No. I don't think she's mafia. I kind of thought she may be acting on her own, and I thought her role could be something like what zori claimed. Badge-powered serial killer maybe? But yeah, you're right, I can see how that doesn't make sense and besides it would be kind of unbalanced for town. And to reply to the blu question, I was thinking that mafia didn't kill him at night because they would have figured he'd be an easy mislynch with the associative read. I mean, if you think about it, it makes sense to kill both bm and vm since bm was powertowning hard and vm had the bodyguard/lure ability. The kill that doesn't make much sense, at least imo, is rnp's because while he may have had a powerful badgepower, it seemed clear (at least to me) that he didn't have those badges yet. It could be because everyone was reading him as confirmed town, though. idk.I don't really understand this. Is your thesis just that Negrek has a kill every night in addition to the main mafia one? If so, (a) why were there still no deaths on N0 despite two attempts, and (b) why would that make Negrek mafia as opposed to, say, a vig? (And, if you think Blu is actually town, (c) with two shots last night, how come the mafia still didn't kill him?)
Um.. fwiw, badges are received during the day phase, actually. I received mine in the middle of the day phase and Stryke just claimed having received RNP's. And Hydre's unfortunate grudge on RNP would probably mean that they sent their badges to someone else instead.Also, even if the deaths were caused by that strange kill-everyone-who-visits-your-target role (which there's no evidence for and seems implausible for the balance reasons others have mentioned), we have no particular reason to think RNP didn't have enough badges for his other ability. Hydreigon's badge(s) would have arrived at the beginning of N2 (alongside Herbe's, as you claimed, right?), and as nobody has acknowledged receiving them, it's at least reasonably likely they went to one of tonight's casualties. Unless Hydrei accidentally gave them to the mafia, I suppose.
I guess it made sense to me at the time, but maybe it was just me jumping to conclusions again. :/Altogether, this post makes no sense whatsoever and frankly I'm kinda side-eyeing you for it.
Also, I want to say rari's claim actually does make a lot of sense and explains why she jumped on zori the way she did after her claim and also explains why she initially was as sus of Negrek as she was. And she did ask the question about anyone else having woke up weary and without being able to move a muscle (which no one seemed to really get at the time, but actually makes a lot of sense with their roleblockerish role).
rari, why did you shoot hydre though? Did you think they were 3p?