• Welcome to The Cave of Dragonflies forums, where the smallest bugs live alongside the strongest dragons.

    Guests are not able to post messages or even read certain areas of the forums. Now, that's boring, don't you think? Registration, on the other hand, is simple, completely free of charge, and does not require you to give out any personal information at all. As soon as you register, you can take part in some of the happy fun things at the forums such as posting messages, voting in polls, sending private messages to people and being told that this is where we drink tea and eat cod.

    Of course I'm not forcing you to do anything if you don't want to, but seriously, what have you got to lose? Five seconds of your life?

Cats (2019) Mafia

So, hmm. I kiiiind of want to vote Herbe, because like I said I'm still side-eyeing him for the same reasons as yesterday. I'm starting to think maybe we just have a very, very bussy mafia, and they hoped to gain Herbe towncred by letting the wagons be mostly even and then letting Ultracool die?

On the other hand, for all the mechanical reasons outlined previously, RNP is pretty suspect, and also the sudden move onto Herbe a little while back was kind of huh...?

Ngggh. I think I agree with the previously provided reasoning that ultimately, if RNP is mafia and we don't lynch him now, his roleblocking could stop the vig from getting him tonight, while Herbe is more likely to be safely vigged? RNP
 
Bluwiikoon said:
Keldeo said:
Blu, how's it going? Where's your head at?
Click to expand...
Not gonna lie my brain is white static at this point 😅 Everyone seems to have a good grasp on things and I'm not really sure what I can contribute aside from just stray thoughts as they come to me. Mafia... is a tricky game!

I really wanna believe VM/Tofu are town for reasons. I guess when more flips come to light, I should revisit my Roster List tomorrow?
Click to expand...
Okay, thanks, anything you can do is good! Are those reasons something you can talk about? Do you have any other stray thoughts?
 
mewtini said:
Bluwiikoon said:
I really wanna believe VM/Tofu are town for reasons
Click to expand...
if you can - what are the reasons rq?
Click to expand...
If one of them is vig, the other's surely gotta be town since they did the coded role reveals! It's not impossible for them to be lying to the other, but they've been pretty upfront with how difficult dishonesty would be in a shared physical space.
 
kyeugh said:
M Plus 7 said:
MP7 vibes-based reads list

Moderate to strong town
Butterfree
Emmy
mewtini

Slight to moderate town
Keldeo
koko
kyuegh
rari

Upper POE
Herbe
Mist
Tofu
Trebek
VM

Lower POE
Blu
RNP

Alphabetical within tiers.

@Keldeo
Click to expand...
can you explain your koko read a bit or link me to a post where you did? sorry if you've already explained this and i'm forgetting
Click to expand...

Oh no worries! I'm sort of in ever-replacement mode based on my schedule, lol. I really liked koko's train of thought earlier today with respect to Herbe and RNP; even though I didn't necessarily agree with it, I think it was a uniquely solvey way of looking at it.

I seem to remember liking another one of their posts earlier in the game for a similar reason, but I can't recall lmao.
 
If we are all Jellicles, why is Gus The Theater Cat reminiscing on his former Jellicle days

Butterfree said:
So, hmm. I kiiiind of want to vote Herbe, because like I said I'm still side-eyeing him for the same reasons as yesterday. I'm starting to think maybe we just have a very, very bussy mafia, and they hoped to gain Herbe towncred by letting the wagons be mostly even and then letting Ultracool die?

On the other hand, for all the mechanical reasons outlined previously, RNP is pretty suspect, and also the sudden move onto Herbe a little while back was kind of huh...?

Ngggh. I think I agree with the previously provided reasoning that ultimately, if RNP is mafia and we don't lynch him now, his roleblocking could stop the vig from getting him tonight, while Herbe is more likely to be safely vigged? RNP
Click to expand...
Hey Butterfree! I think I agree about the vig safety thing. Can you talk to me more about what you think is going on in a Herbe/Ultracool partners world, or any other reads you think are worth mentioning?
 
Keldeo said:
M Plus 7 said:
MP7 vibes-based reads list

Moderate to strong town
Butterfree
Emmy
mewtini

Slight to moderate town
Keldeo
koko
kyuegh
rari

Upper POE
Herbe
Mist
Tofu
Trebek
VM

Lower POE
Blu
RNP

Alphabetical within tiers.

@Keldeo
Click to expand...
Can you explain about me, koko, and Tofu/VM being where you put them? What do you think of the earlier Blu/RNP not w/w read for Blu not seeming to understand about the jailer, I don't remember if you said?
Click to expand...

Spoke to koko just now... Tofu and VM are perhaps my two biggest behavioral ???'s right now, so I guess I should actually ISO them with higher priority. They're mostly just because I don't have any reason to town read them in that way.

I liked your logic. I could still see a w/w pairing, but I think w/v is pretty plausible.

What's your reads list right now? Should I be considering anything that you think I may have missed?
 
Keldeo said:
Oh actually I think that post Tofu made a couple minutes ago about not understanding why town jailkeeper RNP would vote Emmy actually makes her and RNP probably not mafia together, either - both because of the pressing on RNP and because of the confusion about the jailkeeper role.
Click to expand...
Oh, that's a good point!
 
Keldeo said:
Do you have any other stray thoughts?
Click to expand...
  • RNP intimidates me :frown:
  • I'm nervous about MP7's scumlean on me considering I am literally just town. It's good to analyse everybody you can, but I'm feeling a bit singled-out!
  • Am I the only surviving townie who [redacted] because that sure doesn't do me any favours
 
uh fwiw if rnp is a wolf and was just lying about jailkeeper/other mafia got confused it might not rule out some of those w/w pairings right? (i talked about this last night and at first thought it still did, but then i went back on it)
 
I feel like I keep feeling worse about MP7 when they aren't here and then feel good about their posts as they're making them. It'd probably be disrespecting their mafia game to say that their posts here are like, superbly towny, but hrrgh tone good
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom