Forum Revival TV Tropes Mafia Revival - D7

[Herbe]

I have to help my mom w/ getting our house ready for a showing so I'm not really gonna be here but if discussion has already stalled, then I guess it's whatever. Honestly I can't wait to get into deadchat lmao. Peace!

 

[IndigoClaudia]

bye herbe

 

[mewtini]

if they’re w/w then mawile didn’t have to target herbe, the whole thing would be made up

oh gotcha. sorry. i totally just didn't understand, thought we were all assuming ingroup-mawile so i got confused :p

mewtini claiming to be a 3p protector

protector?

also, man. to be clear, i was being genuine when i said my herbe attachment is just a tone thing. if he flips scum i'll understand being sussed, i guess, but i also don't think i ever would have claimed or broken my role-silence as mafia there when i'm in everyone's town pile ... not even to curry points! i feel like if i were to make a bogus claim at this point in the game, i would've tried to cook something up that could defend herbe? (tbh idk how i would have done it. but not like that.)

maybe i stuck with talking about herbe for too long, i just gut-felt like he was 3p. sorry tbh. i always wanted to lynch him above flora/seri today, and maybe i didn't make that obvious enough. :P

herbe

 

[mewtini]

tbh this probably just sounds like a retcon but now that i'm thinking about it harder, i can understand herbe executing the kills that have happened and could see his VM talk as an effort to seem comfortable/relaxed. i got pocketed really hard by his early game and i probably will shame-drop out if he flips wolf lol but it does by far make the most sense, i think i let myself avoid dealing with it because everyone else seemed mostly lukewarm about it ... i'm actually kind of sorry. the more objectively i think about it, the more i think herbe is probably a wolf

non-herbe possibilities are flora/seri/emmy/seshas/skylar
- assuming herbe flips red, the remaining w/w team is between flora/seri/seshas (skylar sussed him, emmy pretty easily followed vote) and i think it easily becomes either seshas/seri or seshas/flora
- if he doesn't, then no one gets crossed off of that suspect list. i think?

 

[IndigoClaudia]

i haven't been super involved today. But yeah hang herbe.

 

[Zori]

the herbe wagon is making me slightly uncomfortable

 

[IndigoClaudia]

why?

 

[Zori]

just like
everyone: /vote herbe

if herbe is mafia
she ideally has a mafia buddy

 

[IndigoClaudia]

she

(herbe is a guy)

 

[Zori]

frick

 

[IndigoClaudia]

theres no editing it on mafia so if you delete it i won't tell herbe.

 

[IndigoClaudia]

as well as deleting my posts too.

 

[Zori]

frick

sorry

anyways

the solution I was initally thinking of was that they were trying to go in deep
but it's not ottercopter because iirc ottercopter had no reason to start the wagon when they could coast on Flora

 

[mewtini]

idrk what to do because i do think objectively/mathematically it could point to herbe, i just don't want to believe it :T and it probably does make more sense to go down that route than to go with serimachi. sorry if i sounded defensive tbh.

if herbe is mafia
he ideally has a mafia buddy

if we were to assume that there's mafia on the wagon thus far, of the list it would be emmy/skylar distancing (more likely emmy)

 

[IndigoClaudia]

(more likely emmy)

I disagree. If i were mafia, you would know because i'm almost brand new to mafia.

 

[mewtini]

I disagree. If i were mafia, you would know because i'm almost brand new to mafia.

my point is that if skylar were mafia voting for herbe, it would be weird since her push seems more earnest than hypothetical-mafia you just following a vote

i'm not talking about the game overall rn

 

[mewtini]

i'm not sincerely pushing you as mafia at the moment though

 

[IndigoClaudia]

That is good to know.
Mark my words if i get hanged my ghost will tell you all "I told you so"

 

[kyeugh]

tbh this probably just sounds like a retcon but now that i'm thinking about it harder, i can understand herbe executing the kills that have happened and could see his VM talk as an effort to seem comfortable/relaxed. i got pocketed really hard by his early game and i probably will shame-drop out if he flips wolf lol but it does by far make the most sense, i think i let myself avoid dealing with it because everyone else seemed mostly lukewarm about it ... i'm actually kind of sorry. the more objectively i think about it, the more i think herbe is probably a wolf

non-herbe possibilities are flora/seri/emmy/seshas/skylar
- assuming herbe flips red, the remaining w/w team is between flora/seri/seshas (skylar sussed him, emmy pretty easily followed vote) and i think it easily becomes either seshas/seri or seshas/flora
- if he doesn't, then no one gets crossed off of that suspect list. i think?

idk whether to read this as a walkback because i said i'd feel bad about you if herbe flips red, but that seems to obvious so i guess i'm going to read it as genuine

if herbe flips not-mafia i think like... that does not really make sense honestly? like i don't think i strongly read herbe as scum so much as just, him flipping scum would not not make sense whereas him flipping town would be kind of a question mark

 

[mewtini]

idk whether to read this as a walkback because i said i'd feel bad about you if herbe flips red, but that seems to obvious so i guess i'm going to read it as genuine

i mean it was definitely triggered by that, tbh

i do think that mathematically a w/w/w team being only between everyone who isn't herbe would be bizarre