Snom Mafia

[Tangrowth]

MP7 if you really need a sleep don't put yourself at risk for us! Rest helps you brain better later on

But I need to solve the game! XD

 

[Tangrowth]

I think the idea that you're town for being dissed is fine, but I don't have a strong feeling based on your posts.

i forget if i’ve said this already but i kind of disagree with this. while the diss role could be mafia for sure, i don’t think it’s right to assume that it’s PROBABLY mafia to the point that we’re building reads on other people from it. i’m all for getting townleaned but i don’t want it to be built on pillars of sand and that’s how i kind of feel when a bunch of people’s reads are informed by it.

it sounds like most of you guys are in agreement about keldeo/mewtini/mp7/blu? hmm. maybe i’ll reread the thread tomorrow… if you guys all see it, maybe i’m missing something.

I would advise against this... I actively welcome reads dissent discussions. Please let me know if you disagree on any of my reads for sure!

 

[Tangrowth]

MP7 if you really need a sleep don't put yourself at risk for us! Rest helps you brain better later on

But I need to solve the game! XD

I'm just really not a "brain works well at evening" sort of person, it's fine really.

 

[Trebek]

I actually feel pretty good about townreading mewtini, MP7 (for now tm), and Blu

i think this is about where i am at with my limited vibes. i may be a little confbiased about mewt bc i just want her to be town lol, but i do really like the vibes im getting from her, as well as Blu. I also really like MP7's reads on my posts

Could you expand a little more on these? What do you mean with the MP7 read in particular?

so actually, after thinking about it a bit more, i realized that my origional reasoning for townleaning MP7 is actually NAI: i think i am just subconsciously associating "good logical processes" with "towny play"

with that in mind, i still have good vibes about her, theyre just much less describable than i origonally thought.

 

[mewtini]

idrk what my townreads are atm to be honest, but i'll remark that i don't think mp7 sounds strictly different from how she did in cats - even though in a vacuum i definitely call her tone/analysis towny, i think the main difference is just the amount of time she's been here, right?

 

[mewtini]

idrk what my townreads are atm to be honest

by which i mean: i started writing out a list and it was pretty much everyone who posted minus like, koko/jolt/ysabel because i am still

 

[Keldeo]

MP, I've vaguely thought about the idea that the game is literally not solvable today and so I should take it easy because of the number of players who've made very few content posts for irl or other reasons, hehe.

I actually think the most consensus townread, speaking generally and not just of the people who are in the thread right now, is mewtini, is that right?

I think the idea that you're town for being dissed is fine, but I don't have a strong feeling based on your posts.

i forget if i’ve said this already but i kind of disagree with this. while the diss role could be mafia for sure, i don’t think it’s right to assume that it’s PROBABLY mafia to the point that we’re building reads on other people from it. i’m all for getting townleaned but i don’t want it to be built on pillars of sand and that’s how i kind of feel when a bunch of people’s reads are informed by it.

it sounds like most of you guys are in agreement about keldeo/mewtini/mp7/blu? hmm. maybe i’ll reread the thread tomorrow… if you guys all see it, maybe i’m missing something.

That's fair. You repeatedly speaking against it for these mechanical considerations might be +town points anyway heh.

(I say this as someone who pushes back on townreads of me for incorrect reasons to get cred as either alignment (thus Ysabel's townread on me for pushing back against koko's townread of me is for incorrect reasons!))

 

[Tangrowth]

I actually feel pretty good about townreading mewtini, MP7 (for now tm), and Blu

i think this is about where i am at with my limited vibes. i may be a little confbiased about mewt bc i just want her to be town lol, but i do really like the vibes im getting from her, as well as Blu. I also really like MP7's reads on my posts

Could you expand a little more on these? What do you mean with the MP7 read in particular?

so actually, after thinking about it a bit more, i realized that my origional reasoning for townleaning MP7 is actually NAI: i think i am just subconsciously associating "good logical processes" with "towny play"

with that in mind, i still have good vibes about her, theyre just much less describable than i origonally thought.

What specifically made you realize this?

 

[Tangrowth]

idrk what my townreads are atm to be honest

by which i mean: i started writing out a list and it was pretty much everyone who posted minus like, koko/jolt/ysabel because i am still

I mean... sorting by post count right now wouldn't be the most terrible thing, but eh. What do you think of Trebek?

 

[Tangrowth]

MP, I've vaguely thought about the idea that the game is literally not solvable today and so I should take it easy because of the number of players who've made very few content posts for irl or other reasons, hehe.

But... yeah, okay, you're probably right, but I feel too turbulent about my reads right now for comfort.

 

[kyeugh]

I would advise against this... I actively welcome reads dissent discussions. Please let me know if you disagree on any of my reads for sure!

it’s not really that i actually disagree so much as that nothing is really standing out to me in either direction so far? everything just feels grey. i don’t feel like i know you well enough to have a read yet, keldeo/mewt both feel to me like they could still be within their wolf ranges, and blu is sitting firmly at null for me—i definitely think he could be a good actor, and his iso was a little strange to me. but none of this actually approaches a scumlean, it’s just holding me back from a townlean either. ambivalence is in da house tonight, everybody just have a good time

 

[Tangrowth]

The small amount of players also means we have less margin of error insofar as yeets are concerned... not trying to stress anyone out though.

 

[Trebek]

mewtini, is that right?

there are 3 constants in life

death
taxes
mewtini being towncore

 

[Tangrowth]

I would advise against this... I actively welcome reads dissent discussions. Please let me know if you disagree on any of my reads for sure!

it’s not really that i actually disagree so much as that nothing is really standing out to me in either direction so far? everything just feels grey. i don’t feel like i know you well enough to have a read yet, keldeo/mewt both feel to me like they could still be within their wolf ranges, and blu is sitting firmly at null for me—i definitely think he could be a good actor, and his iso was a little strange to me. but none of this actually approaches a scumlean, it’s just holding me back from a townlean either. ambivalence is in da house tonight, everybody just have a good time

What makes you think Keldeo and mewtini are within wolf range?

Can you elaborate on what was strange about Blu's ISO?

 

[Tangrowth]

Actually, I may give up and do a reads list with a fresh perspective in the morning, sigh. But I don't want to! I'll at least do the koko thing.

 

[Keldeo]

idrk what my townreads are atm to be honest, but i'll remark that i don't think mp7 sounds strictly different from how she did in cats - even though in a vacuum i definitely call her tone/analysis towny, i think the main difference is just the amount of time she's been here, right?

it’s not really that i actually disagree so much as that nothing is really standing out to me in either direction so far? everything just feels grey. i don’t feel like i know you well enough to have a read yet, keldeo/mewt both feel to me like they could still be within their wolf ranges, and blu is sitting firmly at null for me—i definitely think he could be a good actor, and his iso was a little strange to me. but none of this actually approaches a scumlean, it’s just holding me back from a townlean either. ambivalence is in da house tonight, everybody just have a good time

These are probably fair but also, hmm... I guess I'm magnifying my own confidence / disregarding things, because if I start to let myself talk myself out of those reads, I don't really have anything confident either, hehe.

What was strange about Blu's ISO, kyeugh?

 

[Tangrowth]

idrk what my townreads are atm to be honest, but i'll remark that i don't think mp7 sounds strictly different from how she did in cats - even though in a vacuum i definitely call her tone/analysis towny, i think the main difference is just the amount of time she's been here, right?

it’s not really that i actually disagree so much as that nothing is really standing out to me in either direction so far? everything just feels grey. i don’t feel like i know you well enough to have a read yet, keldeo/mewt both feel to me like they could still be within their wolf ranges, and blu is sitting firmly at null for me—i definitely think he could be a good actor, and his iso was a little strange to me. but none of this actually approaches a scumlean, it’s just holding me back from a townlean either. ambivalence is in da house tonight, everybody just have a good time

These are probably fair but also, hmm... I guess I'm magnifying my own confidence / disregarding things, because if I start to let myself talk myself out of those reads, I don't really have anything confident either, hehe.

What was strange about Blu's ISO, kyeugh?

Look at that.

 

[mewtini]

What do you think of Trebek?

so i'm kind of like ... wrestling with a lot of things about him, like

- i agree that his posting could seem tonally awkward, but i think it's not far off from his natural speech patterns. (but then it's maybe confbias because i know him and want him to be town, but then, ... etc). in particular his entrance post, that you pointed out as stilted, is a pretty run of the mill joke from him ime
- i've been doing a lot of metareading but that doesn't really work for him, since he barely posted d1 of cats (his first forum mafia game) because he's more comfortable with mechspec
- i think he sounded earnest enough in like, 495, and also i kind of liked that he asked why you thought his posting sounded stilted though that is probably NAI

i still don't really want to vote him today tbh because i think either way i want to see him talk mechanics before deciding anything

 

[Trebek]

I actually feel pretty good about townreading mewtini, MP7 (for now tm), and Blu

i think this is about where i am at with my limited vibes. i may be a little confbiased about mewt bc i just want her to be town lol, but i do really like the vibes im getting from her, as well as Blu. I also really like MP7's reads on my posts

Could you expand a little more on these? What do you mean with the MP7 read in particular?

so actually, after thinking about it a bit more, i realized that my origional reasoning for townleaning MP7 is actually NAI: i think i am just subconsciously associating "good logical processes" with "towny play"

with that in mind, i still have good vibes about her, theyre just much less describable than i origonally thought.

What specifically made you realize this?

not a specific thing that made me realize, more just a general "trebek makes posts before thinking them through all the way bc otherwise he never posts and thats worse"

 

[mewtini]

What do you think of Trebek?

so i'm kind of like ... wrestling with a lot of things about him, like

- i agree that his posting could seem tonally awkward, but i think it's not far off from his natural speech patterns. (but then it's maybe confbias because i know him and want him to be town, but then, ... etc). in particular his entrance post, that you pointed out as stilted, is a pretty run of the mill joke from him ime
- i've been doing a lot of metareading but that doesn't really work for him, since he barely posted d1 of cats (his first forum mafia game) because he's more comfortable with mechspec
- i think he sounded earnest enough in like, 495, and also i kind of liked that he asked why you thought his posting sounded stilted though that is probably NAI

i still don't really want to vote him today tbh because i think either way i want to see him talk mechanics before deciding anything

also the "he overthinks his posts" thing was exactly what made me worried about him in cats but he ended up being town so. i think he might just be self-conscious in that way as either alignment maybe, is my guess