something mafia [INNOCENTS WIN]

[Clover]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Ohhh yeah, I forgot. After I even pointed it out in the other thread, herp. (seriously what is with the alien hate :()

Iunno. Lucky docs? [tirade of all other possibilities that gets brought up every time in this situation]? /shrug.

 

[opaltiger]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Does anyone else think 'is there at least one mafia faction?' might be a good question for an oracle to ask?

 

[Eifie]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Well, the innocent win condition is "you win when all Mafia are dead" so there would have to be at least one faction, wouldn't there? Although that does not necessarily mean that there is a Mafia-aligned killing role, I guess.

 

[opaltiger]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

I was going to say GMs can mess with win conditions all they like, but I suppose the role PM is fairly unambiguous. Shame. Still, as you say, there might not be any killing roles...

Well, unless any doctors are willing to speak up (or, you know, anyone else who might have a clue what's going on), I think it would be a good idea to abstain again - I reckon three no-deaths in a row is evidence of something extremely odd, and if we do lose someone, well, we probably would have anyway.

 

[Clover]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

I'll go ahead and abstain, if only to get a tie for the other vote. (Not that I wouldn't mind going after Green, either, but ... ... I don't have a but.)

 

[Tailsy]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Huh.

Abstain.

 

[opaltiger]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

No lynch.

 

[MilkAndCookies]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Nothing to go on. Abstain.

 

[Squirrel]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Agree with the above. Sorry for not contributing more, but I'll keep an eye out.

Abstain.

 

[Wargle]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

this game is boring... But If it almost ends happily ever after, some jerk will ruin it.

 

[Zero Moment]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

I can't believe it's that Day 2 and still no kills/lynches.

 

[JackPK]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Bump because somebody's post got temporarily swallowed by the forum gods.

 

[Blaziking the God General]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Remember how yesterday I was all "GIVE US ALL LIFE" and shit like that?

Well, screw that, I think we just have a freaking inactive mafia that isn't sending in night actions. Which means inactive lynch might actually hit them. It's probably too late now, but someone else suggested Excavalier so I say we role with it.

 

[JackPK]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

As I always say, a lynch is better than no lynch (exception made for aliens), so sure, Excavalier.

 

[opaltiger]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Guys. Seriously. What are the odds that not only can the mafia choose to forego a kill, but all the mafia are inactive?

 

[Minish]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

As I always say, a lynch is better than no lynch (exception made for aliens), so sure, Excavalier.

No it's not. :( There are more innocents than mafia, therefore, a lynch is more likely to hit an innocent.

We've been pretty lucky so far, so, I say abstain.

 

[MilkAndCookies]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

No it's not. :( There are more innocents than mafia, therefore, a lynch is more likely to hit an innocent.

We've been pretty lucky so far, so, I say abstain.

We haven't been "pretty lucky". We need lynches to win.
Vote: Excavalier

 

[Tailsy]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

I can't fully understand this thread due to my boyfriend's weird learn japanese extension, but I'm happy to bandwagon with Excavalier

 

[Mai]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Abstaining is working with us now, but it's not going to work forever and soon enough the mafia's going to start killing. I think we should lynch Excavalier for now.

 

[Tailsy]

Re: something mafia [day 2]

Abstaining is for losers and opaltiger. >:( Besides, Excavalier is rarely active in any of his games, so lynching him, even if he's innocent, is hardly a big loss.