Re: Reverse Mafia [N2]
It seems to me like you usually say at least something. Just a little bit suspicious in my opinion. :/
Sometimes people suddenly have nothing to say! I haven't seen Glace playing, though, so it might be suspicious.
Also vanilla people can definitely have a lot to say, as Eifie said, so that's not really a reason!
Um, I don't know if it would be better to go for someone who generally doesn't contribute to discussion or for someone who might but hasn't even been online and might not be online for a while (on the other hand, maybe ey could be). This would be an easier decision if I knew anything about how Bobino plays mafia, I guess. (does anyone?)
I'd prefer someone who generally doesn't contribute, I guess! I kind of doubt Bobino will show up (because that would be convenient), but regardless that's a mystery! And there are enough other reasons to lynch not-Bobino, anyway.
Good point. Although it doesn't get rid of the possibility that he could be a powerless innocent lackey or a role of that sort, him not being around is a good reason not to kill him.
I think that since Glace and Superbird have posted, those were the only two inactives left. Should someone take his place, or should we not take the risk and at least avoid killing someone who contributes?
I'd rather let someone take Bobino's place; I guess that's a bit riskier, but then maybe we'll actually be doing something useful, so that would be good. We can't stall lynching someone potentially useful forever, so maybe it's best to try it out now when we have enough people to afford it.
Since he's not helping us either, lynching him would be neutral. If we decide to lynch someone else, there is a chance they will be mafia, there is a chance they will be useful, and in any case they will be someone who contributes. If Bobino turns out to be mafia, the mafia can win one turn sooner if we don't end up killing him, and the town can have killed all the other mafia and still not have won. We will never have any more reason to kill him than we do now (well, unless no one dies a couple of nights days in a row) and we have an extra lynch we have to use up. And if he's scum, don't expect the mafia to take care of him. It seems like Hiikaru is proposing a random lynch, and that doesn't sound like a good idea to me.
Of course I'm proposing a random lynch! What else
can we do, we don't actually have information! Lynching Bobino is also essentially "random" - we don't know for sure ey's good to lynch, just that ey isn't contributing.
Lynching any other inactive person is just as random, only with the chance that they might be a problem role. If Bobino's innocent, then
even if ey becomes don, ey can't do anything, because ey doesn't even log in to submit day-actions. Ey can't hurt us! Ey's not a problem role.
So you're right that there are definitely some pros to lynching Bobino (and cons for anyone else), but I'm kind of more concerned with the fact that lynching em won't get rid of a problem person, but lynching someone else
might. I understand that a neutral lynch is good, sure! But I don't really want to, it isn't particularly useful!
Which is why I guess I'm going to also vote for
Glace?
