• Welcome to The Cave of Dragonflies forums, where the smallest bugs live alongside the strongest dragons.

    Guests are not able to post messages or even read certain areas of the forums. Now, that's boring, don't you think? Registration, on the other hand, is simple, completely free of charge, and does not require you to give out any personal information at all. As soon as you register, you can take part in some of the happy fun things at the forums such as posting messages, voting in polls, sending private messages to people and being told that this is where we drink tea and eat cod.

    Of course I'm not forcing you to do anything if you don't want to, but seriously, what have you got to lose? Five seconds of your life?

ASB Halloween Mafia: Day 1

Who should die today?

  • Icalasari

    Votes: 6 24.0%

  • turbler

    Votes: 19 76.0%

  • EvilCrazyMonkey

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    25
Status
Not open for further replies.
People stole my speculations... D:
And yes, WUE was killed by revenge because two wishes would not cause strangulation.

I say turbler because s/he posted some random fact that should be painfully obvious to anyone that read the rules. I'm not going to nominate him/her yet; I'm just listening to other possiblities.
 
It's more like "if we've got nothing else we should kill the person who posts the most useless things" imo, although I'm not entirely sure that's better than going after the people who don't talk at all. Actually it probably is better because they could be trying to lie low, not bring any attention to themselves, and hope everyone forgets about them during discussions. We'll probably end up losing an innocent, but theoretically if we have to lose an innocent it's best to lose one that contributes nothing to discussion anyways.

Just that this tactic can end up filling the thread with useless "hi guys I exist" posts which also contribute nothing, and well, what is there to say at this point?


Also for MD(R) to win, it must be on the Death Queue at night at one point, and at some point after that be executed during the day. Executing MD(R) now, when it probably hasn't transformed, would be best, sure, but is there any real way of figuring it out?
 
Oh wait, disregard my last post. I thought turbler was blatantly stating a fact when s/he was in fact saying that we need to execute MDR before it kills us. In fact, it wouldn't be activated because the mafia was aimed towards Kratos, which wasn't MDR because s/he actually died. In fact, Kratos was one of the rivals. We also know that WUE is neither mafia nor one of the rivals.
 
Damn, how is one supposed to figure out anything at this point in the game?

>.> In order to get people to slip up defending themselves or the nomination, I am going to nominate Kusarigamatchi. That way, if he is mafia, he should hopefully slip up while defending himself, or even better, somebody else slips up trying to defend him. If nobody slips up though, I will retract my nomination tomorrow
 
I nominate Icalasari.

Your only post is very suspicious. Let me explain why.
You have one post, and in it, you put up a nomination without real reason. I mean, it's the first day and we have no leads whatsoever; you come by and say someone might slip up. As of now, no one has proof to defend themselves, so every single person here is a sitting duck. And you also just happen to, by coincidence (imagine that!), nominate the person that has contributed the most to the conversation.

tl;dr Icalasari nominated the person that has contributed the most without true reason in his first and only post.
 
My defence:

I nominated him so that people would begin to nominate one another, to try to force slip ups. If somebody is in the mafia, then they will likely panic and make some sort of mistake in their posts, leading to the evidence stacking up against them. I nominated Kusarigamatchi randomly, without rhyme or reason, as at this point, we have no real rhyme or reason that tells us which member belongs to which group
 
Alright, Mafia! Now, let's see- Woah, 2 people are dead already?

I don't really have much to say right now, but I'm going with Icalasari, because Kusari is a smart person and could help a /lot/ during later parts of the game, when we have more to go on than "Hey, let's lynch ___".
Also for the reasons that EvilCrazyMonkey has stated. x9
 
I second the nomination of Icalasari.

It's not the fact that you nominated randomly that stands odd to me; it's the fact that you did so early. Generally, random nominations are made towards the end of the day and there's nothing to go by. They also usually target people who haven't posted much, unlike Kusari.
 
o.o; I obviously did not think this through...

I withdraw my nomination

^^ Well, it was worth a try. I just wanted to get somebody to slip up, is all
 
You know, the bad thing about doing this online is that it's hard for anyone to slip up. They can look over their post, edit it, tailor it to their needs...which makes things a lot more difficult for mafia finders.
 
>.> Look, I was just trying to get somebody to slip up and accidentally let out that they are mafia, alright?
 
turbler said:
first of all the "whismical" music dragon character must be executed lest he level the place then the mafia there-after.
Click to expand...
sertinajii said:
If we try to execute Music Dragon(r), then we all die. And Music Dragon(r) wins. The end!

Besides, we don't even know who he is. o.o
Click to expand...

Turbler is something, now that I think about it. Turbler's either Music Dragon (R), thinking / knowing that she's in her real form or whatever, and wants us to execute her so that she can win the game, OR she's the mafia and immediately is trying to change the subject from finding the mafia.

Or, of course, she might just be posting for the hell of it, but I'm leaning towards her being a twisted mafia member or Music Dragon (R).

Upon this evidence, I NOMINATE TURBLER!
 
You might be on to something, Blaziking, though Music Dragon(r) has to be in his/her unactivated form right now. Unfortunately, even if turbler is Music Dragon, we won't be able to tell since she'll be displayed as an innocent. I'm not seconding this nomination (yet), but it does have some merit. Just don't forget that she might just be posting 'for the hell of it'. Turbler is new to this, after all.
 
I'm pretty sure of Icalasari's innocence right now, but Turbler strikes me as suspicious, especially due to the evidence that Blaziking posted. Therefore, I second Turbler's nomination.

EDIT: Actually, there's one chance that Music Dragon(R) could be in his/her evil form: if there were crossed wishes. Right? So we can't be too risky. I still uphold my nomination though. :/
 
Just posting to say I'm here, and all that.

I'm a bit suspicious of turbler, but refraining from nomination for now.
 
Involuntary Twitch said:
EDIT: Actually, there's one chance that Music Dragon(R) could be in his/her evil form: if there were crossed wishes. Right? So we can't be too risky. I still uphold my nomination though. :/
Click to expand...

Crossed wishes would kill MDR; only the mafia activated eir evil form.

Still suspecting Icalasari, though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom