Cats (2019) Mafia

[Tangrowth]

In no particular order it’d be nice to get your thoughts on Ultracool’s ISO (it’s really short), Herbe’s ISO, and IndigoEmmy’s claim and People’s reactions (can’t fetch the link but search for Skimbleshanks)

I'm down with that.

 

[mewtini]

I'm looking back now, does anyone have any idea around what page range the Ultracool wagon started?

fwiw though it's been slow-growing. looking at vote history is maybe also useful

Spoiler: vote hist

VM/kyeugh 1270
kyeugh/ultracool 1299
VM/ultracool 1326
mewtini/ultracool 1327
mewtini/unvote 1340
mewtini/kyeugh 1357
mewtini/unvote 1359
rnp/kyeugh 1453
mewtini/emmy 1472
trebek/emmy 1473
rari/emmy 1482
herbe/emmy 1489
keldeo/ultracool 1567
tofu/ultracool 1604
emmy/ultracool 1612
ultracool/emmy 1614
herbe/unvote 1653
blu/emmy 1717
rari/ultracool 1730
kyeugh/tofu 1732
emmy/tofu 1634
trebek/ultracool 1736
blu/tofu 1747
mewtini/tofu 1797
trebek/tofu 1876
ultracool/unvote 1884
herbe/ultracool 1886
rnp/emmy 1926
trebek/ultracool 1927
kyeugh/ultracool 1939
mewtini/ultracool 1941
ils/blu 1996
keldeo/herbe 2056
mewtini/herbe 2059
trebek/herbe 2084
blu/unvote 2095
VM/herbe 2104
VM/unvote 2114
VM/herbe 2119
bfree/herbe 2163
rari/mewtini 2184
rari/ultracool 2186

 

[mewtini]

ok just realized that some of that bolding is wrong/leaves stuff out so maybe just ignore it heh.

 

[Keldeo]

Btw re: reading MP7, there’s something I’m looking for whose name will sound really dumb if I say it, but it’s essentially an intense emotional reaction along the lines of how Rari originally reacted to the Alonzo claim - he’s self aware about it but I think if he does it it’ll make him town

If he doesn’t do it I don’t think it makes him mafia, but I’m wary

 

[Tangrowth]

Btw re: reading MP7, there’s something I’m looking for whose name will sound really dumb if I say it, but it’s essentially an intense emotional reaction along the lines of how Rari originally reacted to the Alonzo claim - he’s self aware about it but I think if he does it it’ll make him town

If he doesn’t do it I don’t think it makes him mafia, but I’m wary

LMAO, yeah, I uhh don't have enough grounding in the game for that yet, but it is certainly a Thing that could happen at some point whenever I feel like I get a strong feeling about someone or something.

 

[Tangrowth]

Btw re: reading MP7, there’s something I’m looking for whose name will sound really dumb if I say it, but it’s essentially an intense emotional reaction along the lines of how Rari originally reacted to the Alonzo claim - he’s self aware about it but I think if he does it it’ll make him town

If he doesn’t do it I don’t think it makes him mafia, but I’m wary

LMAO, yeah, I uhh don't have enough grounding in the game for that yet, but it is certainly a Thing that could happen at some point whenever I feel like I get a strong feeling about someone or something.

I need to find a better name for it anyway, it only is called that thanks to an infamous quote from a Syndicate mafia player who sadly doesn't play much anymore.

 

[Bluwiikoon]

I am gonna quickly eat something and then I’ll be back.

@Bluwiikoon if you had to choose between the two main wagons (Ultracool and Herbe) (with a third option of starting a new wagon) what would you pick?

I think Herbe for now. In day one they kept mentioning how towny they are and uhhhh honestly? I feel like a rolecop is kind of a huge risk for any town power roles, especially considering y'all are saying rolecop is usually a mafia role >:o Unless we get a specific cat claim from Herbe that people knowledgeable in The Lore can explain as being rolecop AND town, I'm ok putting my vote there. Sorry tangy bro ;o;

Tfw I realise my grocery delivery arrives anywhere in the next two hours Sorry if I get sparse, I'll try my best!

 

[rari_teh]

what troubles me more is that herbe isn’t even here and isn’t likely to be before being lynched thrown in the basement

@Herbe PLEASE come and claim your cat
the only way the wagon may dissolve is if you catclaim and nobody counters it

 

[Keldeo]

I am gonna quickly eat something and then I’ll be back.

@Bluwiikoon if you had to choose between the two main wagons (Ultracool and Herbe) (with a third option of starting a new wagon) what would you pick?

