You have high Mafia Equity

As a result, you are getting lynched
On the off chance you are Alien, you lost anyways, and you have no incentive to vote with Town
 
Seshas said:
Keldeo votes Ottercopter (#1488)
Keldeo unvotes (#1550)
Eifie votes Panini (#1577)
Keldeo votes Panini (#1882)
Mist1422 votes Panini (#1940)
Herbe votes serimachi (#2001)
Eifie unvotes (#2101)
Keldeo unvotes (#2131)
Herbe unvotes (#2155)
Eifie votes Mawile (#2177)
Herbe votes serimachi (#2179)
M&F votes Keldeo (#2210)
rari_teh votes Mawile (#2215)
IndigoEmmy votes Mawile (#2216)
Herbe unvotes (#2251)
Herbe votes Stryke (#2259)
IndigoEmmy votes Stryke (#2261)
M&F votes Stryke (#2311)
Panini votes Mist1422 (#2356)
kokorico votes serimachi (#2357)
kyeugh votes Odie_Pie (#2404)
mewtini votes Mawile (#2407)
kokorico votes Odie_Pie (#2429)
Mawile votes Odie_Pie (#2434)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2435)
Herbe votes Odie_Pie (#2436)
kyeugh votes Mawile (#2439)
Stryke votes Odie_Pie (#2441)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2446)
Ottercopter votes Odie_Pie (#2451)
mewtini votes Mawile (#2466)
Panini votes Mawile (#2479)
Keldeo votes Mawile (#2495)
Negrek votes Odie_Pie (#2547)
Ottercopter votes Mawile (#2579)
Eifie votes Odie_Pie (#2612)
Ottercopter votes Odie_Pie (#2614)
Keldeo votes Odie_Pie (#2619)
Panini votes Odie_Pie (#2621)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2624)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2638)
rari_teh votes Stryke (#2643)
Seshas votes Stryke (#2702)
Herbe votes Stryke (#2705)
mewtini unvotes (#2713)
rari_teh votes Odie_Pie (#2716)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2718)
rari_teh votes Mawile (#2720)
Keldeo votes Stryke (#2722)
rari_teh votes Stryke (#2739)
kokorico votes Stryke (#2740)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2741)
mewtini votes Stryke (#2765)
Keldeo votes Odie_Pie (#2787)
Panini votes Stryke (#2806)
Panini votes Odie_Pie (#2819)
mewtini votes Odie_Pie (#2821)
kyeugh votes Odie_Pie (#2849)

A veritable rainbow
Click to expand...
Kyeugh comes off this looking townie
Emmy comes off loking a bit worse
 
serimachi said:
Hi, guys. First time player here.

Obviously Eifie is acting incredibly suspicious, and this isn't her first rodeo. Hypotheses (in order of how likely I think they are):
  1. She's an alien, or some other role that benefits by being lynched
  2. She's just acting in character for a trope, or this is just her regular sense of humor
  3. She's wants us to think she is so obviously an alien or some other role that benefits from being lynched, so that we don't lynch her
  4. Something I'm missing or misunderstanding about the game
If she's not distributing powers completely randomly, I think we should also consider that Butterfree might give the most powerful/important/interesting roles to experienced players or people she trusts, so as to keep the game interesting. This casts a little more doubt on Eifie and the likes of Negrek, mewtini, and other long-time forum go-ers. It's likely that one of them is the boss of the mafia.

I really have no idea about the death or the circumstances of the death, those are just my thoughts so far. I agree that based on the flavour text, JackPK doesn't seem like Mafia.

Also, I didn't count on how it would genuinely make a part of me feel gross to vote on people to kill! :ROFLMAO: I'll abstain based on no good grounds to suspect anyone, unless someone explains to me why that's a bad idea.
Click to expand...
serimachi said:
Keldeo said:
In what way do you mean, just asking to be lynched or something else? (I will also chime in that this is her normal sense of humor - just trying to get a sense of how you're thinking here.)
Click to expand...

Haha, well just in the first few pages, right?

Eifie said:
I volunteer to be lynched!
Click to expand...
Eifie said:
I personally am in my element when surrounded by corpses and blood. Ooh, death...
Click to expand...
Eifie said:
Oh. We'll need to fix that. 🗡
Click to expand...
Eifie said:
you think I do my own killing? how crass...
Click to expand...

Now don't get me wrong, it is hilarious. But could it be something more..? 🤔
Click to expand...
serimachi said:
I'll assume bad townlean means you guys are skeptical about me being an innocent. I don't know if it's a good idea to reveal power even in general terms, but I can see already some people have. Can anyone experienced in the game tell me when that's a good idea?
Click to expand...
serimachi said:
Hi! Didn't notice Day 2 had started--figured it'd be in another thread.

Um, how do you guys find so much to speculate about? :ROFLMAO: I mean literally dozens of pages worth of speculation! I still feel like there's very little evidence of anything right now. We have some hints of people with powers who are probably not Mafia, but that's as solid as I feel about anything (and even that could just be trickery).

I mean, I'm aware that I'm really inexperienced and the fact that I feel like we have very little to go on is probably just a consequence of that. But I just find it all very tough to follow.
Click to expand...
serimachi said:
Aww, shoot. Now I feel bad that I ever mentioned suspecting Eifie. :confused: It sounds like she was an important role, too, and not an alien or something like I suspected.

Out of general curiosity, and something I've been wondering, is it allowed for more than one person to have the same role?
Click to expand...
every single post made by serimachi
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom