Werewolf [Townies Win]

[Chief Zackrai]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Well Coroxon, it's a little too early for crazy theories, isn't it? That might be why people want to lynch you. You're speculating on too little, and it's suspicious.

 

[Coroxn]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Normally I would agree with you but no one else has claimed Inspector so we have no real reason no to trust KR-9. That and the whole plan kind of sounds really suspicious. But this is me.

So by that logic I say Coroxon

How does this incriminate me at all? I never said KR-9 was mafia, I said we should check by killing Glace, whom we have no reason whatsover to trust or distrust.

Edit:I just completely incriminated myself basted on Sizzie's ninja post, didn't I? It matters not. I don't really think my theories are crazy. Or plural, even. Lynch Glace, and then we see if Rk-9 is truly an inspector or not.

 

[Zero Moment]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

How does this incriminate me at all? I never said KR-9 was mafia, I said we should check by killing Glace, whom we have no reason whatsover to trust or distrust.

It completely incriminates you. You don't make a plan to check one unsuspicious player's alignment by trying to get an even less suspicious player lynched.
That's not how you play The Game. You just lost it.

Coroxn

Ι
Ι
V​

 

[Phantom]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

The Game. You just lost it.

.... I hate you LS99, so much, EVERY TIME I come on TCoD I swear somehow you make me lose.

I guess I go with Coroxn.

 

[Zapi]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Eh, in AniChoice Mafia we all lynched Coroxn 'cause he was acting suspicious, and he turned out innocent. But things could be different here, so. Coroxn.

 

[Coroxn]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Wow, you guys are going to feel so silly :D. No hard feelings, I promise.

 

[Zero Moment]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Wow, you guys are going to feel so silly :D. No hard feelings, I promise.

...I don't think we'll particularly care what you flip as. As long as the lynched is inactive or particularly scummy, it doesn't really matter.

 

[Glace]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Uh, Coroxn. Not wanting to roleclaim on the first day seems logical in my opinion. And seeing as how half of the roleclaims are vanilla and only one confirmed... well, yeah (remember that the confirmed vanilla is dead).

So yeah voting Coroxn.

Man, I should really learn to shut up. Every time I start talking in a Mafia game, people start voting for me. Why? What is it about me that screams mafia? It's my long words, isn't it...
Anyway, Light, You're Kira! Even Glace himself said that me claiming to be a mafia means I'm a townie, so logically, he wouldn't want to claim townie because he's worried no one would believe him.

... What? Nowhere in my post did I state that. You are clearly speculating here.

Listen, feel free to lynch me. But need I remind you, killing me will reveal me, and me alone. Killing Glace will also reveal RK-9. And aside from Light's reasoning, which rested on Glace being a doctor but not admitting it, the only argument against me is Glace's. Which was that I claimed to be a townie. Lots of people claimed to be a townie, Glace, why do I get such priority?

You voted against me. You got my vote because of that and your sudden theory. I don't really see what's confusing here.

Make you a deal. Lynch Glace, and if he turns out innocent, even I'll vote for myself.

Light, remember the reasons for voting for me?

"Glace not wanting to roleclaim means he's probably going to claim something other than townsperson."

No. Even Glace himself said that me claiming to be a townie means I'm a townie, so logically, he wouldn't want to claim townie because he's worried no one would believe him.

Once again, nowhere in my post did I say that.

"If he were doctor there probably wouldn't be any reason to ever say so."

Yeah, that's right. Mafia would target him. But if he were an inspector when someone else had claimed to be, or a mafia member, there wouldn't be any reason to ever say so either. Claiming he's a doctor has little justification.

"So it would make sense that the mafia want to get rid of him."

Unless the mafia are like me, and they don't think not roleclaiming means insteant doctorate. And you are saying I'm mafia, so, no.

Most of your argument is either theory or speculation.

 

[Phantom]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

I feel bad if Coroxn is innocent, but his speculations aren't helping us at all, so it won't be a loss.

 

[Superbird]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Unless Superbird specifically states that there aren't sanities.

The King slammed his scepter upon hearing the comment, and at once the entire room fell silent. "Well," he said, making everyone nervous, "I would argue that ALL of you are insane; but I do not think that any of you is unsane enough to do anything stupid. As much as I HATE to say this, all of you are perfectly sane." Then, he slammed his Scepter again. The room remained silent. Moments passed. Then, "GET BACK TO YOUR DISCUSSION, YOU STUPID IGNORANT FOOLS!"

 

[Phantom]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

O_o, someone get that guy a sammich. So I say let's do a final tally.

Your Grace! High Lord and Protector of the Realm, King Superbird, I, Phantom, a lowly citizen, vote that Ser Coroxn be taken to the gallows!

 

[Light]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

he wouldn't want to claim townie because he's worried no one would believe him.

Why would he be afraid no one would believe him when so many other people have also claimed townie? He would be just another townie-claimer who happened to have been cleared by an inspector claimer.

Claiming he's a doctor has little justification.

Not saying he's doctor. I said there would be no reason to claim doctor, so the doctor would probably claim townsperson. There are a lot of other possible roles, if malevolent (like alien or terrorist) or unimportant.

 

[Phantom]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Why would he be afraid no one would believe him when so many other people have also claimed townie? He would be just another townie-claimer who happened to have been cleared by an inspector claimer.

We aren't lynching because he's claiming townie. We're lynching him because he's making odd assumptions and creating suspicions when none need to be made. If he really is a townie it may be we'd be better off without him.

Not saying he's doctor. I said there would be no reason to claim doctor, so the doctor would probably claim townsperson. There are a lot of other possible roles, if malevolent (like alien or terrorist) or unimportant.

... We know this already... It's common sense. He isn't an activated alien, so if he is the alien, poof, we're good, no more alien. And if he's terrorist, we'll he'd have blown up by now.

 

[Karkat Vantas]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Let's lynch Glace. If he turns out to be Mafia, then we'll lynch KR-9, because we know he was lying.

(Sorry Glace, but I'm a logical person, and this is logical.).

And the best part, KR-9? Even if Glace turns out to be innocent, you're still not in the clear. It's entirely possible that you knew someone would suggest this, or picked a random person to say was not mafia. Basically, if we lynch Glace and he's Mafia, RK-9 is screwed. But if we lynch Glace and he's innocent, RK-9 still may be guilty.

So, I vote Glace, for the above reasons. Oh, and by the way, I'm townie. Boring, but hey.

Thoughts?

If KR-9 was Mafia, he would not need to "pick a random person to say was not mafia". If he is a mafia member, he knows who the mafia are, and by process of elimination he knows who the innocents are. He is not going to "screw up"; in effect, by lynching anyone KR-9 claims is innocent, you are more or less killing confirmed innocents.

You may be scum. You may not be scum. However, one thing is certain, Coroxn-- you sure don't think things through.

 

[Phantom]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

You may be scum. You may not be scum. However, one thing is certain, Coroxn-- you sure don't think things through.

And therefore are not a good ally to have in the first place. We may be safer with you gone.

 

[Mai]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Let's lynch Glace. If he turns out to be Mafia, then we'll lynch KR-9, because we know he was lying.

(Sorry Glace, but I'm a logical person, and this is logical.).

And the best part, KR-9? Even if Glace turns out to be innocent, you're still not in the clear. It's entirely possible that you knew someone would suggest this, or picked a random person to say was not mafia. Basically, if we lynch Glace and he's Mafia, RK-9 is screwed. But if we lynch Glace and he's innocent, RK-9 still may be guilty. (THEN WHY WOULD YOU SUGGEST THIS?!)

So, I vote Glace, for the above reasons. Oh, and by the way, I'm townie. Boring, but hey.

Thoughts?

Yeah no. Wtf?

Everyone jumped on this, and for good reason. I had to leave almost immediately after you posted and couldn't reply, so sorry I'm sort of just bandwagoning.

Coroxn. Why? Because you're saying that we should lynch a confirmed innocent to confirm another innocent, and also saying that that if the confirmed innocent is innocent then it has no effect on whether RK-9 is mafia.

However, I do have a word about RK-9: I can remember him fakeclaiming inspector a lot. And I remember he confirmed mafia members as innocent first! (Which is a Bad Idea, in my opinion.) Honestly, I sort of doubt his claim more than I would normally. However, I suspect you a lot more and you're being highly illogical. Doubting the inspector is fine! I do too.

This isn't the way to go about proving him, though. And if anyone wants to counterclaim (which seems unlikely at this point!), that would.

Sorry if this is rude.

 

[Wargle]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

My brain hurts I think I'm going to go insane hearing all the arguing on day one god I can't take it

Wargle get me the heck outta here

 

[RK-9]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Yeah first time I fakeclaimed I was an idiot but I'm serious; I be inspector

 

[Phantom]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

My brain hurts I think I'm going to go insane hearing all the arguing on day one god I can't take it

Wargle get me the heck outta here

Wait, what?

 

[Zero Moment]

Re: Werewolf [Day 1]

Wait, what?

I think she's just confused about all the arguing and going AGGGHH