I think Herbe for now. In day one they kept mentioning how towny they are and uhhhh honestly? I feel like a rolecop is kind of a huge risk for any town power roles, especially considering y'all are saying rolecop is usually a mafia role >:o Unless we get a specific cat claim from Herbe that people knowledgeable in The Lore can explain as being rolecop AND town, I'm ok putting my vote there. Sorry tangy bro ;o;

Tfw I realise my grocery delivery arrives anywhere in the next two hours Sorry if I get sparse, I'll try my best!

Oh yeah, he claimed Victoria, who spies on the other cats? Are there any Cats lore knowers around who can shed light on that?

I don’t think it’s usually a mafia role, it’s just possible for it to be mafia, especially more so than cop.

 

[mewtini]

I feel like a rolecop is kind of a huge risk for any town power roles, especially considering y'all are saying rolecop is usually a mafia role

oh, yeah. if herbe himself is the rolecop (i.e. it's not a scenario where someone else is feeding him info) then there's also the question of him, as mafia, finding a strong PR and supplying the mafia with a last nightkill before getting lynched

sounds like rolecop isn't necessarily mafia though so there is that

 

[Vipera Magnifica]

Lol, I like it, Trebek, although insert sentiment about something something tinfoil not useful this early whatever.

oh, 100%. entirely for the memes right now, although i did have a bad dream last night about this exact scenario

I have a running theory that unprompted dreams about mafia posts are town tells.

I had a dream a few days ago that I was playing mafia on another forum and they had an algorithm that could solve the whole game on D1. It made it not very fun.

 

[rari_teh]

Oh yeah, he claimed Victoria, who spies on the other cats? Are there any Cats lore knowers around who can shed light on that?

oh yeah i’d forgotten about that! :o
@I liek Squirtles you around to comment?

 

[Bluwiikoon]

If there are roleblockers it would be pretty silly of them to target an alien and not an actual cop LOL

 

[rari_teh]

Lol, I like it, Trebek, although insert sentiment about something something tinfoil not useful this early whatever.

oh, 100%. entirely for the memes right now, although i did have a bad dream last night about this exact scenario

I have a running theory that unprompted dreams about mafia posts are town tells.

I had a dream a few days ago that I was playing mafia on another forum and they had an algorithm that could solve the whole game on D1. It made it not very fun.

they asked if they could, but they forgot to ask whether they should

 

[Trebek]

if herbe flips red, there’s also the implication of who did he actually investigate, since he can easily leak any mafia role names that could come across as NAI, and instead investigate other people secretly. that’s a tinfoil hat that i am not going to devote any more thought to unless he flips red though

 

[rari_teh]

If there are roleblockers it would be pretty silly of them to target an alien and not an actual cop LOL

yeah mate i think i see where you’re going with this, and for your image’s sake i’d say it’d probably for the best if you dropped this line of thinking for now tbh

 

[Butterfree]

I am gonna quickly eat something and then I’ll be back.

@Bluwiikoon if you had to choose between the two main wagons (Ultracool and Herbe) (with a third option of starting a new wagon) what would you pick?

I think Herbe for now. In day one they kept mentioning how towny they are and uhhhh honestly? I feel like a rolecop is kind of a huge risk for any town power roles, especially considering y'all are saying rolecop is usually a mafia role >:o Unless we get a specific cat claim from Herbe that people knowledgeable in The Lore can explain as being rolecop AND town, I'm ok putting my vote there. Sorry tangy bro ;o;

Tfw I realise my grocery delivery arrives anywhere in the next two hours Sorry if I get sparse, I'll try my best!

Oh yeah, he claimed Victoria, who spies on the other cats? Are there any Cats lore knowers around who can shed light on that?

I don’t think it’s usually a mafia role, it’s just possible for it to be mafia, especially more so than cop.

Victoria is the “new guy” in the 2019 movie; she’s learning about the Jellicle tribe. The rolecop claim checks out with it. It’s sort of unusual to make her mafia, when she’s kind of the main character, but I’m not sure we should quite trust in the cats being alignment-indicative in general (I imagine Macavity is mafia, but otherwise it’s probably a toss-up).

 

[rari_teh]

it’d probably

it’d *be probably for the best
smh where my head at

 

[Tangrowth]

Ultracool's ISO is... thin, to say the least.

I'm really, really sorry for not posting, like, at all, but I just genuinely can't manage to read anything of relevance out of toDay. The only things I found even slightly suspicious were the WIFOM-Macavity Claim and kyeugh imploring the Mafia to read more into the kill flavor, since they are pretty much the only ones who would know exactly why and how someone was killed :/

I still think this sounds genuine, but I suppose a scum!UltraCool could be channeling something NAI into a thing here.

Otherwise I got a big *shrug* for the rest of the ISO.

 

[Vipera Magnifica]

it’d probably

it’d *be probably for the best
smh where my head at

who is this be and why are we lynching them