I voted for Blackstar and Tallstar. Why? Because in my eyes,Firestar is a gary-stu who can do everything perfectly most of the time and nothing bad ever happens to him exept maybie losing a few lives. Tigerstar is much awsomer because who doesn't like ambition, I really would have likes a Tigerstar super-edition story. Firestar, on the other hand has way too many fans just because he's a gary-stu and is the main character.
So yeah.
Except he's not. Flametail could debate you out if you want, but seeing as Firestar isn't my favorite character, I don't have much to debate for. (Flametail, if you see this, please debate because I want to see your reason for liking Firestar anyway. :P)
I voted for Firestar, Crookedstar, Blackstar and Tallstar, anyway.