Forum Revival TV Tropes Mafia Revival - D7

[mewtini]

oh did Keldeo say something about Panini or are you just referring to the fact that me and Keldeo are the same person

keldeo voted for panini at some point during the EoD clusterfuck didnt he?

god no matter how many times I use that emoji it doesn't get added to my recent smilies :(

:(

 

[kyeugh]

ok, so, i'm gonna just post my current tierlist before i elaborate, but i will do that sometime soon! just wanted to make sure it wouldnt be too derailing. top list is pretty defined, even order (ie i don't trust the bottom much less than the top), second/third are mostly ordered (top = i trust more, bottom = less)

likely town? like 85% think so?
emmy (roleclaim)
kyeugh
seshas (roleclaim)
VM (roleclaim)
eifie
rari
kokorico

iiiiidk
keldeo
mawile
ultracool
mist (havent seen much from them)
odie (inactive)
@RedneckPhoenix can you explain your end of day?
@Flora are you alive
@Stryke i am interested in your thoughts on the goings-on when you get a chance.

maybe uncomfortable with
negrek
panini (currently am following eif/keldeo's read)
mf

hopefully not missing anyone this time

you're on my town list too mewmew-chan

 

[Eifie]

i really can't get a handle on panini's meta (i say for like the third game in a row) but i don't really find the odie_pie vote that odd although i do find it useless/not different from abstaining
not wanting to fuck up developments that occur while she's gone feels like a reasonable and imo towny sentiment though

mmf I just feel like she hasn't taken a stance on anyone in this game and I know she's busy but even when overwhelmed in mashes she does spit out some reads

 

[mewtini]

not a single herbe in sight :((((

oh sorry! lol

let me amend/just going to repost so no one gets lost

Spoiler: mewt's tierlist

likely town? like 85% think so?
emmy (roleclaim)
kyeugh
seshas (roleclaim)
VM (roleclaim)
eifie
herbe
rari
kokorico

iiiiidk
keldeo
mawile
ultracool
mist (havent seen much from them)
odie (inactive)
@RedneckPhoenix can you explain your end of day?
@Flora are you alive
@Stryke i am interested in your thoughts on the goings-on when you get a chance.

maybe uncomfortable with
negrek
panini (currently am following eif/keldeo's read)
mf

 

[Eifie]

keldeo voted for panini at some point during the EoD clusterfuck didnt he?

nah that was me and boq

 

[Herbe]

i've never played w panini before so I'm kinda just going based off of y'alls experience rn

 

[Eifie]

ok, so, i'm gonna just post my current tierlist before i elaborate, but i will do that sometime soon! just wanted to make sure it wouldnt be too derailing. top list is pretty defined, even order (ie i don't trust the bottom much less than the top), second/third are mostly ordered (top = i trust more, bottom = less)

likely town? like 85% think so?
emmy (roleclaim)
kyeugh
seshas (roleclaim)
VM (roleclaim)
eifie
rari
kokorico

iiiiidk
keldeo
mawile
ultracool
mist (havent seen much from them)
odie (inactive)
@RedneckPhoenix can you explain your end of day?
@Flora are you alive
@Stryke i am interested in your thoughts on the goings-on when you get a chance.

maybe uncomfortable with
negrek
panini (currently am following eif/keldeo's read)
mf

hopefully not missing anyone this time

serimachi?

 

[mewtini]

you're on my town list too mewmew-chan

owo

but actually skylar is there a chance i could see your list? kind of interested in your Takes and since they've been more fluid than others' (which for posterity is kinda why i #trust you right now) i'd be curious to know where your head is at

 

[mewtini]

serimachi?

god damn it. i forgot they were playing and just 100% left them out of my notes. lmfao. i dont feel like reposting but seri was in "inactive, idk"

 

[kyeugh]

mmf I just feel like she hasn't taken a stance on anyone in this game and I know she's busy but even when overwhelmed in mashes she does spit out some reads

i feel like she had lukewarm takes on ils/ottercopter and was on ottercopter when it was a minority wagon imo so that's something
honestly i don't think she was in a significantly different place than the rest of the game at that time seeing as almost everyone was just sort of picking whatever wagon they liked the most without believing that strongly in either
i have kind of come to expect more Content from her but like it's not just the reads that are lacking, it's her activity in general, so meh

 

[kyeugh]

ive been praying like this whole game that no one would ask me for a reads list bc my thoughts are not that organized
but sure i'll do it tbh it's probably time
i have to go set up the switch so my dad can play mario kart and then. probably play it with him. but i'll try and write a list tonight

 

[mewtini]

ive been praying like this whole game that no one would ask me for a reads list bc my thoughts are not that organized
but sure i'll do it tbh it's probably time
i have to go set up the switch so my dad can play mario kart and then. probably play it with him. but i'll try and write a list tonight

haaahahaha i'm sorry. no pressure to, just have definitely been wondering in between your different rounds of spec

 

[kyeugh]

i feel like she had lukewarm takes on ils/ottercopter and was on ottercopter when it was a minority wagon imo so that's something
honestly i don't think she was in a significantly different place than the rest of the game at that time seeing as almost everyone was just sort of picking whatever wagon they liked the most without believing that strongly in either
i have kind of come to expect more Content from her but like it's not just the reads that are lacking, it's her activity in general, so meh

this is supposed to say "when it was a minority wagon iirc" lol @ "the numbers are my opinion"

 

[Eifie]

lemme try mine

The Queen
Eifie!

