Cats (2019) Mafia

[RNP]

either don't lynch me today or lynch me, and when i flip green, lynch one of those two tomorrow

 

[RNP]

or vigkill one of em. i'm not picky when it comes to killing mafia

 

[kyeugh]

btw if rnp flips town it’s on sight for herbe

 

[rari_teh]

d2 i hard claim not-cop, implying i'm a power role other than cop

uuuuh how so? the implied statement i see is that you’re town and you want to be sure that nobody is FoSing possible-cop because they think you’re the real cop who’s afraid to claim

otherwise, while I 100% see where you’re going, I have Reasons to believe that kyeugh is not mafia

 

[RNP]

when rnp flips town i'm declaring open season on kyemmy

 

[RNP]

d2 i hard claim not-cop, implying i'm a power role other than cop

uuuuh how so? the implied statement i see is that you’re town and you want to be sure that nobody is FoSing possible-cop because they think you’re the real cop who’s afraid to claim

otherwise, while I 100% see where you’re going, I have Reasons to believe that kyeugh is not mafia

yes but what are the reasons

i wanna help the got damn town but when you're dodging like this i cant

 

[rari_teh]

d2 i hard claim not-cop, implying i'm a power role other than cop

uuuuh how so? the implied statement i see is that you’re town and you want to be sure that nobody is FoSing possible-cop because they think you’re the real cop who’s afraid to claim

otherwise, while I 100% see where you’re going, I have Reasons to believe that kyeugh is not mafia

yes but what are the reasons

i wanna help the got damn town but when you're dodging like this i cant

if i say, i may put people in danger and i do not like it
if this wagon grows i’ll probably spill the beans, but you have to trust me. i see the same dots you’re seeing and i see that when connected they produce a nifty picture of a sirfetch’d with a gun in the wing, but i am saying that i have solid reasons to trust kyeugh at this point

 

[JackPK]

Reminder: The day phase will end in 2 hours.

Active votes
Mist1422 votes Vipera Magnifica (#2779)
Keldeo votes M Plus 7 (#2899)
Vipera Magnifica votes RedneckPhoenix (#2931)
Tofu votes RedneckPhoenix (#2934)
Bluwiikoon votes RedneckPhoenix (#2946)
kyeugh votes RedneckPhoenix (#3075)
IndigoEmmy votes RedneckPhoenix (#3099)
Herbe votes M Plus 7 (#3236)
mewtini votes RedneckPhoenix (#3297)
kokorico votes Herbe (#3339)
RedneckPhoenix votes kyeugh (#3411)

Spoiler: Full vote history

Active votes bolded. Invalid votes stricken through.

Herbe votes Keldeo (#2539)
mewtini votes Keldeo (#2541)
Mist1422 votes Vipera Magnifica (#2779)
rari_teh votes Vipera Magnifica (#2785)
Keldeo votes M Plus 7 (#2899)
RedneckPhoenix votes IndigoEmmy (#2911)
Vipera Magnifica votes RedneckPhoenix (#2931)
kyeugh votes RedneckPhoenix (#2932)
Tofu votes RedneckPhoenix (#2934)
mewtini votes RedneckPhoenix (#2936)
mewtini votes kyeugh (#2939)
Trebek votes RedneckPhoenix (#2940)
mewtini votes RedneckPhoenix (#2941)
Bluwiikoon votes RedneckPhoenix (#2946)
Trebek votes Santa (#2948)
rari_teh votes Keldeo (#2951)
Trebek votes RedneckPhoenix (#2965)
kyeugh unvotes (#2983)
kyeugh votes RedneckPhoenix (#3075)
IndigoEmmy votes RedneckPhoenix (#3099)
rari_teh unvotes (#3141)
rari_teh votes RedneckPhoenix (#3172)
Herbe votes RedneckPhoenix (#3175)
Herbe unvotes (#3220)
mewtini unvotes (#3222)
rari_teh unvotes (#3225)
Trebek unvotes (#3233)
Herbe votes M Plus 7 (#3236)
mewtini votes RedneckPhoenix (#3297)
RedneckPhoenix votes kyeugh (#3311)
rari_teh unvotes (#3333)
kokorico votes Herbe (#3339)
RedneckPhoenix votes kyeugh (#3411)

 

[Tangrowth]

ISO of RNP

This is a strange one because RNP's ISO is so short, and what is there was a real struggle to try to get anything alignment-indicative out of, especially since he strikes me as a very... unique player, in a good way but it also makes assessments inevitably difficult. I also wanted to look into the circumstances surrounding the claim and wagon formation to try and provide necessary context.

The conclusion I am making is that RNP has a great sense of humor.

Spoiler

wow! i never knew voting at random was such a high level tactic!

what the fuck did seshas do to get a wagon

Spoiler

looking thru the thread again i cannot see anything that would make seshas seem suspicious. why

These two read like potential TMI to me.

Spoiler

sorry i'm late

i jailed emmy, so emmy is either mafia or was targetted by mafia, if the vigkill went thru

Spoiler

i jailed stryke first bc it was funny and then i jailed kyeugh outta spite.

Spoiler

blocks and protects

Spoiler

's why i hypocleared kyeugh but then i thought "well, she might be a different mafia role" and un-cleared

Spoiler

emmy

i'm not smart and emmy's been quiet so i'm just sticking to the one hunch i have

I... have been trying to parse out the exact series of these posts with respect to the claim. The logic is... hard to follow for that of a villager.

The more recent behavior is also sort of a *shrug* I don't really know what's going on? I buy the theory that it is more likely a flailing wolf trying to make things stick than the other way around, but other opinions are welcome. I wish I could have come to some sort of behavioral conclusion that helped more.

 

[Tangrowth]

That updated vote tally is a godsend.

I need to go back and see why koko is voting Herbe, I don't recall that.

 

[kyeugh]

That updated vote tally is a godsend.

I need to go back and see why koko is voting Herbe, I don't recall that.

good starting place:

Cats (2019) Mafia

I mean, I see what like Rari is saying about consensus-y-ness, and maybe my own reads are too consensus given that I am sort of in the consensus POE, but... I feel like given the Ultracool weirdness this mafia team seems somewhat unconcerned with their people dying, in general? That actually...

forums.dragonflycave.com

 

[Trebek]

god idk what’s happening anymore but i also don’t want to get to EoD without voting so i guess i just have to Think ™ more

 

[Tangrowth]

That updated vote tally is a godsend.

I need to go back and see why koko is voting Herbe, I don't recall that.

good starting place:

Cats (2019) Mafia

I mean, I see what like Rari is saying about consensus-y-ness, and maybe my own reads are too consensus given that I am sort of in the consensus POE, but... I feel like given the Ultracool weirdness this mafia team seems somewhat unconcerned with their people dying, in general? That actually...

forums.dragonflycave.com

Much appreciated!

 

[rari_teh]

These two read like potential TMI to me.

I don’t see it

I made a post some time ago that tentatively explains in less knotty terms what rnp is saying, i’ll see if i can find it so that i can quote it to you

 

[RNP]

kyeugh is controlling the thread again shoutouts

 

[qenya]

That updated vote tally is a godsend.

I need to go back and see why koko is voting Herbe, I don't recall that.

tl;dr: role distribution doesn't make sense if both RNP and Herbe are telling the truth, and imo wolf!Herbe is more likely than wolf!RNP

evidently I'm not going to convince the rest of town, but everyone seems to agree that if RNP flips green tonight Herbe ought to be the next lynch or vigkill, so I'm cool with that ig

 

[rari_teh]

@M Plus 7:

if town, he genuinely believed in D2 that she could be either cop or mafia, so he jailed her so that she couldn’t kill or be killed. since there was no mafia kill last night, he deduced that she could be the don and voted for her

 

[Keldeo]

Hey hey, gonna eat something and then be here!

MP7 can you walk through the town RNP and mafia RNP mindsets/logic that you see there for me?

god idk what’s happening anymore but i also don’t want to get to EoD without voting so i guess i just have to Think ™ more

same lol the x hours of sleep didn’t really help

 

[RNP]

cant wait for AC mafia when i'm a roleblocker and get lynched by a kyeugh wagon again

 

[kyeugh]

That updated vote tally is a godsend.

I need to go back and see why koko is voting Herbe, I don't recall that.

tl;dr: role distribution doesn't make sense if both RNP and Herbe are telling the truth, and imo wolf!Herbe is more likely than wolf!RNP

evidently I'm not going to convince the rest of town, but everyone seems to agree that if RNP flips green tonight Herbe ought to be the next lynch or vigkill, so I'm cool with that ig

big agree on the second part