Forum Revival TV Tropes Mafia Revival - D7

[kyeugh]

lol HANG THEM IN TOWN SQUARE
i mean this in the best way but this reads more to me like inexperienced floundering than scummy
like if we assume indigo doesn't have a solid idea what she's doing/is easily convince/is just trying to vibe (and i think this is a reasonable assumption regardless of alignment), i think her behavior adds up as town
as scum i expect she'd have her partners reigning her in a bit

 

[mewtini]

ehhhhhhhh
I'm not as confident of this anymore tbh
ftr here's the entire progression

i agree that it's weird but i very honestly can't tell if it's AI or just excited!emmy

if she were mafia wouldn't she have kept pushing mist, having known that mist wasn't mafia? or am i missing something ... oh. are you thinking that mafia wondered about mist being outgroup?

 

[Butterfree]

Vote count, with the shiny new update to the vote script that actually links the posts instead of just having a post number:

Spoiler: Full vote history

mewtini votes Flora
Herbe votes Flora
Mr. Ultracool votes Flora
mewtini unvotes
Ottercopter votes Herbe
kyeugh votes Herbe
IndigoEmmy votes Herbe
Panini votes Herbe
mewtini votes Herbe

Spoiler: Active votes

Herbe votes Flora
IndigoEmmy votes Herbe
Mr. Ultracool votes Flora
Ottercopter votes Herbe
Panini votes Herbe
kyeugh votes Herbe
mewtini votes Herbe

Vote counts:
Herbe (5) (IndigoEmmy, Ottercopter, Panini, kyeugh, mewtini)
Flora (2) (Herbe, Mr. Ultracool)
No vote (3) (Flora, serimachi, Seshas)

 

[mewtini]

would it be possible to keep the post numbers in, alongside the links? i like being able to look at how much time passes between votes :')

 

[Zori]

lol HANG THEM IN TOWN SQUARE
i mean this in the best way but this reads more to me like inexperienced floundering than scummy
like if we assume indigo doesn't have a solid idea what she's doing/is easily convince/is just trying to vibe (and i think this is a reasonable assumption regardless of alignment), i think her behavior adds up as town
as scum i expect she'd have her partners reigning her in a bit

fair
I just say emmy clearing Mist here then hopping back on in full force as soon as he came back on the table

 

[Zori]

ehhhhhhhh
I'm not as confident of this anymore tbh
ftr here's the entire progression

i agree that it's weird but i very honestly can't tell if it's AI or just excited!emmy

if she were mafia wouldn't she have kept pushing mist, having known that mist wasn't mafia? or am i missing something ... oh. are you thinking that mafia wondered about mist being outgroup?

I don't see what Mafia!Emmy thinks she gains by continuing to push a seemingly confirmed Cop

 

[mewtini]

i guess i don't mean 'push' so much as i don't think w!emmy would suddenly try to keep the cop alive and go so far as to say "they're not mafia"

 

[Zori]

I mean, if the cop suddenly claims, it makes sense as mafia to stop pushing them if you think they aren't getting lynched because of their claim
nightkills are always an option to off people as well

 

[mewtini]

I just say emmy clearing Mist here then hopping back on in full force as soon as he came back on the table

oh i didn't totally read everything in detail, i see what you mean now. i'm still thinking it sounds like flailing?

either way, i don't think that there's a high chance that emmy and herbe are wolves at the same time

 

[Butterfree]

would it be possible to keep the post numbers in, alongside the links? i like being able to look at how much time passes between votes :')

Unfortunately this could only happen if for each vote post I noted down both the post number and the link, or if I added some sort of scraping thing to it that'd actually visit the link and find the post number, both of which are way more trouble than they're worth.

 

[IndigoClaudia]

excited!emmy

 

[mewtini]

I mean, if the cop suddenly claims, it makes sense as mafia to stop pushing them if you think they aren't getting lynched because of their claim
nightkills are always an option to off people as well

reading through the thread, i think a slightly weirder/more abrupt juncture is her "mist is very very suspicious" 4261 -> her reading that mist is claiming 3p two posts later -> her backing up mist with "they're not mafia" in 4266. i also think that still seems like a confused/flailing townie and i'd (hope) that as mafia, the process you're describing would have happened in a less weird way; what she did still didn't like, sway many opinions, i'd say

 

[IndigoClaudia]

lol HANG THEM IN TOWN SQUARE
i mean this in the best way but this reads more to me like inexperienced floundering than scummy
like if we assume indigo doesn't have a solid idea what she's doing/is easily convince/is just trying to vibe (and i think this is a reasonable assumption regardless of alignment), i think her behavior adds up as town
as scum i expect she'd have her partners reigning her in a bit

yeah but what if you're my mafia buddy and you're only saying this to make me seem less supsicious!?
(that probably isn't helping my case, huh?)

 

[mewtini]

 

[IndigoClaudia]

Indeed, Mewtini.

 

[IndigoClaudia]

Anyway. In my defense, i was just being exited and hyper, and i was a townie :3

 

[IndigoClaudia]

Anyway. In my defense, i was just being exited and hyper, and i was a townie :3

And i still am a townie!

 

[IndigoClaudia]

so yeah also i'm really gullible so I 100% believed everything mist said, and most turned out to be true.

 

[Herbe]

Before I kick the bucket, I want to gather some Fun Quotes to laugh at with y'all :) (House showing was postponed for a couple days)
See y'all in a couple minutes

 

[mewtini]

oh yeah

w!herbe cements inno!seri given that post-boq death discussion about seri that he drove (and that rari/i were talking during)
oh god. i remember skylar saying it felt like a wolf was steering it...... F