My Mech Clears
Mr. Ultracool
Keldeo
Mist1422

Basically lock town
IndigoEmmy
Seshas

Town for now, think later
Vipera Magnifica
Negrek

Probably town I hope, hopefully 0-1 mafia here, 2 if I'm bad
kyeugh
mewtini
Herbe
rari_teh
kokorico

Sure
Mawile
serimachi (floating back to null because no/basically no activity since the last read)

idc right now
Ottercopter

amorphous blob unordered
Flora
RedneckPhoenix
Stryke
Odie_Pie

I don't feel so good
M&F
Panini

 

[Stryke]

@Stryke i am interested in your thoughts on the goings-on when you get a chance.

Not too many thoughts really. I really want to believe otter because it honestly does seem like just a string of unfortunate/ill-timed posts, but like... I could also see it as pretty scummy too, like maybe she actually is an alien type role and now she's trying to backpedal on it in a chance to get activated. But at the same time she seems like she knew she messed up and accidentally made herself seem a lot more scummy than she might be, and she's been really willing to cooperate too. I can see both sides of the story, so I'm definitely interested in whenever she elaborates on her role, maybe it'll help clear things up

 

[mewtini]

OKAY i decided i had stuff to add anyway so i'm reposting. again. this is probably the final time right? untagging my tags from earlier so as to not ping them a third time

Spoiler: mewt's tierlist

likely town? like 85% think so?
emmy (roleclaim)
kyeugh
seshas (roleclaim)
VM (roleclaim)
eifie (hypoclaim)
herbe (maybe i just feel validated by him tbh but i Accept)
rari
kokorico (i like their EoD d1)

iiiiidk
keldeo
mawile
ultracool (havent seen much from them) (hypo green n1)
mist (havent seen much from them) (hypo green n0)
seri (inactive?)
odie (inactive)
RNP can you explain your end of day?
flora are you alive
stryke (is answering my q as i post this :D)

maybe uncomfortable with tbh
negrek
panini (currently am following eif and boq (MAY HE REST IN PEACE :prayer:))
mf

[/QUOTE]

 

[mewtini]

Not too many thoughts really. I really want to believe otter because it honestly does seem like just a string of unfortunate/ill-timed posts, but like... I could also see it as pretty scummy too, like maybe she actually is an alien type role and now she's trying to backpedal on it in a chance to get activated. But at the same time she seems like she knew she messed up and accidentally made herself seem a lot more scummy than she might be, and she's been really willing to cooperate too. I can see both sides of the story, so I'm definitely interested in whenever she elaborates on her role, maybe it'll help clear things up

hi! thanks!
have you still been lurkfollowing? do you have anything to say about anyone else or any town/scumreads?

 

[Eifie]

i feel like she had lukewarm takes on ils/ottercopter and was on ottercopter when it was a minority wagon imo so that's something
honestly i don't think she was in a significantly different place than the rest of the game at that time seeing as almost everyone was just sort of picking whatever wagon they liked the most without believing that strongly in either
i have kind of come to expect more Content from her but like it's not just the reads that are lacking, it's her activity in general, so meh

she's been like actually in the thread a few times to post about like... stuff no one cares about tbh. I swear she's been talking about reading back and taking notes and stuff? where is that smh

 

[Keldeo]

my post about Panini at EoD was kind of harshly worded, sorry @Panini :( I was desperate to get something out before the day ended. anyway the thing that worries me there is that Panini didn't really make a stance (she said if she was voting for one she would vote for ILS but without an actual vote there that doesn't really mean anything to me) and instead voted on a wagon that was at that point not happening, in a case where there were two competing wagons and I think neither were capital-m Mafia-aligned. it kind of made me nervous even right there when it happened and I was like "what if we have t/t wagons and she's a wolf staying away???" so now that I think neither wagon was Mafia I'm getting confirmation bias like whoa. her reason for voting Odie_pie there was if she doesn't come back in time and her vote gets in the way or something but I don't know if that really feels like her. like a lot of people on the wagons were clearly actively online right then to move their votes around and also the just not using her vote doesn't feel that town!Panini-like :( there's also the fact that she hasn't done much in the way of solving, keeps promising more content but hasn't delivered yet, and I am probably totally biased but I am not thrilled with her question to me about voting Odie_pie because I literally gave my reasons right in the post where I voted her. if she saw my vote she was the reasons. so the asking me about it kind of feels like asking to do something/shade.

it also sort of brings up alarm bells for me that M&F posted once close to EoD but never placed a non-joke vote which doesn't really jive with her like, not wanting to waste lynches? I expected her to have some sort of opinion or do something and as far as I recall she never did and again I think the wolves didn't care which of the two was lynched (until Rebecca made her claim)

Hi homesleif. I have not reread basically at all but I think these reads are cromulent and solid directions to push. I also think they'll both post more today and would like to hear Panini's big thoughts that make you say you want to remove it :P

Can you tell me about the wagons being v/v (or v/3p)? That kinda maps to the EOD weirdness in everyone shifting back and forth, but also maps to I think a different world than I had in a v ILS / w Otter world. Otter's wagon looks very clean either way imo.

 

[mewtini]

she's been like actually in the thread a few times to post about like... stuff no one cares about tbh. I swear she's been talking about reading back and taking notes and stuff? where is that smh

ftr while i agree with you i actually feel worse about mf for reasons you have described as well