Cats (2019) Mafia

[Vipera Magnifica]

@Tofu please follow my lead on this

@kyeugh I have just one question for you and then I will let you off the hook forever

between Tofu and I, one of us is the vigilante, and one of us is a watcher

you said:

pretty sure i know who the vig is tbh

please tell me which one of us is the vigilante, and explain how you know this

if I am satisfied with your answer, I will no longer suspect you

if not, the vigilante will kill you

 

[Novae]

my posting schedule is entirely arbitrary as both alignments tbh

anyway gonna vote Ultracool because I don't think herbe flips scum here

I don't think ultracool does either but

 

[rari_teh]

but i’m stubborn

it's not you, it's me, cont

never forget, good sport. it’s not you, it’s me ~

 

[kyeugh]

today is my mom's birthday

wtf ils’s mom is does married to bfree??

 

[Trebek]

for all we know, role names could have been set up in this game so that rolecop has a super hard time gleaning alignment. is such a thing possible?

Very possible imo, if mafia have roles that can also be town - though that just makes rolecop itself kind of a useless role as town since... you can't get anyone's alignment, you can just check claims, and if mafia have roles that can also be town they'd just true claim.

yeah, that’s what i was actually expecting to be true in this AU: the role cop functions the best if it can be combined with a copcheck. my assumption would be that if there were roles that could be NAI, like a role blocker, then the roles would be roles where alignment could be determined through thread presence and night action history

idk, i’m thinking too hard about this particular thing and not hard enough about the rest of EoD, i’m gonna go back and reread now

 

[Butterfree]

For what it’s worth, in case it relates to what mewtini is thinking: I don’t think that it’s impossible to have both a town rolecop and an alignment cop. If Herbe were to flip town, I don’t think that this would implicate Indigo. My suspicion of Herbe does not depend on him being town being incompatible with Indigo being town; it’s his specific behaviour in response to Indigo’s claim.

 

[mewtini]

for posterity - it does not 100% relate. but ty!

 

[Keldeo]

mafia see me push a case on their town partner and get supported by probably multiple townies, turn up the BUS IDLE because they don't think they can stop the train

wires got crossed

mafia see town me push a case on their partner and get supported by probably multiple townies, turn up the BUS IDLE because they don't think they can stop the train

 

[Keldeo]

Please click the BUS IDLE link I've been waiting to use that in a mafia game forever

 

[kyeugh]

@Tofu please follow my lead on this

@kyeugh I have just one question for you and then I will let you off the hook forever

between Tofu and I, one of us is the vigilante, and one of us is a watcher

you said:

pretty sure i know who the vig is tbh

please tell me which one of us is the vigilante, and explain how you know this

if I am satisfied with your answer, I will no longer suspect you

if not, the vigilante will kill you

i was pretty sure it was you. you seemed to be looking for guidance before, and suggested the presence of a vig iirc before we knew for sure there was one: https://forums.dragonflycave.com/threads/cats-2019-mafia.18670/post-682169

then you reacted pretty strongly to me mentioning it and tried to get me to talk about it, and apparently never forgot about it. i’ve been pretty much counting on getting shot tonight since you started pushing me anyway tbh. maybe it comes out to be tofu and haha lolskylar but i’ve been thinking it was you for a while now.

 

[Novae]

I'm in this awkward position where I'm kinda hating bfree/mewtini progression on herbe but it's probably just me being bad because like, they have mech stuff going for them if herb is town?

 

[Keldeo]

I'm in this awkward position where I'm kinda hating bfree/mewtini progression on herbe but it's probably just me being bad because like, they have mech stuff going for them if herb is town?

I think they're both mechanically near clear no matter Herbe's alignment, do you disagree?

 

[I liek Squirtles]

Please click the BUS IDLE link I've been waiting to use that in a mafia game forever

I can smell this sound. ready 2 go on a fieldtrip

 

[Novae]

I'm in this awkward position where I'm kinda hating bfree/mewtini progression on herbe but it's probably just me being bad because like, they have mech stuff going for them if herb is town?

I think they're both mechanically near clear no matter Herbe's alignment, do you disagree?

butterfree sure but I don't remember seeing a clearing claim from mewtini

 

[Keldeo]

My suspicion of Herbe does not depend on him being town being incompatible with Indigo being town; it’s his specific behaviour in response to Indigo’s claim.

Also, this is true for me as well and this is why I think I'm sticking on Herbe

 

[rari_teh]

I'm in this awkward position where I'm kinda hating bfree/mewtini progression on herbe but it's probably just me being bad because like, they have mech stuff going for them if herb is town?

I think they're both mechanically near clear no matter Herbe's alignment, do you disagree?

butterfree sure but I don't remember seeing a clearing claim from mewtini

Emmy cleared her n0

 

[Keldeo]

I'm in this awkward position where I'm kinda hating bfree/mewtini progression on herbe but it's probably just me being bad because like, they have mech stuff going for them if herb is town?

I think they're both mechanically near clear no matter Herbe's alignment, do you disagree?

butterfree sure but I don't remember seeing a clearing claim from mewtini

Oh, Emmy claimed to have cop checked her

Spoiler

would Mist have mist this as mafia?

 

[mewtini]

we're at 25 minutes to EoD
is there another person who anyone wants to push

 

[Keldeo]

Uh hey Mr. Ultracool, I see you're reacting to stuff but not posting, do you have any thoughts?

 

[qenya]

herbe (8): keldeo, mewtini, trebek, VM, bfree, blu, koko, kyeugh
ultracool (3): tofu, rari, herbe
tofu (1): emmy
blu (1): ils
emmy (1): rnp

what is happening tbh

holy shit
uh

wasn't the reason we were doubtful of the ultracool wagon that nobody really seemed to be opposing it? and now the same thing is happening with herbe

i swear to god, if this is another v/v