Forum Revival TV Tropes Mafia Revival - D7

[Ottercopter]

We should probably only get roleclaims from people about to die unless they have something immediately useful, right? Otherwise we're just narrowing down the field of cops, doctors, and other roles that the mafia's definitely gonna want to kill.

 

[mewtini]

that is also why i said he shouldn't feel the need to right now. i think it's likely that things tighten up a bit soon and the voting veers somewhere wild :|

 

[Eifie]

Sure, but on principle I don't think it would be great for him to claim unless he's dying for sure, and the wagons are super loose right now. Does that make sense?

Like Stryke can claim now if he wants, but I don't want him to have to reveal that info if it's not actually useful to us.

meh idk, it's not like if he doesn't get lynched today we aren't still going to want to resolve him tomorrow

 

[kyeugh]

odie_pie
i think i would’ve laid my case on rari out toDay if i knew it was going to be so uneventful
might fuck around and do it tomorrow

 

[qenya]

meh idk, it's not like if he doesn't get lynched today we aren't still going to want to resolve him tomorrow

but surely it would then be better to have the information tomorrow, after mafia do their nightkill?

 

[kyeugh]

someone should tell me why i should vote mawile over odie

 

[mewtini]

mawile (p much with the intent of keeping the top 2 wagons even for now; might switch later)

this puts us at

(3) Stryke: Herbe, IndigoEmmy, M&F
(3) Mawile: Eifie, rari_teh, mewtini
(1) Panini: Mist
(1) Mist1422: Panini
(1) serimachi: kokorico
(1) odie_pie: kyeugh

 

[Panini]

meh idk, it's not like if he doesn't get lynched today we aren't still going to want to resolve him tomorrow

hm still feels unnecessary if we're not going to end there, one unouted night can make a big difference depending on what it is?

On the other I get not wanting to repeat what happened to ILS so maybe a middle ground is best

 

[Eifie]

but surely it would then be better to have the information tomorrow, after mafia do their nightkill?

I suppose

I'm just bored and feel like I'm waiting an hour for the inevitable

 

[kyeugh]

I suppose

I'm just bored and feel like I'm waiting an hour for the inevitable

the wagons are random! there’s no such thing as inevitable!

 

[Ottercopter]

Is there a good reason not to do say it now, Kyeugh? Even if we don't wanna start a last minute rari_teh wagon, we never know if you'll end up dead tomorrow before you can say it.

meh idk, it's not like if he doesn't get lynched today we aren't still going to want to resolve him tomorrow

Yeah, but tomorrow's a new day with at least sooooome new information in theory. It's another night for a theoretical cop to add to their list of inspected people or whatever.

God, i still dunno who to nominate today...

 

[kyeugh]

panini and mist sitting on their votes for each other is weird

 

[mewtini]

someone should tell me why i should vote mawile over odie

i think the best point i've seen (still tenuous) is what you said, about how mawile feels more unresolvably uncomfortable and untrustworthy than others. other than that i still am more pro-odie and that might be my top preference rn, just waiting to see if it gains any traction ://

 

[mewtini]

Is there a good reason not to do say it now, Kyeugh? Even if we don't wanna start a last minute rari_teh wagon, we never know if you'll end up dead tomorrow before you can say it.

:C

 

[kyeugh]

Is there a good reason not to do say it now, Kyeugh? Even if we don't wanna start a last minute rari_teh wagon, we never know if you'll end up dead tomorrow before you can say it.

i don’t want to type it on my phone tbh. if i die overnight you know rari killed me! dohohohoh!

 

[Herbe]

just waiting to see if it gains any traction ://

tbh im only staying on stryke rn to keep the wagons even, but if you want to flip to odie w me (my preference anyway) then im down mewtini

 

[Panini]

panini and mist sitting on their votes for each other is weird

If you make me pick between Mawile and Stryke I probably go Mawile > Stryke but I don't feel confident in either and would rather go here or Odie

Part of the reason I don't feel good about Chemist is because he's been sitting on me all day without really explaining himself so

 

[kyeugh]

if you do that i’ll probably go to mawile tbh

 

[Ottercopter]

For the record, not advocating a last minute lynch wagon for a non-Odie, Mawile, or Stryke person. I think we should stick to what we've decided at this point and not try to introduce someone new based on last minute panic if we don't have time to think it over???

 

[Keldeo]

I don't know how to process Mawile's self-consciousness and focus on optics. I honestly think the fact that he's talking openly about it is pretty towny, but I don't... have much of an opinion on his thoughts overall? So I can see what Eifie et al. are saying about him remaining like very null for everyone.

For what it's worth, I spend a fair amount of time (when I'm actually online) reading the thread and typing up a post and then I get cold feet because I get worried that it sounds too much like someone else's post and then people will be even more suspicious of me. And then I delete the post and usually post a meme instead :x